The Floor Price: Minimum Unit Pricing After the Uprating and the Distribution of a Price Floor in Scotland's Alcohol Market
On 30 September 2024 Scotland raised its minimum unit price for alcohol from 50 to 65 pence, six years after the floor first took effect and after a parliamentary vote that kept a policy otherwise due to lapse under its own sunset clause. Wales followed on 1 October 2026. The uprating is usually discussed as a public health decision, and the evidence for the original floor is usually summarised in a single figure: an estimated 13.4 per cent reduction in deaths wholly attributable to alcohol over its first 32 months. This paper reads the uprating instead as a market intervention, and asks four questions of it that the public health framing tends to set aside. Who pays the higher floor and who gains from it; how much demand leaves the regulated Scottish market for cross-border, online or illicit supply; whether a floor is an adequate substitute for restrictions on marketing; and where the revenue a floor creates actually goes.The analysis draws on the Public Health Scotland evaluation, the Scottish Government's business and regulatory impact assessment for the uprating, as corrected in December 2025, a 2026 model-based appraisal, and mortality and sales series published up to October 2026. It finds that the 65 pence floor is a materially larger intervention than the 50 pence floor was on introduction, binding on an estimated 64 per cent of off-trade alcohol by volume in 2022 against 45 per cent below 50 pence in the year before launch; that the transfer it creates accrues to retailers, chiefly in the off-trade, while modelled alcohol tax receipts fall; that the evidence on cross-border and illicit substitution remains thin rather than reassuring; and that the appraisal on which Parliament voted contained a modelling error that reduced the first-year estimate of deaths averted from 60 to 38 once corrected. None of this makes the case against a floor. It does make the case for indexation in statute, for recovering the retail transfer, and for a higher standard of published correction in the modelling on which price policy now depends.
Authors
- Alan Jenkins (ORCID: https://orcid.org/0009-0001-1445-6813)
Publication Details
- Journal
- Figshare
- Published
- 2026-11-18
- DOI
- https://doi.org/10.6084/m9.figshare.35051635
- Primary Topic
- Global Public Health Policies and Epidemiology
- Type
- preprint