“I just want them to treat me with respect and dignity, even if my paper is rejected, because it is really bad”: Ubuntu-Maaya, a relational framework to establish open and equal dialogic collaborative review practices

Abstract The applied linguistics community has recently multiplied actions (e.g., Habibie & Hultgren, 2022a ; Mackey et al., 2022 ) to foster gate-opening and collaborative peer review practices in academic publications. However, some Western editors and peer reviewers continue to exclude Francophone West African authors’ research, raising ethical concerns. Therefore, this study, framed in Ubuntu-Maaya values, examines the publishing experiences of three West Africans in Western journals. Participants participated in three focus group sessions, during which we discussed their relationships with Western editors and peer reviewers. I developed two themes and two subthemes after conducting a reflexive thematic analysis. The first theme, reviewing means to become authors’ jatigi to co-construct knowledge in dignity , describes how the peer reviewers’ compassion, hospitality, and respect foster long-term collegial relationships, whether the editorial decision is favorable or not, which enables participants to recover confidence. The second theme, reject my manuscript without rejecting my knowledge: This is humiliating , exemplifies how participants may often perceive some editors’ and peer reviewers’ practices as undermining their confidence and positioning as researchers. I discuss how the conceptualization of review practices in Western tradition, which is sometimes unidirectional and top-down, may differ from and be perceived as unethical within the Ubuntu-Maaya epistemic frame, which emphasizes the relational aspect and the dignity of all stakeholders.

Authors

Institutions

Publication Details

Journal
AILA Review
Published
2026-11-17
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1075/aila.25097.kon
Primary Topic
Publishing and Scholarly Communication
Type
article
Field-Weighted Citation Impact
0.00
Controls
|||
ALL TIME
JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
OCT
NOV
article

“I just want them to treat me with respect and dignity, even if my paper is rejected, because it is really bad”: Ubuntu-Maaya, a relational framework to establish open and equal dialogic collaborative review practices

Kadidja Koné
5 links
AILA Review
Publishing and Scholarly Communication
article

“I just want them to treat me with respect and dignity, even if my paper is rejected, because it is really bad”: Ubuntu-Maaya, a relational framework to establish open and equal dialogic collaborative review practices

Kadidja Koné
article en

Abstract

Abstract The applied linguistics community has recently multiplied actions (e.g., Habibie & Hultgren, 2022a ; Mackey et al., 2022 ) to foster gate-opening and collaborative peer review practices in academic publications. However, some Western editors and peer reviewers continue to exclude Francophone West African authors’ research, raising ethical concerns. Therefore, this study, framed in Ubuntu-Maaya values, examines the publishing experiences of three West Africans in Western journals. Participants participated in three focus group sessions, during which we discussed their relationships with Western editors and peer reviewers. I developed two themes and two subthemes after conducting a reflexive thematic analysis. The first theme, reviewing means to become authors’ jatigi to co-construct knowledge in dignity , describes how the peer reviewers’ compassion, hospitality, and respect foster long-term collegial relationships, whether the editorial decision is favorable or not, which enables participants to recover confidence. The second theme, reject my manuscript without rejecting my knowledge: This is humiliating , exemplifies how participants may often perceive some editors’ and peer reviewers’ practices as undermining their confidence and positioning as researchers. I discuss how the conceptualization of review practices in Western tradition, which is sometimes unidirectional and top-down, may differ from and be perceived as unethical within the Ubuntu-Maaya epistemic frame, which emphasizes the relational aspect and the dignity of all stakeholders.

AILA Review
École Normale Supérieure (BI), École normale d'Enseignement technique et professionnel (ML)
Publishing and Scholarly Communication
AI Navigator

Ask Laika to Summarize, Analyze, and Connect papers live on the map.

Summarize Papers & Methodologies

Extract key findings, datasets, and comparative methods across publications.

Benchmark Rankings & Visual Analytics

Rank top research institutions, authors, funders, topics, and journals by Field-Weighted Citation Impact (FWCI) and paper volume with instant charts.

Connect Distant Disciplines

Bridge topological clusters on the map to find hidden collaborative intersections.

Laika access coming soon