The Kathāvatthu as the Adversarial Refutation and Axiom-Minimality Engine of the Octonionic Abhidhamma: The Eight-Door Calculus, Heterodox Farkas Certificates, and the Moduli Space of Early Buddhist Schools under Machine Verification

## Abstract In Papers 31 and 32 of Series 2 (`S2-P31` and `S2-P32`), we formalized Book VI (*Yamaka*, "Book of Pairs") and Book III (*Dhātukathā*, "Discussion of Elements") of the Theravāda *Abhidhamma Piṭaka* inside the **Epistemic Life Engine v4.1 (`epistemic_v4.1_harness`)**, establishing machine-verified quantifier discipline across the 31 *bhūmis* and three-valued (*ekadesa*) relational incidence across the **82-*paramattha* / 170-token ultimate reality catalog** ($89\text{ cittas} + 52\text{ cetasikas} + 28\text{ rūpas} + 1\text{ Nibbāna} = 170$) and the **$5\text{ khandhas} + 12\text{ āyatanas} + 18\text{ dhātus} = 35$ ontological containers**. Together with Paper 3 of Series 1 (*Paṭṭhāna*, Book VII), three of the four logical and relational books of the *Abhidhamma Piṭaka* have now been audited. Yet Book V—the ***Kathāvatthu*** ("Points of Controversy", compiled by Ācariya Moggaliputtatissa at the Third Council under Emperor Aśoka, c. 250 BCE)—occupies a unique architectural role: it is the canon's **adversarial axiom-mutation and formal refutation engine**. Where the *Dhātukathā* builds the positive conservation laws and the *Yamaka* audits converse symmetry, the *Kathāvatthu* tests what happens when heterodox schools (Puggalavāda, Sarvāstivāda, Mahāsāṃghika, Andhaka, Mahīśāsaka) mutate a foundational axiom. Applying Guardrail 13 (*The Selective Correspondence Standard*), we select an irreducible **6-controversy spanning basis** from the *Kathāvatthu* that directly stress-tests the load-bearing axioms of Series 1 and Series 2, and submit it to adversarial verification in `epistemic_v4.1_harness`, establishing six principal results: - **Theorem K.I (Formalization of the *Aṭṭhamukha-vāda* Pentad Calculus & Dual-Kernel Audit of the 6 Spanning Controversies).** Formalizing Moggaliputtatissa's 5-step affirmative pentad (*anuloma-pañcaka*) and 5-step rejoinder pentad (*paṭikkhepa-pañcaka*) in both Z3 SMT and an independent zero-Z3 Python evaluator yields 100% agreement across all $2^3 = 8$ propositional truth-table rows (`all_8_truth_table_agree = true`, plus a false-pervasion `SAT` negative control) and across all six spanning controversies (strictly *relative* to the canonical Theravāda axioms; school identifications reflect Buddhaghosa's *Kathāvatthu-aṭṭhakathā*): 1. ***Puggalakathā* (*Kv 1.1*, Puggalavāda):** Every token in $\mathcal{U}_{170}$ / $\mathcal{U}_{82}$ satisfies the exclusive disjunction $\bigl(x \in \bigcup_{i=1}^5 \text{Khandha}_i \wedge \text{saṅkhata}(x)\bigr) \oplus (x = \text{Nibbāna} \wedge \text{asaṅkhata}(x))$; positing an ultimate *puggala* outside both limbs is `UNSAT` (whereas *puggala* as *sammuti-paññatti* supervening on the 5 *khandhas* is `SAT`). 2. ***Parihānikathā* (*Kv 1.2*, Sarvāstivāda / Sammitīya):** Across the 4 path-stages ($10 \to 7 \to 7 \to 5 \to 0$ remaining fetters), *arahatta-magga* ($\mathfrak{T}^{-1}$) zeroes all graded Jordan cohomology obstructions ($H_J^0 \oplus H_J^1 \oplus H_J^2 \oplus H_J^3 = 0$), forcing the non-Hermitian craving drive $\Delta H_{NH}\{\rho\} \equiv 0$; post-Arahant regression (`post_arahant_fetters >= 1`) is `UNSAT`. 3. ***Sabbamatthītikathā* (*Kv 1.6*, Sarvāstivāda Eternalism):** Under the discrete Non-Continuum Calculus (NCC) semigroup $K(\sigma) = e^{-\sigma H_{29}}$, *kāritra* belongs exclusively to the present *khaṇa* (*uppāda–ṭhiti–bhaṅga*); in the early *sabbaṃ atthi* formulation targeted by *Kv 1.6* (prior to the later Vaibhāṣika distinction between persistent *svabhāva* and momentary *kāritra*), substantial coexistence of a past *citta* with a present *citta* violates the rank-1 bottleneck (`total_simultaneous <= 1`, `UNSAT`). 4. ***Anusayakathā* (*Kv 9.4, 11.1, 14.5*, Mahāsāṃghika / Andhaka):** Across $\mathcal{U}_{170}$, all $50/50$ tokens in *saṅkhārakkhandha* are strictly associated with mind (`sankhara_vippayutta_token_count = 0`); the 7 canonical *anusayas* map surjectively onto **6 *akusala cetasikas*** (`lobha, dosa, māna, diṭṭhi, vicikicchā, moha` $\subset \text{saṅkhārakkhandha}$), proving that *citta-vippayutta* / *anārammaṇa anusaya* placed inside *saṅkhārakkhandha* is `UNSAT`. 5. ***Nirodhakathā (Dve Nirodhā) & Ākāsakathā* (*Kv 2.11, Kv 6.2 & Kv 6.6*, Mahīśāsaka / Uttarāpathaka / Andhaka):** In $\mathcal{U}_{170}$, `nibbana:nibbana` ($\ker H_{29}$, $\dim = 1$) is the unique unconditioned reality (`unique_unconditioned_nibbana = true`, rejecting a second *asaṅkhata* cessation substance as debated in *Kv 2.11* / *6.2*), while delimiting `akasa_dhatu` (`pariccheda-rūpa`, *Kv 6.6*) is a conditioned *sukhuma-rūpa* inside `rupakkhandha` at $D_4$ root height $h = \pm 3$. 6. ***Vacībheda-, Cittaṭṭhiti- & Ekacittakkhaṇikā-kathā* (*Kv 2.5, Kv 2.7 & Kv 22.8*, Andhaka / Pubbaseliya):** Across all 89 *cittas* ($10_{\text{pañca}} + 3_{\text{mano}} + 76_{\text{manoviññāṇa}}$), *citta–citta sampayoga* is identically empty (`zero_citta_citta_sampayoga = true`), matching orthogonal Jordan Peirce idempotents $E_i \circ E_j = \delta_{ij} E_i$ ($\operatorname{Tr}(E_i) = 1$, verified numerically in concrete $(3, 3, 8)$ Hermitian $J_3(\mathbb{O})$ arithmetic). Furthermore, `EpistemicProvenanceLedger` enforces `ABSTAIN_UNDERSPECIFIED` when an unqualified *puggala* assertion omits the truth-stratum quantifier (`paramattha` vs. `sammuti-paññatti`). [Tier M1; Tier B1/B2.]- **Theorem K.II (Layer $-1$ Exact Rational Farkas Impossibility Certificates for Heterodox Posits).** Using `AutonomousDeadlockScout` and the zero-Z3 `IndependentUnsatChecker`, we extract exact rational (`Fraction`) Farkas certificates proving the **relative** linear infeasibility of: (a) Puggalavāda's 83rd ultimate *paramattha* reality under 82-*paramattha* closure (`multipliers = (-1, 1, -1, -1, -1, -1; 1)` $\implies 0 \le -1$), (b) Mahāsāṃghika/Andhaka's *citta-vippayutta anusaya* inside 50-factor *saṅkhārakkhandha* ($\implies 0 \le -1$), and (c) Andhaka's simultaneous sensory + mental *citta* concourse under the rank-1 Peirce trace ceiling ($\implies 0 \le -1$), while Filter A rejects unanchored debate-verbosity compromises in 0 SMT cycles. Volatile `latency_ms` fields and unordered Z3/set core lists are canonicalized prior to integrity hashing. [Tier M1; Tier B1.]- **Theorem K.III (Layer 2b Three-Span Categorical Pushout & Sectarian-Gematria Passenger Rejection).** Fusing `Ontology_82_Paramattha_Domain`, `Cohomology_Anusaya_Pahana_Domain`, and `Temporal_Vithi_Bottleneck_Domain` in `MultiSpanColimitEngine` with strictly homogeneous variable types (separating *paramattha* category counts, *saṃyojana* fetter counts, and *khaṇa* counts via the $14 = 6_{\text{anusaya-base}} + 8_{\text{concomitant}}$ *akusala cetasika* decomposition and stoichiometric Arahant bounds) passes all five `PostPushoutVerifier` hardening gates: pre-pinned offline `ChallengeAxiomLock` SHA-256 (`f84339a616e28bc5...`), pure-Python AST witness replay (`n_paramattha_cat = 82, n_arahant_residual_fetter = 0, n_arahant_residual_akusala_cat = 0, n_rupa_life_submoments = 51`), $3/3$ Farkas-verified heterodox mutation kills (`KS-KV-1`, `KS-KV-2`, `KS-KV-3`), `assumed_count = 0` with `net_free_dof = 0`, and causal synergy $\Phi_{\text{syn}} = 1.0$. Appending an uncoupled `E8_Sectarian_Gematria_Slot` (`e8_sectarian_root_slot` $\in [1, 248]$) is rejected fail-closed by Gate 5 (`TRIVIAL_JUXTAPOSITION_PASSENGER_DOMAINS`, $\Phi_{\text{syn}} = 0.0$). [Tier M2; Tier B2.]- **Theorem K.IV (Relative Orthogonal Axiom-Blocking & $6 \times 6$ School Moduli Space).** Encoding the coupled Z3 integer conservation and transition system over canonical counts $(A_1, \dots, A_6)$ and testing single-axiom relaxations against the six paired heterodox theses $(T_1, \dots, T_6)$ demonstrates an exact bifurcation governed by the Sarvāstivāda *svabhāva/kāritra* split: (a) when $A_6$ is scoped to instantaneous present-moment simultaneous *cittas* (`n_present_citta == 1`), the coupled integer **Axiom-Relaxation Matrix** is the exact $6 \times 6$ identity $\mathbf{M}_{\text{relax}} = \mathbf{I}_6$; whereas (b) when $A_6$ constrains *all* substantially existing *cittas* without separating *atthibhāva* from present *kāritra* (`n_present_citta + n_nonpresent_atthi_citta <= 1`, matching §3.3), dropping $A_3$ alone leaves $T_3$ **still `UNSAT`**, isolating the genuine $A_3 \leftrightarrow A_6$ coupling. This matrix certifies **relative orthogonal blocking among the six canonical rules**, complemented by live concrete $(3, 3, 8)$ Hermitian NumPy $J_3(\mathbb{O})$ checks (`peirce_idempotent_max_err = 0.0`, `jordan_fundamental_identity_max_err = 2.22e-16`, `peirce_associator_norm = 0.6287 > 0.1`). [Tier M1; Tier B2/B3.]- **Theorem K.V (Layer 6 SAT Manifold & Standalone Zero-Z3 DPLL + Resolution Refutations).** A 10-variable canonical *Kathāvatthu* CNF yields exactly **20** admissible Boolean profiles (matching exhaustive $2^{10} = 1024$ enumeration). Using `IndependentUnsatChecker.verify_cnf_unsat()`, we emit four standalone zero-Z3 **DPLL + explicit Resolution Refutation proofs (`VALID_RESOLUTION_REFUTATION`)** refuting Kv 1.1 (*Puggalavāda*), Kv 1.2 (*Parihāni*), Kv 1.6 (*Sarvāstivāda* non-present efficacy), and Kv 9.4 (*Mahāsāṃghika* disembodied mental factor). [Tier M1; Tier B1/B2.]- **Proposition K.VI (Worldling Indistinguishability & 3-Query Boundary Identifiability).** Evaluating the four competing school hypotheses (`H1_THERAVADA_CANONICAL`, `H2_PUGGALAVADA_AVAKTAVYA`, `H3_SARVASTIVADA_TRIKALA_PARIHANI`, `H4_ANDHAKA_VIPPAYUTTA_ANUSAYA`) in `ActiveRuleDiscoverer` against the canonical Theravāda target profile proves that ordinary present-moment worldling (*puthujjana*) probes leave all four schools macroscopically indistinguishable (`AMBIGUOUS_HYPOTHESIS_CLASS`), whereas Moggaliputtatissa's three targeted boundary probes (`P_KV1_1_KHANDHA_EXHAUSTIVENESS`, `P_KV1_2_ARAHANT_TRIKALA_BOUNDARY`, `P_KV9_4_ANUSAYA_SAMPAYOGA_BOUNDARY`) uniquely identify `H1_THERAVADA_CANONICAL` in 3 queries. [Tier M2; Tier B3.]

Authors

Publication Details

Journal
Zenodo (CERN European Organization for Nuclear Research)
Published
2026-11-18
DOI
https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24334278
Primary Topic
Indian and Buddhist Studies
Type
preprint
Controls
|||
ALL TIME
JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
OCT
NOV
preprint

The Kathāvatthu as the Adversarial Refutation and Axiom-Minimality Engine of the Octonionic Abhidhamma: The Eight-Door Calculus, Heterodox Farkas Certificates, and the Moduli Space of Early Buddhist Schools under Machine Verification

Myo Oo
4 links
Zenodo (CERN European Organization for Nuclear Research)
Indian and Buddhist Studies
preprint

The Kathāvatthu as the Adversarial Refutation and Axiom-Minimality Engine of the Octonionic Abhidhamma: The Eight-Door Calculus, Heterodox Farkas Certificates, and the Moduli Space of Early Buddhist Schools under Machine Verification

Myo Oo
preprint en

Abstract

## Abstract In Papers 31 and 32 of Series 2 (`S2-P31` and `S2-P32`), we formalized Book VI (*Yamaka*, "Book of Pairs") and Book III (*Dhātukathā*, "Discussion of Elements") of the Theravāda *Abhidhamma Piṭaka* inside the **Epistemic Life Engine v4.1 (`epistemic_v4.1_harness`)**, establishing machine-verified quantifier discipline across the 31 *bhūmis* and three-valued (*ekadesa*) relational incidence across the **82-*paramattha* / 170-token ultimate reality catalog** ($89\text{ cittas} + 52\text{ cetasikas} + 28\text{ rūpas} + 1\text{ Nibbāna} = 170$) and the **$5\text{ khandhas} + 12\text{ āyatanas} + 18\text{ dhātus} = 35$ ontological containers**. Together with Paper 3 of Series 1 (*Paṭṭhāna*, Book VII), three of the four logical and relational books of the *Abhidhamma Piṭaka* have now been audited. Yet Book V—the ***Kathāvatthu*** ("Points of Controversy", compiled by Ācariya Moggaliputtatissa at the Third Council under Emperor Aśoka, c. 250 BCE)—occupies a unique architectural role: it is the canon's **adversarial axiom-mutation and formal refutation engine**. Where the *Dhātukathā* builds the positive conservation laws and the *Yamaka* audits converse symmetry, the *Kathāvatthu* tests what happens when heterodox schools (Puggalavāda, Sarvāstivāda, Mahāsāṃghika, Andhaka, Mahīśāsaka) mutate a foundational axiom. Applying Guardrail 13 (*The Selective Correspondence Standard*), we select an irreducible **6-controversy spanning basis** from the *Kathāvatthu* that directly stress-tests the load-bearing axioms of Series 1 and Series 2, and submit it to adversarial verification in `epistemic_v4.1_harness`, establishing six principal results: - **Theorem K.I (Formalization of the *Aṭṭhamukha-vāda* Pentad Calculus & Dual-Kernel Audit of the 6 Spanning Controversies).** Formalizing Moggaliputtatissa's 5-step affirmative pentad (*anuloma-pañcaka*) and 5-step rejoinder pentad (*paṭikkhepa-pañcaka*) in both Z3 SMT and an independent zero-Z3 Python evaluator yields 100% agreement across all $2^3 = 8$ propositional truth-table rows (`all_8_truth_table_agree = true`, plus a false-pervasion `SAT` negative control) and across all six spanning controversies (strictly *relative* to the canonical Theravāda axioms; school identifications reflect Buddhaghosa's *Kathāvatthu-aṭṭhakathā*): 1. ***Puggalakathā* (*Kv 1.1*, Puggalavāda):** Every token in $\mathcal{U}_{170}$ / $\mathcal{U}_{82}$ satisfies the exclusive disjunction $\bigl(x \in \bigcup_{i=1}^5 \text{Khandha}_i \wedge \text{saṅkhata}(x)\bigr) \oplus (x = \text{Nibbāna} \wedge \text{asaṅkhata}(x))$; positing an ultimate *puggala* outside both limbs is `UNSAT` (whereas *puggala* as *sammuti-paññatti* supervening on the 5 *khandhas* is `SAT`). 2. ***Parihānikathā* (*Kv 1.2*, Sarvāstivāda / Sammitīya):** Across the 4 path-stages ($10 \to 7 \to 7 \to 5 \to 0$ remaining fetters), *arahatta-magga* ($\mathfrak{T}^{-1}$) zeroes all graded Jordan cohomology obstructions ($H_J^0 \oplus H_J^1 \oplus H_J^2 \oplus H_J^3 = 0$), forcing the non-Hermitian craving drive $\Delta H_{NH}\{\rho\} \equiv 0$; post-Arahant regression (`post_arahant_fetters >= 1`) is `UNSAT`. 3. ***Sabbamatthītikathā* (*Kv 1.6*, Sarvāstivāda Eternalism):** Under the discrete Non-Continuum Calculus (NCC) semigroup $K(\sigma) = e^{-\sigma H_{29}}$, *kāritra* belongs exclusively to the present *khaṇa* (*uppāda–ṭhiti–bhaṅga*); in the early *sabbaṃ atthi* formulation targeted by *Kv 1.6* (prior to the later Vaibhāṣika distinction between persistent *svabhāva* and momentary *kāritra*), substantial coexistence of a past *citta* with a present *citta* violates the rank-1 bottleneck (`total_simultaneous <= 1`, `UNSAT`). 4. ***Anusayakathā* (*Kv 9.4, 11.1, 14.5*, Mahāsāṃghika / Andhaka):** Across $\mathcal{U}_{170}$, all $50/50$ tokens in *saṅkhārakkhandha* are strictly associated with mind (`sankhara_vippayutta_token_count = 0`); the 7 canonical *anusayas* map surjectively onto **6 *akusala cetasikas*** (`lobha, dosa, māna, diṭṭhi, vicikicchā, moha` $\subset \text{saṅkhārakkhandha}$), proving that *citta-vippayutta* / *anārammaṇa anusaya* placed inside *saṅkhārakkhandha* is `UNSAT`. 5. ***Nirodhakathā (Dve Nirodhā) & Ākāsakathā* (*Kv 2.11, Kv 6.2 & Kv 6.6*, Mahīśāsaka / Uttarāpathaka / Andhaka):** In $\mathcal{U}_{170}$, `nibbana:nibbana` ($\ker H_{29}$, $\dim = 1$) is the unique unconditioned reality (`unique_unconditioned_nibbana = true`, rejecting a second *asaṅkhata* cessation substance as debated in *Kv 2.11* / *6.2*), while delimiting `akasa_dhatu` (`pariccheda-rūpa`, *Kv 6.6*) is a conditioned *sukhuma-rūpa* inside `rupakkhandha` at $D_4$ root height $h = \pm 3$. 6. ***Vacībheda-, Cittaṭṭhiti- & Ekacittakkhaṇikā-kathā* (*Kv 2.5, Kv 2.7 & Kv 22.8*, Andhaka / Pubbaseliya):** Across all 89 *cittas* ($10_{\text{pañca}} + 3_{\text{mano}} + 76_{\text{manoviññāṇa}}$), *citta–citta sampayoga* is identically empty (`zero_citta_citta_sampayoga = true`), matching orthogonal Jordan Peirce idempotents $E_i \circ E_j = \delta_{ij} E_i$ ($\operatorname{Tr}(E_i) = 1$, verified numerically in concrete $(3, 3, 8)$ Hermitian $J_3(\mathbb{O})$ arithmetic). Furthermore, `EpistemicProvenanceLedger` enforces `ABSTAIN_UNDERSPECIFIED` when an unqualified *puggala* assertion omits the truth-stratum quantifier (`paramattha` vs. `sammuti-paññatti`). [Tier M1; Tier B1/B2.]- **Theorem K.II (Layer $-1$ Exact Rational Farkas Impossibility Certificates for Heterodox Posits).** Using `AutonomousDeadlockScout` and the zero-Z3 `IndependentUnsatChecker`, we extract exact rational (`Fraction`) Farkas certificates proving the **relative** linear infeasibility of: (a) Puggalavāda's 83rd ultimate *paramattha* reality under 82-*paramattha* closure (`multipliers = (-1, 1, -1, -1, -1, -1; 1)` $\implies 0 \le -1$), (b) Mahāsāṃghika/Andhaka's *citta-vippayutta anusaya* inside 50-factor *saṅkhārakkhandha* ($\implies 0 \le -1$), and (c) Andhaka's simultaneous sensory + mental *citta* concourse under the rank-1 Peirce trace ceiling ($\implies 0 \le -1$), while Filter A rejects unanchored debate-verbosity compromises in 0 SMT cycles. Volatile `latency_ms` fields and unordered Z3/set core lists are canonicalized prior to integrity hashing. [Tier M1; Tier B1.]- **Theorem K.III (Layer 2b Three-Span Categorical Pushout & Sectarian-Gematria Passenger Rejection).** Fusing `Ontology_82_Paramattha_Domain`, `Cohomology_Anusaya_Pahana_Domain`, and `Temporal_Vithi_Bottleneck_Domain` in `MultiSpanColimitEngine` with strictly homogeneous variable types (separating *paramattha* category counts, *saṃyojana* fetter counts, and *khaṇa* counts via the $14 = 6_{\text{anusaya-base}} + 8_{\text{concomitant}}$ *akusala cetasika* decomposition and stoichiometric Arahant bounds) passes all five `PostPushoutVerifier` hardening gates: pre-pinned offline `ChallengeAxiomLock` SHA-256 (`f84339a616e28bc5...`), pure-Python AST witness replay (`n_paramattha_cat = 82, n_arahant_residual_fetter = 0, n_arahant_residual_akusala_cat = 0, n_rupa_life_submoments = 51`), $3/3$ Farkas-verified heterodox mutation kills (`KS-KV-1`, `KS-KV-2`, `KS-KV-3`), `assumed_count = 0` with `net_free_dof = 0`, and causal synergy $\Phi_{\text{syn}} = 1.0$. Appending an uncoupled `E8_Sectarian_Gematria_Slot` (`e8_sectarian_root_slot` $\in [1, 248]$) is rejected fail-closed by Gate 5 (`TRIVIAL_JUXTAPOSITION_PASSENGER_DOMAINS`, $\Phi_{\text{syn}} = 0.0$). [Tier M2; Tier B2.]- **Theorem K.IV (Relative Orthogonal Axiom-Blocking & $6 \times 6$ School Moduli Space).** Encoding the coupled Z3 integer conservation and transition system over canonical counts $(A_1, \dots, A_6)$ and testing single-axiom relaxations against the six paired heterodox theses $(T_1, \dots, T_6)$ demonstrates an exact bifurcation governed by the Sarvāstivāda *svabhāva/kāritra* split: (a) when $A_6$ is scoped to instantaneous present-moment simultaneous *cittas* (`n_present_citta == 1`), the coupled integer **Axiom-Relaxation Matrix** is the exact $6 \times 6$ identity $\mathbf{M}_{\text{relax}} = \mathbf{I}_6$; whereas (b) when $A_6$ constrains *all* substantially existing *cittas* without separating *atthibhāva* from present *kāritra* (`n_present_citta + n_nonpresent_atthi_citta <= 1`, matching §3.3), dropping $A_3$ alone leaves $T_3$ **still `UNSAT`**, isolating the genuine $A_3 \leftrightarrow A_6$ coupling. This matrix certifies **relative orthogonal blocking among the six canonical rules**, complemented by live concrete $(3, 3, 8)$ Hermitian NumPy $J_3(\mathbb{O})$ checks (`peirce_idempotent_max_err = 0.0`, `jordan_fundamental_identity_max_err = 2.22e-16`, `peirce_associator_norm = 0.6287 > 0.1`). [Tier M1; Tier B2/B3.]- **Theorem K.V (Layer 6 SAT Manifold & Standalone Zero-Z3 DPLL + Resolution Refutations).** A 10-variable canonical *Kathāvatthu* CNF yields exactly **20** admissible Boolean profiles (matching exhaustive $2^{10} = 1024$ enumeration). Using `IndependentUnsatChecker.verify_cnf_unsat()`, we emit four standalone zero-Z3 **DPLL + explicit Resolution Refutation proofs (`VALID_RESOLUTION_REFUTATION`)** refuting Kv 1.1 (*Puggalavāda*), Kv 1.2 (*Parihāni*), Kv 1.6 (*Sarvāstivāda* non-present efficacy), and Kv 9.4 (*Mahāsāṃghika* disembodied mental factor). [Tier M1; Tier B1/B2.]- **Proposition K.VI (Worldling Indistinguishability & 3-Query Boundary Identifiability).** Evaluating the four competing school hypotheses (`H1_THERAVADA_CANONICAL`, `H2_PUGGALAVADA_AVAKTAVYA`, `H3_SARVASTIVADA_TRIKALA_PARIHANI`, `H4_ANDHAKA_VIPPAYUTTA_ANUSAYA`) in `ActiveRuleDiscoverer` against the canonical Theravāda target profile proves that ordinary present-moment worldling (*puthujjana*) probes leave all four schools macroscopically indistinguishable (`AMBIGUOUS_HYPOTHESIS_CLASS`), whereas Moggaliputtatissa's three targeted boundary probes (`P_KV1_1_KHANDHA_EXHAUSTIVENESS`, `P_KV1_2_ARAHANT_TRIKALA_BOUNDARY`, `P_KV9_4_ANUSAYA_SAMPAYOGA_BOUNDARY`) uniquely identify `H1_THERAVADA_CANONICAL` in 3 queries. [Tier M2; Tier B3.]

Zenodo (CERN European Organization for Nuclear Research)
Indian and Buddhist Studies
AI Navigator

Ask Laika to Summarize, Analyze, and Connect papers live on the map.

Summarize Papers & Methodologies

Extract key findings, datasets, and comparative methods across publications.

Benchmark Rankings & Visual Analytics

Rank top research institutions, authors, funders, topics, and journals by Field-Weighted Citation Impact (FWCI) and paper volume with instant charts.

Connect Distant Disciplines

Bridge topological clusters on the map to find hidden collaborative intersections.

Laika access coming soon