Medical, social and ethical reasons to deny fertility treatment: a survey of multidisciplinary stakeholders

Abstract Finite financial resources create difficult decisions regarding allocation of public funding and access to Medically Assisted Reproduction (MAR). As a result, individuals may be refused funding for fertility treatment based on medical reasons, for example expected low chance of treatment success, or social reasons, for example being single. A survey of multidisciplinary stakeholder opinions for possible reasons to deny MAR were captured using a questionnaire. The survey was distributed via email and social media. Snowball sampling was used, with respondents encouraged to share the survey. This study was classified as exempt by ethics. 319 participants responded. Many selected substance (mis)use, for example smoking (64%), marijuana (63%), alcohol (51%), and other substances (69%), as legitimate reasons to deny treatment. Less than half of all participants supported age (41%) and BMI (46%) as treatment exclusion criteria, although BMI was the highest reason overall selected by physicians. Less than 3% all respondents supported marital status, partner status, sexual orientation, or physical disability as reasons to deny MAR. Reasons articulated for treatment denial centred on nonmaleficence, especially welfare of the child. Respondents also raised themes of patient autonomy and justice, particularly towards marginalised groups, as reasons to support more inclusive access to MAR. These results emphasise the need for multidisciplinary and diverse perspectives to ensure fairness in determining access to publicly funded MAR. Lay Summary Public funding for fertility treatments in the UK is limited, so decisions need to be made about who can access medically assisted reproduction (MAR). People may be denied treatment for medical reasons, including a predicted low chance of success, or social reasons, such as being single. This study surveyed 319 people from different backgrounds to understand the reasons they felt justified in denying access to MAR. Most respondents (around 60%) felt that substance use, such as tobacco, marijuana, alcohol, or other drugs, was a valid reason to refuse treatment. Around 40% of respondents supported denying treatment based on age or body weight, although doctors were more likely to select body weight as a valid reason. Very few respondents (less than 3%) supported excluding people based on relationship status, sexual orientation, or disability. Overall, responses highlighted concern for child welfare, while also emphasising fairness, patient choice, and inclusive access to care.

Authors

Institutions

Publication Details

Journal
Reproduction and Fertility
Published
2026-11-17
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1530/raf-26-0015
Primary Topic
Reproductive Health and Technologies
Type
article
Field-Weighted Citation Impact
0.00
Controls
|||
ALL TIME
JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
OCT
NOV
article

Medical, social and ethical reasons to deny fertility treatment: a survey of multidisciplinary stakeholders

Sarah Martins da Silva, Lisa Campo‐Engelstein, Eve Blackwood, Jasmine Jones
2 links
Reproduction and Fertility
Reproductive Health and Technologies
article

Medical, social and ethical reasons to deny fertility treatment: a survey of multidisciplinary stakeholders

Sarah Martins da Silva, Lisa Campo‐Engelstein, Eve Blackwood, Jasmine Jones
article en

Abstract

Abstract Finite financial resources create difficult decisions regarding allocation of public funding and access to Medically Assisted Reproduction (MAR). As a result, individuals may be refused funding for fertility treatment based on medical reasons, for example expected low chance of treatment success, or social reasons, for example being single. A survey of multidisciplinary stakeholder opinions for possible reasons to deny MAR were captured using a questionnaire. The survey was distributed via email and social media. Snowball sampling was used, with respondents encouraged to share the survey. This study was classified as exempt by ethics. 319 participants responded. Many selected substance (mis)use, for example smoking (64%), marijuana (63%), alcohol (51%), and other substances (69%), as legitimate reasons to deny treatment. Less than half of all participants supported age (41%) and BMI (46%) as treatment exclusion criteria, although BMI was the highest reason overall selected by physicians. Less than 3% all respondents supported marital status, partner status, sexual orientation, or physical disability as reasons to deny MAR. Reasons articulated for treatment denial centred on nonmaleficence, especially welfare of the child. Respondents also raised themes of patient autonomy and justice, particularly towards marginalised groups, as reasons to support more inclusive access to MAR. These results emphasise the need for multidisciplinary and diverse perspectives to ensure fairness in determining access to publicly funded MAR. Lay Summary Public funding for fertility treatments in the UK is limited, so decisions need to be made about who can access medically assisted reproduction (MAR). People may be denied treatment for medical reasons, including a predicted low chance of success, or social reasons, such as being single. This study surveyed 319 people from different backgrounds to understand the reasons they felt justified in denying access to MAR. Most respondents (around 60%) felt that substance use, such as tobacco, marijuana, alcohol, or other drugs, was a valid reason to refuse treatment. Around 40% of respondents supported denying treatment based on age or body weight, although doctors were more likely to select body weight as a valid reason. Very few respondents (less than 3%) supported excluding people based on relationship status, sexual orientation, or disability. Overall, responses highlighted concern for child welfare, while also emphasising fairness, patient choice, and inclusive access to care.

Reproduction and Fertility
University of Dundee (GB), Ninewells Hospital (GB), Cal Humanities (US), Rush University (US), The University of Texas Medical Branch at Galveston (US)
Good health and well-being, Reduced inequalities
Reproductive Health and Technologies
AI Navigator

Ask Laika to Summarize, Analyze, and Connect papers live on the map.

Summarize Papers & Methodologies

Extract key findings, datasets, and comparative methods across publications.

Benchmark Rankings & Visual Analytics

Rank top research institutions, authors, funders, topics, and journals by Field-Weighted Citation Impact (FWCI) and paper volume with instant charts.

Connect Distant Disciplines

Bridge topological clusters on the map to find hidden collaborative intersections.

Laika access coming soon