Cement replacement for lagoon-exposed concrete: a TOPSIS decision framework combining strength retention, water absorption, life-cycle carbon, embodied energy, and cost
The partial replacement of cement in concrete exposed to brackish water involves trade-offs between strength, durability, cost, and environmental impact. This study develops a transparent decision framework using TOPSIS to evaluate seven site-mixed 1:1.5:3 concretes from south-western Nigeria: a Portland limestone cement (PLC) control and mixtures containing 5, 10, or 15% cement replacement with waste ceramic tile powder or hydrated lime. Six criteria were considered: 90-day lagoon-exposed compressive strength, strength retention, water absorption, partial life-cycle global warming potential (GWP) covering the included production, construction, and end-of-life stages, embodied energy, and cost based on 2026 Abeokuta prices. Rankings were examined under four weighting scenarios and 10,000 randomly generated weight combinations. Vector-normalised TOPSIS ranked the PLC control first under all four scenarios and in 70% of random simulations; COPRAS produced the same leading result. However, min–max TOPSIS, weighted sum and VIKOR ranked the 15% ceramic tile powder mixture first when carbon or cost was prioritised. Among the replacement mixtures, 5% hydrated lime performed best under equal and performance-led weighting and ranked first in 22% of simulations, supported by improved strength after lagoon exposure. The 15% ceramic tile powder mixture was favoured under carbon- and cost-led weighting but ranked first in only 6% of simulations. Despite reducing cost and GWP per cubic metre by 9% and 11%, respectively, it experienced a 42% reduction in lagoon-exposed strength. The findings demonstrate that single indicators can misrepresent overall suitability and that exposure-related performance should be considered alongside environmental and economic criteria when selecting cement replacements.
Authors
- Solomon Olakunle Oyebisi (ORCID: https://orcid.org/0000-0001-8625-3938)
- Tobit Igba
Institutions
- University of the South Pacific (FJ)
Publication Details
- Journal
- Research Square
- Published
- 2026-11-18
- DOI
- https://doi.org/10.21203/rs.3.rs-11607323/v1
- Primary Topic
- Concrete and Cement Materials Research
- Type
- preprint