Circular-economy soil amendments for crop production on mining-degraded soils in Ghana: a critical narrative synthesis of field evidence, food-safety gaps and governance propositions

Small-scale and illegal gold mining (galamsey) has degraded farmland across southern Ghana and left residual heavy-metal contamination in soils used for food production. Circular-economy soil amendments such as biochar, poultry manure, and by-product gypsum are increasingly proposed as low-cost restoration inputs, but field evidence on their effects on crop productivity, nutritional composition, and food safety in Ghana has not been critically appraised. This critical narrative synthesis appraises a purposively assembled core evidence base of three field trials on mining-affected soils (cassava and bamboo at a single galamsey site in Amansie Central District; cucumber on gypsum-amended mine subsoil at Ahafo-Kenyasi), all conducted by members of the author team, together with one biochar–fertilizer trial on conventional farmland (carrot), which is retained only as a labeled comparator for nutritional-composition methods. Amendments improved selected growth, soil-chemical, or tissue-composition indicators in each mining-affected trial, but responses were endpoint-, season-, and amendment-specific. In cassava, combined biochar and poultry manure increased first-year stover biomass without a significant effect on tuber yield or harvest index, and lowered root arsenic and lead relative to the unamended galamsey control in year one (arsenic again in year two). However, because the primary papers did not state the tissue analyzed or the reporting basis, compliance could only be calculated under stated assumptions: on either a fresh- or dry-weight assumption, lead and cadmium in all cassava treatments, including the forest-soil control, would exceed Codex maximum levels. Gypsum did not reduce lead in cucumber, which exceeded 8 mg/kg in one season. These calculated exceedances do not confirm regulatory non-compliance, but the evidence does not show that produce from amended mining-affected soils is safe to eat. None of the trials reported cost per hectare, land area restored, or time to recovery. We propose a preliminary six-metric reporting framework for future restoration trials, present governance constraints on scaling as propositions for investigation rather than findings, and conclude that the current evidence is preliminary, site-specific and hypothesis-generating, warranting multi-site trials with fresh-weight contaminant reporting and dietary exposure assessment before food production on such land is recommended.

Authors

Institutions

Publication Details

Journal
Frontiers in Sustainable Food Systems
Published
2026-11-17
DOI
https://doi.org/10.3389/fsufs.2026.1943763
Primary Topic
Heavy metals in environment
Type
article
Field-Weighted Citation Impact
0.00
Controls
|||
ALL TIME
JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
OCT
NOV
article

Circular-economy soil amendments for crop production on mining-degraded soils in Ghana: a critical narrative synthesis of field evidence, food-safety gaps and governance propositions

Clement Oppong Peprah, Felix Frimpong, Kwaku Onwona-Hwesofour Asante, Mavis Badu Brempong et al.
2 links
Frontiers in Sustainable Food Systems
Heavy metals in environment
article

Circular-economy soil amendments for crop production on mining-degraded soils in Ghana: a critical narrative synthesis of field evidence, food-safety gaps and governance propositions

Clement Oppong Peprah, Felix Frimpong, Kwaku Onwona-Hwesofour Asante, Mavis Badu Brempong, Agbesi Kwadzo Keteku, Eric Owusu Danquah, Jeannette Aduhene-Chinbuah
article en

Abstract

Small-scale and illegal gold mining (galamsey) has degraded farmland across southern Ghana and left residual heavy-metal contamination in soils used for food production. Circular-economy soil amendments such as biochar, poultry manure, and by-product gypsum are increasingly proposed as low-cost restoration inputs, but field evidence on their effects on crop productivity, nutritional composition, and food safety in Ghana has not been critically appraised. This critical narrative synthesis appraises a purposively assembled core evidence base of three field trials on mining-affected soils (cassava and bamboo at a single galamsey site in Amansie Central District; cucumber on gypsum-amended mine subsoil at Ahafo-Kenyasi), all conducted by members of the author team, together with one biochar–fertilizer trial on conventional farmland (carrot), which is retained only as a labeled comparator for nutritional-composition methods. Amendments improved selected growth, soil-chemical, or tissue-composition indicators in each mining-affected trial, but responses were endpoint-, season-, and amendment-specific. In cassava, combined biochar and poultry manure increased first-year stover biomass without a significant effect on tuber yield or harvest index, and lowered root arsenic and lead relative to the unamended galamsey control in year one (arsenic again in year two). However, because the primary papers did not state the tissue analyzed or the reporting basis, compliance could only be calculated under stated assumptions: on either a fresh- or dry-weight assumption, lead and cadmium in all cassava treatments, including the forest-soil control, would exceed Codex maximum levels. Gypsum did not reduce lead in cucumber, which exceeded 8 mg/kg in one season. These calculated exceedances do not confirm regulatory non-compliance, but the evidence does not show that produce from amended mining-affected soils is safe to eat. None of the trials reported cost per hectare, land area restored, or time to recovery. We propose a preliminary six-metric reporting framework for future restoration trials, present governance constraints on scaling as propositions for investigation rather than findings, and conclude that the current evidence is preliminary, site-specific and hypothesis-generating, warranting multi-site trials with fresh-weight contaminant reporting and dietary exposure assessment before food production on such land is recommended.

Frontiers in Sustainable Food SystemsVol. 10
Kwame Nkrumah University of Science and Technology (GH), Council for Scientific and Industrial Research (GH)
Zero hunger, Responsible consumption and production, Life on land
Heavy metals in environment
AI Navigator

Ask Laika to Summarize, Analyze, and Connect papers live on the map.

Summarize Papers & Methodologies

Extract key findings, datasets, and comparative methods across publications.

Benchmark Rankings & Visual Analytics

Rank top research institutions, authors, funders, topics, and journals by Field-Weighted Citation Impact (FWCI) and paper volume with instant charts.

Connect Distant Disciplines

Bridge topological clusters on the map to find hidden collaborative intersections.

Laika access coming soon