NSW Snowy Water Policy

25 years ago the Snowy River was promised water. For 25 years western irrigators have had their water confiscated. So where is it? By Greg Adamson In 2000, the NSW, Victorian and Commonwealth governments promised to restore an average of 212 gigalitres of water annually to the Snowy River, equivalent to 21 per cent of its natural flow. At the same time, they promised that irrigation entitlements in the Murray and Murrumbidgee would not be adversely affected. More than 25 years later, I question whether either commitment has been honoured. Having spent years involved in water issues alongside Murrumbidgee irrigation communities, I have watched governments reduce farmers' access to water while announcing major environmental recovery programmes. In September 2014, NSW Upper House MP Scot MacDonald told Parliament that high-security irrigators had surrendered five per cent of their water without compensation. The 95 per cent allocation rule remains in place today under Clause 40 of the Murrumbidgee Water Sharing Plan. We also know that water recovered from the Murrumbidgee was directed towards restoring the Snowy. In September 2010, NSW Office of Water Commissioner David Harriss confirmed to a parliamentary inquiry that water recovered through the Barren Box Swamp project was being credited towards Snowy River commitments. Yet my analysis of the water releases raises serious questions about whether the promised 212 gigalitres has actually been delivered over the long term. So where is the water? The Snowy River below Jindabyne remains environmentally degraded, while the Upper Murrumbidgee below Tantangara has been deprived of most of its natural flow. Meanwhile, western irrigation communities have spent more than two decades adjusting to reduced water availability. What I find extraordinary is that governments are again considering changes to water arrangements without first providing a complete accounting of what has already been recovered. The original Snowy agreement required continuous audited records of water recovery. Surely those records should establish precisely how much water was recovered, where it came from, how it was allocated and how much was actually released into the Snowy River. They should also establish whether the five per cent reduction imposed on high-security irrigators contributed to environmental water recovery or was retained for other purposes. I want an independent public audit of the original water-sharing decisions, the water entitlements recovered, the infrastructure savings claimed and the actual releases made below Jindabyne. The farmers of the Murrumbidgee and communities of Monaro have a common interest in getting these answers. Governments cannot continue asking rural communities to accept further changes to water arrangements while leaving historical commitments inadequately explained. If the water was recovered, account for it. If it was delivered, demonstrate where and when. If the commitments were not met, explain why. Before governments start talking about taking more water, they should account for what they have already taken.

Authors

Publication Details

Journal
Zenodo (CERN European Organization for Nuclear Research)
Published
2026-11-18
DOI
https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24331434
Primary Topic
Water resources management and optimization
Type
preprint
Controls
|||
ALL TIME
JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
OCT
NOV
preprint

NSW Snowy Water Policy

Gregory Adamson
1 links
Zenodo (CERN European Organization for Nuclear Research)
Water resources management and optimization
preprint

NSW Snowy Water Policy

Gregory Adamson
preprint en

Abstract

25 years ago the Snowy River was promised water. For 25 years western irrigators have had their water confiscated. So where is it? By Greg Adamson In 2000, the NSW, Victorian and Commonwealth governments promised to restore an average of 212 gigalitres of water annually to the Snowy River, equivalent to 21 per cent of its natural flow. At the same time, they promised that irrigation entitlements in the Murray and Murrumbidgee would not be adversely affected. More than 25 years later, I question whether either commitment has been honoured. Having spent years involved in water issues alongside Murrumbidgee irrigation communities, I have watched governments reduce farmers' access to water while announcing major environmental recovery programmes. In September 2014, NSW Upper House MP Scot MacDonald told Parliament that high-security irrigators had surrendered five per cent of their water without compensation. The 95 per cent allocation rule remains in place today under Clause 40 of the Murrumbidgee Water Sharing Plan. We also know that water recovered from the Murrumbidgee was directed towards restoring the Snowy. In September 2010, NSW Office of Water Commissioner David Harriss confirmed to a parliamentary inquiry that water recovered through the Barren Box Swamp project was being credited towards Snowy River commitments. Yet my analysis of the water releases raises serious questions about whether the promised 212 gigalitres has actually been delivered over the long term. So where is the water? The Snowy River below Jindabyne remains environmentally degraded, while the Upper Murrumbidgee below Tantangara has been deprived of most of its natural flow. Meanwhile, western irrigation communities have spent more than two decades adjusting to reduced water availability. What I find extraordinary is that governments are again considering changes to water arrangements without first providing a complete accounting of what has already been recovered. The original Snowy agreement required continuous audited records of water recovery. Surely those records should establish precisely how much water was recovered, where it came from, how it was allocated and how much was actually released into the Snowy River. They should also establish whether the five per cent reduction imposed on high-security irrigators contributed to environmental water recovery or was retained for other purposes. I want an independent public audit of the original water-sharing decisions, the water entitlements recovered, the infrastructure savings claimed and the actual releases made below Jindabyne. The farmers of the Murrumbidgee and communities of Monaro have a common interest in getting these answers. Governments cannot continue asking rural communities to accept further changes to water arrangements while leaving historical commitments inadequately explained. If the water was recovered, account for it. If it was delivered, demonstrate where and when. If the commitments were not met, explain why. Before governments start talking about taking more water, they should account for what they have already taken.

Zenodo (CERN European Organization for Nuclear Research)
Clean water and sanitation
Water resources management and optimization
AI Navigator

Ask Laika to Summarize, Analyze, and Connect papers live on the map.

Summarize Papers & Methodologies

Extract key findings, datasets, and comparative methods across publications.

Benchmark Rankings & Visual Analytics

Rank top research institutions, authors, funders, topics, and journals by Field-Weighted Citation Impact (FWCI) and paper volume with instant charts.

Connect Distant Disciplines

Bridge topological clusters on the map to find hidden collaborative intersections.

Laika access coming soon