Teachers’ Strategies, Challenges, and Enablers in Implementing Deep Learning in Indonesian Senior Secondary Education: A Scoping Review
Following the enactment of Permendikbudristek No. 12/2024 and Permendikdasmen No. 13/2025, pedagogical Deep Learning (DL) has been institutionalized within Indonesia’s Kurikulum Merdeka. Despite growing adoption, comprehensive evidence mapping DL practices across senior secondary education remains fragmented. This study addresses this gap by presenting the first cross-study synthesis on DL implementation in Indonesian senior secondary schools (SMA/SMK/MA) from 2020–2026, introducing a novel three-tier barrier taxonomy and an empirical enabler framework for teacher professional development. Guided by the Arksey and O’Malley framework and PRISMA-ScR guidelines, 398 records retrieved from Publish or Perish and Scopus AI were screened, yielding 27 eligible SINTA- and Scopus-indexed articles for thematic synthesis. Eight instructional strategies emerged, led by Mindful-Meaningful-Joyful (MMJ) learning (25.9%), Project-Based Learning (14.8%), and AI/technology-assisted DL (14.8%). Implementation barriers were predominantly internal, stemming from teachers’ pedagogical habits and conceptual misconceptions (66.7%), followed by structural constraints (29.6%) and policy burdens (7.4%). Nevertheless, 100% of reviewed studies reported positive cognitive and affective student outcomes, primarily enabled by Kurikulum Merdeka’s regulatory flexibility (33.3%), digital learning media (25.9%), and targeted teacher coaching (14.8%). Sustaining DL transformation in Indonesian secondary schools requires shifting professional development from one-off workshops toward continuous, practice-based coaching that transforms teachers’ pedagogical paradigms.
Authors
- Indah Sari
- Ahmad Hamka
- Widya Ningsih
- Arrafa Nayla Alfaithy
- Udin Supriyadi
Institutions
- Indonesia University of Education (ID)
Publication Details
- Journal
- Mindset
- Published
- 2026-11-17
- Primary Topic
- Educational Curriculum and Learning Methods
- Type
- article
- Field-Weighted Citation Impact
- 0.00
Funders
- Universitas Pendidikan Indonesia