An Analysis of Students’ Mathematical Reasoning in Solving Indefinite Integral Problems Based on Lithner’s Framework

Correct solutions to indefinite integral problems can result from applying routine procedures and therefore provide limited evidence of the reasoning students used. Drawing on Lithner’s framework, this study examined the types and components of mathematical reasoning evident in students’ written solutions and explored how errors related to reasoning type. A descriptive–interpretive qualitative document analysis was conducted on 20 scanned handwritten scripts, comprising 19 scripts covering 13 odd-numbered antiderivative items and one definite-integral script used for comparison. Qualitative content analysis involved deductive coding of strategy choice, implementation, argumentation, and mathematical foundation, followed by classification into four levels (A–D) according to the dominant reasoning pattern and categorization of errors. All 19 antiderivative scripts exhibited algorithmic reasoning. Eleven showed procedural steps alone, five stated a general rule, and three provided reasons or specified conditions for a rule’s validity. No script met all three criteria for creative reasoning or showed verification by differentiation. Errors were associated with the reuse of procedural templates across items, copying slips, and uncritical interpretations of notation. The findings show that the routine tasks examined elicited imitative reasoning and underscore that creative reasoning requires strategic novelty alongside mathematical grounding. The study provides coding indicators and reasoning levels for analyzing written solutions and identifies ways to design calculus assessments that require students to verify results, justify strategies, and test the conditions under which rules apply. The analysis was limited to written evidence and relied on a single coder.

Authors

Publication Details

Journal
International Journal of Humanities Education and Social Sciences
Published
2026-11-18
DOI
https://doi.org/10.58578/ijhess.v4i3.12670
Primary Topic
Mathematics Education and Pedagogy
Type
article
Field-Weighted Citation Impact
0.00
Controls
|||
ALL TIME
JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
OCT
NOV
article

An Analysis of Students’ Mathematical Reasoning in Solving Indefinite Integral Problems Based on Lithner’s Framework

Khadijah
International Journal of Humanities Education and Social Sciences
Mathematics Education and Pedagogy
article

An Analysis of Students’ Mathematical Reasoning in Solving Indefinite Integral Problems Based on Lithner’s Framework

Khadijah
article en

Abstract

Correct solutions to indefinite integral problems can result from applying routine procedures and therefore provide limited evidence of the reasoning students used. Drawing on Lithner’s framework, this study examined the types and components of mathematical reasoning evident in students’ written solutions and explored how errors related to reasoning type. A descriptive–interpretive qualitative document analysis was conducted on 20 scanned handwritten scripts, comprising 19 scripts covering 13 odd-numbered antiderivative items and one definite-integral script used for comparison. Qualitative content analysis involved deductive coding of strategy choice, implementation, argumentation, and mathematical foundation, followed by classification into four levels (A–D) according to the dominant reasoning pattern and categorization of errors. All 19 antiderivative scripts exhibited algorithmic reasoning. Eleven showed procedural steps alone, five stated a general rule, and three provided reasons or specified conditions for a rule’s validity. No script met all three criteria for creative reasoning or showed verification by differentiation. Errors were associated with the reuse of procedural templates across items, copying slips, and uncritical interpretations of notation. The findings show that the routine tasks examined elicited imitative reasoning and underscore that creative reasoning requires strategic novelty alongside mathematical grounding. The study provides coding indicators and reasoning levels for analyzing written solutions and identifies ways to design calculus assessments that require students to verify results, justify strategies, and test the conditions under which rules apply. The analysis was limited to written evidence and relied on a single coder.

International Journal of Humanities Education and Social SciencesVol. 4(3)
Quality education
Mathematics Education and Pedagogy
AI Navigator

Ask Laika to Summarize, Analyze, and Connect papers live on the map.

Summarize Papers & Methodologies

Extract key findings, datasets, and comparative methods across publications.

Benchmark Rankings & Visual Analytics

Rank top research institutions, authors, funders, topics, and journals by Field-Weighted Citation Impact (FWCI) and paper volume with instant charts.

Connect Distant Disciplines

Bridge topological clusters on the map to find hidden collaborative intersections.

Laika access coming soon