Modelling with uncertain and potentially disinformative discharge data: Part II. A GLUE limits-of-acceptability approach to ensemble calibration

The information content of uncertain hydrological data imposes limits on the extent to which a modeller can identify the model structures that most adequately represent an assemblage of real-world states and fluxes. This study demonstrates an ensemble modelling strategy for investigating catchment functioning. It builds on the first paper in this two-part series, where a Generalised Likelihood Uncertainty Estimation approach to specifying limits of acceptability was developed based on propagating the joint effect of uncertainties in precipitation and discharge data on a timestep-by-timestep basis through rainfall–runoff ratio (RRR)-based benchmarks. Here, these a priori defined rejection criteria were used to discriminate among 3.5 million parameter sets within 70 model structures configured using the Framework for Understanding Structural Errors (FUSE) for a data-poor, baseflow-dominated Philippine catchment. Analysis of predictive reliability–precision trade-off and other diagnostics was performed to compare the effectiveness of the conventional limits-of-acceptability definition based on rating curve (RC) uncertainty with that of the proposed RRR-based definition, which also applies an informal likelihood measure designed to downweight the influence of residuals associated with potentially disinformative observations on model conditioning. No model realisations survived the RC-based limits, suggesting that discharge data uncertainty alone may underestimate the effective observational error relevant to calibration. Although both definitions converged on the same dominant mechanisms, the RRR-based definition improved discrimination among tested process representations. Differences in behavioural ensemble composition further illustrate how epistemic uncertainties in data, if unaccounted for, can bias hypothesis-testing inference, raising the risk of Type I or Type II errors.

Authors

Institutions

Publication Details

Published
2026-11-18
DOI
https://doi.org/10.22541/essoar.15012455/v1
Primary Topic
Hydrology and Watershed Management Studies
Type
preprint
Controls
|||
ALL TIME
JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
OCT
NOV
preprint

Modelling with uncertain and potentially disinformative discharge data: Part II. A GLUE limits-of-acceptability approach to ensemble calibration

Tolentino B. Moya, Cherry L. Ringor, Mayzonee V. Ligaray, Richard Cornelio
1 links
Hydrology and Watershed Management Studies
preprint

Modelling with uncertain and potentially disinformative discharge data: Part II. A GLUE limits-of-acceptability approach to ensemble calibration

Tolentino B. Moya, Cherry L. Ringor, Mayzonee V. Ligaray, Richard Cornelio
preprint en

Abstract

The information content of uncertain hydrological data imposes limits on the extent to which a modeller can identify the model structures that most adequately represent an assemblage of real-world states and fluxes. This study demonstrates an ensemble modelling strategy for investigating catchment functioning. It builds on the first paper in this two-part series, where a Generalised Likelihood Uncertainty Estimation approach to specifying limits of acceptability was developed based on propagating the joint effect of uncertainties in precipitation and discharge data on a timestep-by-timestep basis through rainfall–runoff ratio (RRR)-based benchmarks. Here, these a priori defined rejection criteria were used to discriminate among 3.5 million parameter sets within 70 model structures configured using the Framework for Understanding Structural Errors (FUSE) for a data-poor, baseflow-dominated Philippine catchment. Analysis of predictive reliability–precision trade-off and other diagnostics was performed to compare the effectiveness of the conventional limits-of-acceptability definition based on rating curve (RC) uncertainty with that of the proposed RRR-based definition, which also applies an informal likelihood measure designed to downweight the influence of residuals associated with potentially disinformative observations on model conditioning. No model realisations survived the RC-based limits, suggesting that discharge data uncertainty alone may underestimate the effective observational error relevant to calibration. Although both definitions converged on the same dominant mechanisms, the RRR-based definition improved discrimination among tested process representations. Differences in behavioural ensemble composition further illustrate how epistemic uncertainties in data, if unaccounted for, can bias hypothesis-testing inference, raising the risk of Type I or Type II errors.

University of the Philippines Diliman (PH)
Clean water and sanitation
Hydrology and Watershed Management Studies
AI Navigator

Ask Laika to Summarize, Analyze, and Connect papers live on the map.

Summarize Papers & Methodologies

Extract key findings, datasets, and comparative methods across publications.

Benchmark Rankings & Visual Analytics

Rank top research institutions, authors, funders, topics, and journals by Field-Weighted Citation Impact (FWCI) and paper volume with instant charts.

Connect Distant Disciplines

Bridge topological clusters on the map to find hidden collaborative intersections.

Laika access coming soon