Before a Wearable May Claim Cognitive Stress: A Three-Quantity Measurement Checklist
Wrist research and consumer pipelines often treat elevated heart rate or skin conductance as evidence of psychological strain, a practice documented across ambulatory stress surveys and laboratory affect studies. That habit confuses constructs psychophysiology has long kept apart: seated cognitive/psychosocial demand versus physical exertion. This paper asks what a measurement model must clear if the claim is specifically cognitive. We audit a public PhysioNet induced-stress and structured-exercise feature matrix (100 sessions; 41 participants; STRESS, AEROBIC, ANAEROBIC), complement it with WESAD and electrodermal/physiological-computing standards, and define three quantities with explicit pass criteria: a temporal eligibility ratio R_t/s, an exertion-control effect-size ratio R_d on named features with 95% confidence intervals, and an exploratory person-wise leave-one-participant-out (LOPO) check. Under a frozen Random Forest and keyword contract, temporal-keyword features hold 22.9% of top-30 importance (R_t/s=0.30). For heart-rate trend slope, stress-versus-aerobic d=-1.53 (95% CI [-2.08,-0.99]) while aerobic-versus-anaerobic d=-0.26 (95% CI [-0.76,0.23]), so point R_d=5.80 (session bootstrap 95% CI [1.75,106], very wide). Pooled LOPO accuracy is 0.76 (participant-bootstrap 95% CI [0.67,0.84]) versus stratified session 5-fold 0.76 (SD 0.07). We drop cross-corpus mean-EDA "sign flip" comparisons from the gate because WESAD stress-versus-rest and PhysioNet stress-versus-exercise are not matched contrasts. A cognitive wearable claim that cannot meet the stated criteria remains an arousal claim.
Authors
- Eleanor Finch
- Tom Hughes
- Shreyanka Pokhrel (ORCID: https://orcid.org/0009-0005-1865-1519)
Institutions
- Excelsior Orthopaedics (US)
- Excelsia University College (AU)
- Melbourne Institute of Technology (AU)
- Excelsior College (US)
Publication Details
- Published
- 2026-11-18
- DOI
- https://doi.org/10.33774/coe-2026-pq545
- Primary Topic
- Emotion and Mood Recognition
- Type
- preprint