A Fair Exchange? How Hartree–Fock Mixing Governs Ruthenium CO2-Photoreduction Models

The description of CO2 coordination and optical excitation in ruthenium pincer complexes depends on the treatment of exchange and correlation. In this work, we compare seven density functionals for the CNC, NCN, and NNN ligand environments, using MP2 geometries and CC2 excitation energies as references. PBE0 and the double hybrids B2PLYP and PBE0-DH preserve the bent Ru–C-bound adduct across all three complexes and both basis sets considered. PBE0 provides the most favorable compromise between structural accuracy and computational cost. In contrast, M06-2X yields nearly linear CO2 and long Ru–C distances for NCN and NNN even with the larger basis set. Additional calculations show that r2SCAN preserves the bent adduct for both complexes, while the inclusion of empirical dispersion corrections does not alter either outcome. Together with the trends across the other functionals, these results provide strong evidence for a substantial role of exact exchange in destabilizing the bent coordination geometry. The excitation energies, however, cannot be explained by the exact-exchange fraction alone. B2PLYP shows the closest agreement with the principal CC2 absorption bands, despite containing more exact exchange than PBE0, and has larger average perturbative double-excitation corrections than PBE0-DH. Agreement in band positions does not ensure agreement in solar-weighted absorption, for which substantial differences remain, particularly for CNC. Interfragment charge-transfer analysis further identifies which excitations transfer electron density toward CO2, although these descriptors do not determine subsequent photocatalytic activity. Our results indicate that the choice of functional should be assessed separately for coordination geometry, optical absorption, and excited-state charge redistribution.

Authors

Institutions

Publication Details

Journal
ACS Omega
Published
2026-11-18
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1021/acsomega.6c08596
Primary Topic
Advanced Chemical Physics Studies
Type
article
Field-Weighted Citation Impact
0.00

Funders

Controls
|||
ALL TIME
JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
OCT
NOV
article

A Fair Exchange? How Hartree–Fock Mixing Governs Ruthenium CO2-Photoreduction Models

Bartłomiej M. Szyja, Robert W. Góra, Jabir Salekhe
ACS Omega
Advanced Chemical Physics Studies
article

A Fair Exchange? How Hartree–Fock Mixing Governs Ruthenium CO2-Photoreduction Models

Bartłomiej M. Szyja, Robert W. Góra, Jabir Salekhe
article en

Abstract

The description of CO2 coordination and optical excitation in ruthenium pincer complexes depends on the treatment of exchange and correlation. In this work, we compare seven density functionals for the CNC, NCN, and NNN ligand environments, using MP2 geometries and CC2 excitation energies as references. PBE0 and the double hybrids B2PLYP and PBE0-DH preserve the bent Ru–C-bound adduct across all three complexes and both basis sets considered. PBE0 provides the most favorable compromise between structural accuracy and computational cost. In contrast, M06-2X yields nearly linear CO2 and long Ru–C distances for NCN and NNN even with the larger basis set. Additional calculations show that r2SCAN preserves the bent adduct for both complexes, while the inclusion of empirical dispersion corrections does not alter either outcome. Together with the trends across the other functionals, these results provide strong evidence for a substantial role of exact exchange in destabilizing the bent coordination geometry. The excitation energies, however, cannot be explained by the exact-exchange fraction alone. B2PLYP shows the closest agreement with the principal CC2 absorption bands, despite containing more exact exchange than PBE0, and has larger average perturbative double-excitation corrections than PBE0-DH. Agreement in band positions does not ensure agreement in solar-weighted absorption, for which substantial differences remain, particularly for CNC. Interfragment charge-transfer analysis further identifies which excitations transfer electron density toward CO2, although these descriptors do not determine subsequent photocatalytic activity. Our results indicate that the choice of functional should be assessed separately for coordination geometry, optical absorption, and excited-state charge redistribution.

ACS Omega
Wrocław University of Science and Technology (PL)
Infrastruktura PL-Grid, Wroclawskie Centrum Sieciowo-Superkomputerowe, Politechnika Wroclawska, Academic Computer Centre Cyfronet, AGH University of Science and Technology
Advanced Chemical Physics Studies
AI Navigator

Ask Laika to Summarize, Analyze, and Connect papers live on the map.

Summarize Papers & Methodologies

Extract key findings, datasets, and comparative methods across publications.

Benchmark Rankings & Visual Analytics

Rank top research institutions, authors, funders, topics, and journals by Field-Weighted Citation Impact (FWCI) and paper volume with instant charts.

Connect Distant Disciplines

Bridge topological clusters on the map to find hidden collaborative intersections.

Laika access coming soon