An Exploratory Randomized Controlled Study Comparing Effects of Metronome-Cued Versus Yoga Breathing on HRV in Patients with Chronic Pain

Background In a previous study, patients with chronic pain showed increased vagally mediated heart rate variability (VmHRV; the variation in the time between heartbeats driven by the vagus nerve) and positive mood states after 10 minutes of metronome-cued low-inspiration-to-expiration (MC low i/e) breathing. Low i/e can also be achieved with yoga breathing which may be less anxiety producing while improving interoception, than metronome regulated breathing. Bumblebee yoga breathing (BBYB) involves a low i/e ratio with a reduced breathing rate. The present explorative study aimed to determine how BBYB and MC low i/e influence VmHRV in patients with chronic pain. Methods In this, exploratory randomized controlled trial, three hundred and four patients with chronic pain, aged between 20 and 70 years, were randomized into four groups. These were: (i) MC low i/e (with a ratio of 28:72 and 12 breaths/minute), (ii) metronome cued equal i/e breathing (MC equal i/e; with a ratio of 50:50 and 12 breaths/minute), (iii) BBYB, and (iv) spontaneous breathing (SB) act as control. The VmHRV, respiration, blood pressure and global vigor (self-reported energy) and mood states (using the Global Vigor and affect Scale (GVA)) were assessed. The data were analyzed using repeated measures analyses of variance (RM-ANOVA). Results The BBYB group alone achieved a low i/e ratio (attained i/e of 0.34). The MC low i/e group and MC equal i/e group had breath rates of 13.72 and 12.29 BPM, respectively but neither achieved the intended i/e ratio. Natural log of LF power in the HRV series for the low frequency band (0.04-0.15 Hz) (LnLF) was significantly greater during BBYB than during spontaneous breathing as control (SB). Natural log of HF power in the HRV series for the high frequency band (0.15-0.40 Hz)) (LnHF) was significantly higher during the MC low i/e and MC equal i/e breathing compared to SB. Natural log of the root mean square of successive time differences between normal, consecutive heartbeats (LnRMSSD) was significantly higher during the MC low i/e, MC equal i/e, and BBYB compared to SB. Self-reported pain intensity was significantly lower after the MC low i/e and BBYB compared to SB (p < 0.05; in all cases based on RM-ANOVA). Conclusion The results suggest that decreased breath rate in both BBYB and MC low i/e appears to increase VmHRV. Pain was significantly lower after MC low i/e and BBYB compared to SB. Also, BBYB alone demonstrated a low inspiration/exhalation ratio, suggesting that modifying breathing in line with yoga practices may facilitate the transition more easily than MC breathing.

Authors

Publication Details

Journal
Complementary Medicine Research
Published
2026-11-18
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1159/cmr/acfag021
Primary Topic
Heart Rate Variability and Autonomic Control
Type
article
Field-Weighted Citation Impact
0.00
Controls
|||
ALL TIME
JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
OCT
NOV
article

An Exploratory Randomized Controlled Study Comparing Effects of Metronome-Cued Versus Yoga Breathing on HRV in Patients with Chronic Pain

Shirley Telles, Neerja Katare, Sachin Kumar Sharma, Ami Gupta et al.
2 links
Complementary Medicine Research
Heart Rate Variability and Autonomic Control
article

An Exploratory Randomized Controlled Study Comparing Effects of Metronome-Cued Versus Yoga Breathing on HRV in Patients with Chronic Pain

Shirley Telles, Neerja Katare, Sachin Kumar Sharma, Ami Gupta, Acharya Balkrishna
article en

Abstract

Background In a previous study, patients with chronic pain showed increased vagally mediated heart rate variability (VmHRV; the variation in the time between heartbeats driven by the vagus nerve) and positive mood states after 10 minutes of metronome-cued low-inspiration-to-expiration (MC low i/e) breathing. Low i/e can also be achieved with yoga breathing which may be less anxiety producing while improving interoception, than metronome regulated breathing. Bumblebee yoga breathing (BBYB) involves a low i/e ratio with a reduced breathing rate. The present explorative study aimed to determine how BBYB and MC low i/e influence VmHRV in patients with chronic pain. Methods In this, exploratory randomized controlled trial, three hundred and four patients with chronic pain, aged between 20 and 70 years, were randomized into four groups. These were: (i) MC low i/e (with a ratio of 28:72 and 12 breaths/minute), (ii) metronome cued equal i/e breathing (MC equal i/e; with a ratio of 50:50 and 12 breaths/minute), (iii) BBYB, and (iv) spontaneous breathing (SB) act as control. The VmHRV, respiration, blood pressure and global vigor (self-reported energy) and mood states (using the Global Vigor and affect Scale (GVA)) were assessed. The data were analyzed using repeated measures analyses of variance (RM-ANOVA). Results The BBYB group alone achieved a low i/e ratio (attained i/e of 0.34). The MC low i/e group and MC equal i/e group had breath rates of 13.72 and 12.29 BPM, respectively but neither achieved the intended i/e ratio. Natural log of LF power in the HRV series for the low frequency band (0.04-0.15 Hz) (LnLF) was significantly greater during BBYB than during spontaneous breathing as control (SB). Natural log of HF power in the HRV series for the high frequency band (0.15-0.40 Hz)) (LnHF) was significantly higher during the MC low i/e and MC equal i/e breathing compared to SB. Natural log of the root mean square of successive time differences between normal, consecutive heartbeats (LnRMSSD) was significantly higher during the MC low i/e, MC equal i/e, and BBYB compared to SB. Self-reported pain intensity was significantly lower after the MC low i/e and BBYB compared to SB (p < 0.05; in all cases based on RM-ANOVA). Conclusion The results suggest that decreased breath rate in both BBYB and MC low i/e appears to increase VmHRV. Pain was significantly lower after MC low i/e and BBYB compared to SB. Also, BBYB alone demonstrated a low inspiration/exhalation ratio, suggesting that modifying breathing in line with yoga practices may facilitate the transition more easily than MC breathing.

Complementary Medicine Research
Good health and well-being
Heart Rate Variability and Autonomic Control
AI Navigator

Ask Laika to Summarize, Analyze, and Connect papers live on the map.

Summarize Papers & Methodologies

Extract key findings, datasets, and comparative methods across publications.

Benchmark Rankings & Visual Analytics

Rank top research institutions, authors, funders, topics, and journals by Field-Weighted Citation Impact (FWCI) and paper volume with instant charts.

Connect Distant Disciplines

Bridge topological clusters on the map to find hidden collaborative intersections.

Laika access coming soon