Interreader and intrareader agreement of qualitative cine four-dimensional computed tomography interpretation for dynamic carpal instability

PURPOSE: To determine the interreader and intrareader agreement of qualitative cine four-dimensional computed tomography (4D CT) interpretation for dynamic carpal instability separately for the binary judgment of whether instability is present and for the assignment of an instability phenotype. METHODS: In this retrospective reader-agreement study, 50 wrists from 50 patients who were consecutively screened and imaged for clinically suspected carpal instability were read independently by three blinded musculoskeletal radiologists in 2 rounds separated by a 4- to 6-week washout with re-randomized case order and identifiers, giving 300 evaluations. The readers reviewed anonymized flexion-extension and radioulnar-deviation cine sequences using a common written guide and evaluation form that standardized the observations and reporting structure; quantitative thresholds for abnormal motion were not specified. The principal analysis focused on round-1 three-reader agreement for the binary overall judgment, estimated with Fleiss kappa (κ); 95% confidence intervals (CIs) were obtained by wrist-level bootstrap resampling (100,000 replicates, fixed seed). Supporting analyses included the Gwet first-order agreement coefficient (AC1), pairwise and intrareader Cohen κ, and replication in round 2. Phenotype, severity and sequence-specific agreement, reader descriptors, and clinical correlation were exploratory. RESULTS: Round-1 Fleiss κ for the binary judgment was 0.679 (95% CI, 0.509-0.830), with identical judgments by all three readers in 38 of 50 wrists (76.0%); Gwet AC1 was 0.681 (95% CI, 0.521-0.840). Intrareader Cohen κ ranged from 0.755 to 0.801. Agreement for the six-category phenotype was 0.529 (95% CI, 0.382-0.664). Among the 21 wrists judged positive by all three readers, all three assigned the same phenotype category in 11 and the same named carpal compartment in 8; Fleiss κ restricted to these wrists was 0.473 (95% CI, 0.204-0.690). Diagnostic accuracy was not evaluated. CONCLUSION: Among three experienced musculoskeletal radiologists, qualitative cine 4D CT yielded an interreader κ of 0.679 for the binary judgment of dynamic carpal instability. Assignment of a specific phenotype was less consistent, with interpretation limited by overlapping qualitative categories. These findings describe agreement under the study reading conditions; they do not establish diagnostic accuracy or clinical validity. CLINICAL SIGNIFICANCE: The three experienced readers showed agreement in binary judgments under controlled reading conditions. Agreement does not establish that those judgments were correct, and the study does not validate qualitative cine 4D CT for clinical decision-making. Phenotype assignments should be interpreted with the clinical findings and other investigations.

Authors

Institutions

Publication Details

Journal
Diagnostic and Interventional Radiology
Published
2026-11-17
DOI
https://doi.org/10.4274/dir.2026.264496
Primary Topic
Orthopedic Surgery and Rehabilitation
Type
article
Field-Weighted Citation Impact
0.00
Controls
|||
ALL TIME
JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
OCT
NOV
article

Interreader and intrareader agreement of qualitative cine four-dimensional computed tomography interpretation for dynamic carpal instability

Ömer Naci Tabakçı, Ismail Bülent Özçelik, Babak Rafiee, Ozgur Genc
1 links
Diagnostic and Interventional Radiology
Orthopedic Surgery and Rehabilitation
article

Interreader and intrareader agreement of qualitative cine four-dimensional computed tomography interpretation for dynamic carpal instability

Ömer Naci Tabakçı, Ismail Bülent Özçelik, Babak Rafiee, Ozgur Genc
article en

Abstract

PURPOSE: To determine the interreader and intrareader agreement of qualitative cine four-dimensional computed tomography (4D CT) interpretation for dynamic carpal instability separately for the binary judgment of whether instability is present and for the assignment of an instability phenotype. METHODS: In this retrospective reader-agreement study, 50 wrists from 50 patients who were consecutively screened and imaged for clinically suspected carpal instability were read independently by three blinded musculoskeletal radiologists in 2 rounds separated by a 4- to 6-week washout with re-randomized case order and identifiers, giving 300 evaluations. The readers reviewed anonymized flexion-extension and radioulnar-deviation cine sequences using a common written guide and evaluation form that standardized the observations and reporting structure; quantitative thresholds for abnormal motion were not specified. The principal analysis focused on round-1 three-reader agreement for the binary overall judgment, estimated with Fleiss kappa (κ); 95% confidence intervals (CIs) were obtained by wrist-level bootstrap resampling (100,000 replicates, fixed seed). Supporting analyses included the Gwet first-order agreement coefficient (AC1), pairwise and intrareader Cohen κ, and replication in round 2. Phenotype, severity and sequence-specific agreement, reader descriptors, and clinical correlation were exploratory. RESULTS: Round-1 Fleiss κ for the binary judgment was 0.679 (95% CI, 0.509-0.830), with identical judgments by all three readers in 38 of 50 wrists (76.0%); Gwet AC1 was 0.681 (95% CI, 0.521-0.840). Intrareader Cohen κ ranged from 0.755 to 0.801. Agreement for the six-category phenotype was 0.529 (95% CI, 0.382-0.664). Among the 21 wrists judged positive by all three readers, all three assigned the same phenotype category in 11 and the same named carpal compartment in 8; Fleiss κ restricted to these wrists was 0.473 (95% CI, 0.204-0.690). Diagnostic accuracy was not evaluated. CONCLUSION: Among three experienced musculoskeletal radiologists, qualitative cine 4D CT yielded an interreader κ of 0.679 for the binary judgment of dynamic carpal instability. Assignment of a specific phenotype was less consistent, with interpretation limited by overlapping qualitative categories. These findings describe agreement under the study reading conditions; they do not establish diagnostic accuracy or clinical validity. CLINICAL SIGNIFICANCE: The three experienced readers showed agreement in binary judgments under controlled reading conditions. Agreement does not establish that those judgments were correct, and the study does not validate qualitative cine 4D CT for clinical decision-making. Phenotype assignments should be interpreted with the clinical findings and other investigations.

Diagnostic and Interventional Radiology
Istanbul Aydın University (TR), Istinye University (TR), Sağlık Bilimleri Üniversitesi (TR)
Good health and well-being
Orthopedic Surgery and Rehabilitation
AI Navigator

Ask Laika to Summarize, Analyze, and Connect papers live on the map.

Summarize Papers & Methodologies

Extract key findings, datasets, and comparative methods across publications.

Benchmark Rankings & Visual Analytics

Rank top research institutions, authors, funders, topics, and journals by Field-Weighted Citation Impact (FWCI) and paper volume with instant charts.

Connect Distant Disciplines

Bridge topological clusters on the map to find hidden collaborative intersections.

Laika access coming soon