Benchmarking honorific academic recognitions against citation metrics
We examined how diverse metrics track individuals receiving major honorific recognitions and whether higher, more prestigious recognitions are associated with higher coverage among a database of top-cited scientists. We assessed with Scopus data the newly inducted (in 2026) 2,038 members of 14 major academies and honorific societies, endowed professors at Stanford University (n=773) and Michigan State University (MSU) endowed professors (n=129) and distinguished professors (n=112), and Nobel (n=166) and Turing (n=25) laureates awarded in 2010-2026 (n=191) for total publications, total citations, h-index, coauthorship-adjusted hm-index, citations to single-, single/first-, and single-/first-/last-authored (SFL) publications, and a composite citation indicator (c-score). For those with ≥5 full papers and ≥20 published items indexed in Scopus, metrics were mapped as percentile values among authors sharing the same primary scientific subfield and ≥5 full papers. Citations to SFL publications had most frequently the best median percentile values and c-score had the best median of median percentile values (0.81%). Subfield-adjusted median percentile values were 0.04-0.23% for Turing/Nobel, 0.23-3.01% for academies and honorific societies, 2.74% for MSU endowed professors, 1.29% for MSU distinguished professors, 0.94% for Stanford endowed professors for citations to SFL publications; and 0.04-0.26%, 0.36-3.85%, 3.21%, 1.55%, 1.03%, respectively, for c-score. The percentages of honorees included in the Stanford/Elsevier listing of top-cited scientists (top-2% of c-score in their scientific subfield or top-100,000 in c-score across all science) followed the perceived prestige gradient: 99% for Turing/Nobel laureates, 84-92% for the national US academies and the UK Royal Society as well as AAP and ACM, 51-76% for other academies/societies, 78% for Stanford endowed professorships, 72% for distinguished MSU professorships, 52% for MSU endowed professorships. Several honored scientists had at least one retraction (highest for medicine (17.5%) and chemistry (11.4%) Nobel laureates), and few had very high proportion of papers in Scopus-discontinued titles, while high self-citations were rarely encountered. Metrics may influence honors and vice versa. The current evidence suggests strong tracking of the median values, especially for citations to SFL publications and c-score, against major recognitions; and a gradient of coverage in a list of top-cited scientists congruent with the perceived relative prestige of these recognitions.
Authors
- Jeroen Baas (ORCID: https://orcid.org/0000-0001-8005-4153)
- John Ioannidis
Institutions
- Elsevier BV (Netherlands) (NL)
- Stanford University (US)
Publication Details
- Journal
- bioRxiv (Cold Spring Harbor Laboratory)
- Published
- 2026-11-17
- DOI
- https://doi.org/10.64898/2026.11.11.766046
- Primary Topic
- scientometrics and bibliometrics research
- Type
- preprint