Implementation Challenges and Unintended Consequences of Performance-Based Payment: A Qualitative Study of Hospital Managers in Iran

Background: Performance-based payment is now widely used to improve efficiency and accountability in healthcare systems. In Iran, this model was introduced under the Health Transformation Plan with the aim of enhancing hospital performance and staff motivation; however, emerging evidence points to notable challenges in its implementation. While previous research has largely examined providers' responses, far less attention has been paid to how hospital managers—those directly responsible for implementing these policies—interpret and manage these incentives in practice. This study explores managers' perspectives on how performance-based payment operates in practice and where they perceive its primary shortcomings. Objective: To explore how public hospital managers interpret, implement, and critically assess performance-based payment, with a particular focus on its operational challenges and unintended consequences. Materials and methods: This qualitative study employed a conventional content analysis approach. Semi-structured interviews were conducted with 11 public hospital managers selected through purposive sampling with maximum variation. Data collection continued until thematic saturation was achieved. Analysis followed an iterative process involving open coding, category development, and abstraction of themes. Trustworthiness was ensured using Lincoln and Guba's criteria. Results: Four main themes emerged: imbalance in motivational drivers, threats to organizational commitment, quality–quantity trade-offs, and structural inefficiencies. Although participants acknowledged the system's potential to differentiate performance and support cost control, they consistently highlighted delayed payments—often extending to 6–8 months—alongside limited transparency in calculation mechanisms and perceived inequities in distribution. These challenges were described as weakening the intended motivational effects of the system and were, in some cases, associated with reduced organizational attachment, increased emphasis on service volume over quality, and tendencies toward dual practice. Conclusion: The effectiveness of performance-based payment in public hospitals appears to be shaped less by its formal design than by the conditions under which it is implemented. Delayed payments, constrained managerial discretion, and limited transparency emerged as key factors undermining its intended impact. Addressing these requires more timely and transparent payment processes alongside greater organizational flexibility— findings that carry implications for other health systems confronting analogous reform challenges.

Authors

Institutions

Publication Details

Journal
Research Square
Published
2026-11-18
DOI
https://doi.org/10.21203/rs.3.rs-11414806/v1
Primary Topic
Healthcare Systems and Reforms
Type
preprint

Funders

Controls
|||
ALL TIME
JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
OCT
NOV
preprint

Implementation Challenges and Unintended Consequences of Performance-Based Payment: A Qualitative Study of Hospital Managers in Iran

Somayeh Rajabzadeh, Marzieh Babaee, Soleiman Ahmady, Tahir Bashir Khan et al.
Research Square
Healthcare Systems and Reforms
preprint

Implementation Challenges and Unintended Consequences of Performance-Based Payment: A Qualitative Study of Hospital Managers in Iran

Somayeh Rajabzadeh, Marzieh Babaee, Soleiman Ahmady, Tahir Bashir Khan, Nasrin Sharbafchizadeh, Vahideh Zeynali
preprint en

Abstract

Background: Performance-based payment is now widely used to improve efficiency and accountability in healthcare systems. In Iran, this model was introduced under the Health Transformation Plan with the aim of enhancing hospital performance and staff motivation; however, emerging evidence points to notable challenges in its implementation. While previous research has largely examined providers' responses, far less attention has been paid to how hospital managers—those directly responsible for implementing these policies—interpret and manage these incentives in practice. This study explores managers' perspectives on how performance-based payment operates in practice and where they perceive its primary shortcomings. Objective: To explore how public hospital managers interpret, implement, and critically assess performance-based payment, with a particular focus on its operational challenges and unintended consequences. Materials and methods: This qualitative study employed a conventional content analysis approach. Semi-structured interviews were conducted with 11 public hospital managers selected through purposive sampling with maximum variation. Data collection continued until thematic saturation was achieved. Analysis followed an iterative process involving open coding, category development, and abstraction of themes. Trustworthiness was ensured using Lincoln and Guba's criteria. Results: Four main themes emerged: imbalance in motivational drivers, threats to organizational commitment, quality–quantity trade-offs, and structural inefficiencies. Although participants acknowledged the system's potential to differentiate performance and support cost control, they consistently highlighted delayed payments—often extending to 6–8 months—alongside limited transparency in calculation mechanisms and perceived inequities in distribution. These challenges were described as weakening the intended motivational effects of the system and were, in some cases, associated with reduced organizational attachment, increased emphasis on service volume over quality, and tendencies toward dual practice. Conclusion: The effectiveness of performance-based payment in public hospitals appears to be shaped less by its formal design than by the conditions under which it is implemented. Delayed payments, constrained managerial discretion, and limited transparency emerged as key factors undermining its intended impact. Addressing these requires more timely and transparent payment processes alongside greater organizational flexibility— findings that carry implications for other health systems confronting analogous reform challenges.

Research Square
Iran University of Medical Sciences (IR), Shahid Beheshti University of Medical Sciences (IR)
Islamic Azad University
Good health and well-being
Healthcare Systems and Reforms
AI Navigator

Ask Laika to Summarize, Analyze, and Connect papers live on the map.

Summarize Papers & Methodologies

Extract key findings, datasets, and comparative methods across publications.

Benchmark Rankings & Visual Analytics

Rank top research institutions, authors, funders, topics, and journals by Field-Weighted Citation Impact (FWCI) and paper volume with instant charts.

Connect Distant Disciplines

Bridge topological clusters on the map to find hidden collaborative intersections.

Laika access coming soon