Beyond Influence Centrality: A Cross-Context Evaluation of Structural Brokerage and Node Irreplaceability in Health-Information Networks

Abstract Conventional centrality measures identify structurally prominent nodes in online social networks but do not explicitly quantify their brokerage across distinct information contexts or the availability of alternative nodes performing equivalent bridging roles. This study introduces two complementary context-sensitive centrality measures: Cross-Context Two-Step Brokerage (CCTB), which quantifies the proportion of directed incoming–outgoing interaction opportunities spanning different contexts, and Irreplaceable Context Brokerage (ICB), which weights ordered context-pair connections according to the scarcity of alternative bridging nodes. The measures were evaluated using FibVID and Monant, with exploratory replication using MC-Fake, through chronological holdout evaluation, comparisons with established centrality measures and predictive modelling of subsequent cross-context brokerage. Incorporating CCTB and ICB alongside degree centrality and context breadth increased mean Average Precision from 0.2966 to 0.3542 in FibVID, from 0.0847 to 0.0925 in Monant, and from 0.0655 to 0.1190 in MC-Fake. Under a fixed 5% node-removal budget, simulations examined the potential of centrality-guided targeting to disrupt structural pathways relevant to misinformation diffusion. Degree-based targeting achieved the greatest reduction in future two-step cross-context brokerage opportunities in FibVID (98.73%), context-breadth targeting performed best in Monant (20.77%), while CCTB and ICB achieved the highest reductions in MC-Fake (96.81% each). These findings suggest that context-sensitive brokerage measures provide complementary information for identifying structurally important intermediaries and may inform targeted strategies aimed at limiting misinformation propagation across online social networks. However, the simulated reductions represent disruption of potential structural diffusion pathways rather than empirically observed reductions in misinformation transmission or established causal intervention effects.

Authors

Institutions

Publication Details

Journal
Research Square
Published
2026-11-17
DOI
https://doi.org/10.21203/rs.3.rs-11641986/v1
Primary Topic
Complex Network Analysis Techniques
Type
preprint
Controls
|||
ALL TIME
JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
OCT
NOV
preprint

Beyond Influence Centrality: A Cross-Context Evaluation of Structural Brokerage and Node Irreplaceability in Health-Information Networks

Mkululi Sikosana
2 links
Research Square
Complex Network Analysis Techniques
preprint

Beyond Influence Centrality: A Cross-Context Evaluation of Structural Brokerage and Node Irreplaceability in Health-Information Networks

Mkululi Sikosana
preprint en

Abstract

Abstract Conventional centrality measures identify structurally prominent nodes in online social networks but do not explicitly quantify their brokerage across distinct information contexts or the availability of alternative nodes performing equivalent bridging roles. This study introduces two complementary context-sensitive centrality measures: Cross-Context Two-Step Brokerage (CCTB), which quantifies the proportion of directed incoming–outgoing interaction opportunities spanning different contexts, and Irreplaceable Context Brokerage (ICB), which weights ordered context-pair connections according to the scarcity of alternative bridging nodes. The measures were evaluated using FibVID and Monant, with exploratory replication using MC-Fake, through chronological holdout evaluation, comparisons with established centrality measures and predictive modelling of subsequent cross-context brokerage. Incorporating CCTB and ICB alongside degree centrality and context breadth increased mean Average Precision from 0.2966 to 0.3542 in FibVID, from 0.0847 to 0.0925 in Monant, and from 0.0655 to 0.1190 in MC-Fake. Under a fixed 5% node-removal budget, simulations examined the potential of centrality-guided targeting to disrupt structural pathways relevant to misinformation diffusion. Degree-based targeting achieved the greatest reduction in future two-step cross-context brokerage opportunities in FibVID (98.73%), context-breadth targeting performed best in Monant (20.77%), while CCTB and ICB achieved the highest reductions in MC-Fake (96.81% each). These findings suggest that context-sensitive brokerage measures provide complementary information for identifying structurally important intermediaries and may inform targeted strategies aimed at limiting misinformation propagation across online social networks. However, the simulated reductions represent disruption of potential structural diffusion pathways rather than empirically observed reductions in misinformation transmission or established causal intervention effects.

Research Square
Manchester Metropolitan University (GB)
Complex Network Analysis Techniques
AI Navigator

Ask Laika to Summarize, Analyze, and Connect papers live on the map.

Summarize Papers & Methodologies

Extract key findings, datasets, and comparative methods across publications.

Benchmark Rankings & Visual Analytics

Rank top research institutions, authors, funders, topics, and journals by Field-Weighted Citation Impact (FWCI) and paper volume with instant charts.

Connect Distant Disciplines

Bridge topological clusters on the map to find hidden collaborative intersections.

Laika access coming soon