A discrete-topological interpretation of the linear variation of the speed of light: microscopic quadratic dispersion, vacuum discrete defects, and verification against GRB data
Systematic analyses by B.-Q. Ma's group of the arrival-time delays of high-energy photons from gamma-ray bursts (GRBs) indicate that the speed of light in vacuum has a linear energy dependence, with a Lorentz-violation energy scale E_LV ≈ 3.60×10^17 GeV, and that the null hypothesis of a constant speed of light is rejected at the 3.1σ level. A linear dispersion, however, lacks a natural theoretical basis in quantum-gravity phenomenology: controlled calculations yield a leading correction that is usually quadratic (n = 2). This paper argues that the observed linear law can be understood as the result of statistical averaging of microscopic quadratic dispersion over a sparse distribution of vacuum discrete defects. Within the discrete-topology framework the microscopic dispersion coefficient α = 1/8 follows from the low-energy expansion of the discrete graph-wave equation (Appendix A); the normalization provided by the geometric-series sum α/(1−α) = 1/7 is taken as a phenomenological input, which yields the effective path fraction P(E) = 7E/E_LV. Along a path of length L the mean number of crossed defects is N(E) = P(E)L/ℓ_d, where ℓ_d is the mean defect size, and each defect contributes an energy-independent topological delay τ_d. With τ_d = ℓ_d/(7c) the total delay reproduces Ma's linear law exactly, with a linear coefficient proportional to L. The linear law fails at P → 1, i.e. at E_th = E_LV/7 ≈ 5.14×10^16 GeV, above which the framework makes no quantitative prediction for the energy dependence of the delay; the quadratic term is diluted by 1−P and does not take over. Once this dilution is included, the delay reads Δt = aE + bE² − (7b/E_LV)E³: the cubic term is fixed by b alone, which is the testable difference between this framework and pure quadratic LIV. The second-order LIV scale E_LIV,2 = 1.30(+0.56/−0.35)×10^−7 E_P implied by the 300 TeV photon detected by Carpet-3 requires a dispersion coefficient α_req ≈ 8.9×10^13, some fifteen orders of magnitude larger than 1/8, so the quadratic dispersion of this framework is far too weak to explain that anomaly. The α = 1/8 coefficient follows from the discrete graph-wave equation; the 1/7 normalization is the single phenomenological input of the framework, and no first-principles derivation of it is claimed. Within this framework the scales E_LV extracted from GRB and AGN samples agree within errors, and the LHAASO quadratic limit is satisfied by E_P/√α ≈ 3.5×10^19 GeV; the framework therefore passes the present tests at the achieved precision, while the joint prediction of α = 1/8 and the 1/7 normalization awaits higher-energy data.
Authors
- Baoyuan Zhang
Publication Details
- Journal
- Zenodo (CERN European Organization for Nuclear Research)
- Published
- 2026-11-17
- DOI
- https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24296849
- Primary Topic
- Noncommutative and Quantum Gravity Theories
- Type
- preprint