Managing for upside in a variable climate: An envirotyping framework for wheat genotype × management strategies

Context In dryland cropping systems, seasonal variation in water supply drives variation in water-limited yield potential, creating a need to align genotype selection and management decisions with evolving seasonal conditions. Existing envirotyping approaches have largely focused on characterising target populations of environments and explaining genotype × environment interactions, with limited application to management decisions under uncertainty. Objective To develop an envirotyping-based framework that integrates genotype selection, sowing date and adaptive nitrogen (N) management and evaluate their capacity to capture water-limited yield potential under seasonal uncertainty. Methods APSIM Next Generation was used to simulate wheat production across 44 sites in low–medium rainfall zone of Australia’s Southern Grain Region over 1970–2025. Seasons were classified into four water-stress environment types (EnvTypes) based on temporal patterns of soil water deficit. The framework evaluated how genotype phenology and sowing date influenced crop exposure to EnvTypes and how fixed, deferred and adaptive N management strategies captured the resulting production opportunities. Results EnvType1 and EnvType2 were most frequent EnvTypes accounting for 34.9% and 39.5% of simulated environments, respectively. Genotype yield responses differed significantly among EnvTypes (p < 0.01), while sowing date altered the frequency of EnvType experienced by crops, demonstrating genotype × management decisions jointly shape the exposure to production opportunities. Initial soil water and soil N further modified water-limited yield and crop responsiveness. Fixed upfront N management strategies were often poorly aligned with realised seasonal opportunities, whereas adaptive N management strategies that reassessed seasonal conditions during crop development matched N supply with yield potential. These strategies typically achieved long-term median relative yields exceeding > 90% of the water-limited yield potential and frequently achieved partial gross margins comparable with N-unlimited benchmarks, particularly in high opportunity seasons. Conclusions EnvTypes provide a crop-centred representation of recurring soil water deficit trajectories rather than purely exogenous environmental states. Water availability defines the water-limited yield opportunities, soil resources determine the scope for crop responsiveness, genotype and sowing date influence the crop exposure to these opportunities, and adaptive N management determines the extent to which they are captured as seasonal uncertainty resolves. Significance This framework extends envirotyping from retrospective characterisation of genotype × environment interactions towards prospective evaluation of integrated genotype × environment × management decisions. It provides a practical basis for identifying management combinations that improve the capture of water-limited yield in rainfed cropping systems.

Authors

Institutions

Publication Details

Journal
Field Crops Research
Published
2026-11-17
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.fcr.2026.110801
Primary Topic
Genetics and Plant Breeding
Type
article
Field-Weighted Citation Impact
0.00

Funders

Controls
|||
ALL TIME
JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
OCT
NOV
article

Managing for upside in a variable climate: An envirotyping framework for wheat genotype × management strategies

Ismail Ibrahim Garba, James B. Manson, Bonnie M. Flohr, Kenton D Porker et al.
1 links
Field Crops Research
Genetics and Plant Breeding
article

Managing for upside in a variable climate: An envirotyping framework for wheat genotype × management strategies

Ismail Ibrahim Garba, James B. Manson, Bonnie M. Flohr, Kenton D Porker, Donald S. Gaydon, Cesar Mariano Cossani
article en

Abstract

Context In dryland cropping systems, seasonal variation in water supply drives variation in water-limited yield potential, creating a need to align genotype selection and management decisions with evolving seasonal conditions. Existing envirotyping approaches have largely focused on characterising target populations of environments and explaining genotype × environment interactions, with limited application to management decisions under uncertainty. Objective To develop an envirotyping-based framework that integrates genotype selection, sowing date and adaptive nitrogen (N) management and evaluate their capacity to capture water-limited yield potential under seasonal uncertainty. Methods APSIM Next Generation was used to simulate wheat production across 44 sites in low–medium rainfall zone of Australia’s Southern Grain Region over 1970–2025. Seasons were classified into four water-stress environment types (EnvTypes) based on temporal patterns of soil water deficit. The framework evaluated how genotype phenology and sowing date influenced crop exposure to EnvTypes and how fixed, deferred and adaptive N management strategies captured the resulting production opportunities. Results EnvType1 and EnvType2 were most frequent EnvTypes accounting for 34.9% and 39.5% of simulated environments, respectively. Genotype yield responses differed significantly among EnvTypes (p < 0.01), while sowing date altered the frequency of EnvType experienced by crops, demonstrating genotype × management decisions jointly shape the exposure to production opportunities. Initial soil water and soil N further modified water-limited yield and crop responsiveness. Fixed upfront N management strategies were often poorly aligned with realised seasonal opportunities, whereas adaptive N management strategies that reassessed seasonal conditions during crop development matched N supply with yield potential. These strategies typically achieved long-term median relative yields exceeding > 90% of the water-limited yield potential and frequently achieved partial gross margins comparable with N-unlimited benchmarks, particularly in high opportunity seasons. Conclusions EnvTypes provide a crop-centred representation of recurring soil water deficit trajectories rather than purely exogenous environmental states. Water availability defines the water-limited yield opportunities, soil resources determine the scope for crop responsiveness, genotype and sowing date influence the crop exposure to these opportunities, and adaptive N management determines the extent to which they are captured as seasonal uncertainty resolves. Significance This framework extends envirotyping from retrospective characterisation of genotype × environment interactions towards prospective evaluation of integrated genotype × environment × management decisions. It provides a practical basis for identifying management combinations that improve the capture of water-limited yield in rainfed cropping systems.

Field Crops ResearchVol. 351
Commonwealth Scientific and Industrial Research Organisation (AU), Flinders University (AU), South Australian Research and Development Institute (AU), The University of Adelaide (AU)
Commonwealth Scientific and Industrial Research Organisation, Grains Research and Development Corporation, University of Adelaide, South Australian Research and Development Institute
Zero hunger, Climate action
Genetics and Plant Breeding
AI Navigator

Ask Laika to Summarize, Analyze, and Connect papers live on the map.

Summarize Papers & Methodologies

Extract key findings, datasets, and comparative methods across publications.

Benchmark Rankings & Visual Analytics

Rank top research institutions, authors, funders, topics, and journals by Field-Weighted Citation Impact (FWCI) and paper volume with instant charts.

Connect Distant Disciplines

Bridge topological clusters on the map to find hidden collaborative intersections.

Laika access coming soon