Project Raphael Revisited — The Loop That Holds: The First Edition's Collapse at Step 788 Withdrawn; a Fast Loop of Janus Transistors That Ignites, Holds or Lets Go; a Slow Loop of Memory That Tips into Obsession, Depends on Its History, and Heals Wh

Second edition (November 2026). It replaces the first edition (June 2026, doi:10.5281/zenodo.20688568), which reported a self-organised critical transition, a "collapse" at step 788, in a closed-loop Janus memory. That result is withdrawn, and the question behind it is asked with the series' devices: when a loop feeds back strongly enough, like a microphone near its own loudspeaker, it selects a state and holds it. Which state, for how long, and how does it let go? (1) The first edition's collapse. Rerun over 200 noise seeds, the collapse step is 974 ± 311; the map has built-in fixed points at ±1 and falls into one of them with or without noise. It is not self-organised criticality. (2) A fast loop. Two populations of Janus transistors drive each other's gates through a gain stage; the Eu trap of each gate is its own adaptation a. Above a coupling of about 0.71 a held plateau appears. It stays lit while a is below a critical value (0.41 at unit coupling, 0.26–0.56 across gain stages) and otherwise lights and goes out by itself. Cutting the loop removes it within one time constant: the state belongs to the loop, not to either half. The Janus gate has a = 0.07–0.20 and locks. (3) What the plateau holds. In a network of 100+100 transistors storing five patterns, the cue chooses the content, a stronger uncued memory never takes it, and a held loop ignores later cues (0 of 11 taken). Thinner barriers and thicker top oxides (a up to 0.48) make the loop let go, but not yet follow a stream. (4) A slow loop. In the memory loop of Ouroboros, a fresh store tips into obsession above a Ce bias of 0.09–0.12 MV/cm. Healthy fluctuations grow towards that line (detrended variance 5–8-fold). The state is path-dependent: a matured store did not tip up to 0.16 MV/cm. Erasing or resetting the store does not heal it, a reset with abstinence heals for a day and relapses, and lowering the bias heals all seeds. (5) The quantum and observer readings of the first edition are discussed as readings, not physics; lessons for systems that learn from their own output (self-trained models, recommenders, replay) are offered as hypotheses. Files: paper in English, Traditional Chinese and Japanese (the English version governs); a primer in each language; code and sources (code_and_sources.zip) reproducing every number and figure, including the first edition's code for the rerun. Computational throughout; nothing is measured. Part of the Angelica Paper Series. Licence: text and figures CC BY 4.0; code Apache-2.0. Defensive publication: disclosed as prior art, free for anyone to use and not to be patented by others. This edition replaces the first edition's licences (CC BY-NC-ND 4.0; BUSL 1.1). Keywords: attractor dynamics; persistent activity; working memory; thalamocortical loop; ignition; adaptation; saddle-node bifurcation; critical transition; early-warning signals; hysteresis; memory consolidation; model collapse; charge-trap synapse; europium; GaN HEMT; retraction; Angelica Paper Series; defensive publication

Authors

Publication Details

Journal
Zenodo (CERN European Organization for Nuclear Research)
Published
2026-11-17
DOI
https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24322595
Primary Topic
Complex Systems and Dynamics
Type
preprint
Controls
|||
ALL TIME
JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
OCT
NOV
preprint

Project Raphael Revisited — The Loop That Holds: The First Edition's Collapse at Step 788 Withdrawn; a Fast Loop of Janus Transistors That Ignites, Holds or Lets Go; a Slow Loop of Memory That Tips into Obsession, Depends on Its History, and Heals Wh

Tung Ning Liu
3 links
Zenodo (CERN European Organization for Nuclear Research)
Complex Systems and Dynamics
preprint

Project Raphael Revisited — The Loop That Holds: The First Edition's Collapse at Step 788 Withdrawn; a Fast Loop of Janus Transistors That Ignites, Holds or Lets Go; a Slow Loop of Memory That Tips into Obsession, Depends on Its History, and Heals Wh

Tung Ning Liu
preprint en

Abstract

Second edition (November 2026). It replaces the first edition (June 2026, doi:10.5281/zenodo.20688568), which reported a self-organised critical transition, a "collapse" at step 788, in a closed-loop Janus memory. That result is withdrawn, and the question behind it is asked with the series' devices: when a loop feeds back strongly enough, like a microphone near its own loudspeaker, it selects a state and holds it. Which state, for how long, and how does it let go? (1) The first edition's collapse. Rerun over 200 noise seeds, the collapse step is 974 ± 311; the map has built-in fixed points at ±1 and falls into one of them with or without noise. It is not self-organised criticality. (2) A fast loop. Two populations of Janus transistors drive each other's gates through a gain stage; the Eu trap of each gate is its own adaptation a. Above a coupling of about 0.71 a held plateau appears. It stays lit while a is below a critical value (0.41 at unit coupling, 0.26–0.56 across gain stages) and otherwise lights and goes out by itself. Cutting the loop removes it within one time constant: the state belongs to the loop, not to either half. The Janus gate has a = 0.07–0.20 and locks. (3) What the plateau holds. In a network of 100+100 transistors storing five patterns, the cue chooses the content, a stronger uncued memory never takes it, and a held loop ignores later cues (0 of 11 taken). Thinner barriers and thicker top oxides (a up to 0.48) make the loop let go, but not yet follow a stream. (4) A slow loop. In the memory loop of Ouroboros, a fresh store tips into obsession above a Ce bias of 0.09–0.12 MV/cm. Healthy fluctuations grow towards that line (detrended variance 5–8-fold). The state is path-dependent: a matured store did not tip up to 0.16 MV/cm. Erasing or resetting the store does not heal it, a reset with abstinence heals for a day and relapses, and lowering the bias heals all seeds. (5) The quantum and observer readings of the first edition are discussed as readings, not physics; lessons for systems that learn from their own output (self-trained models, recommenders, replay) are offered as hypotheses. Files: paper in English, Traditional Chinese and Japanese (the English version governs); a primer in each language; code and sources (code_and_sources.zip) reproducing every number and figure, including the first edition's code for the rerun. Computational throughout; nothing is measured. Part of the Angelica Paper Series. Licence: text and figures CC BY 4.0; code Apache-2.0. Defensive publication: disclosed as prior art, free for anyone to use and not to be patented by others. This edition replaces the first edition's licences (CC BY-NC-ND 4.0; BUSL 1.1). Keywords: attractor dynamics; persistent activity; working memory; thalamocortical loop; ignition; adaptation; saddle-node bifurcation; critical transition; early-warning signals; hysteresis; memory consolidation; model collapse; charge-trap synapse; europium; GaN HEMT; retraction; Angelica Paper Series; defensive publication

Zenodo (CERN European Organization for Nuclear Research)
Complex Systems and Dynamics
AI Navigator

Ask Laika to Summarize, Analyze, and Connect papers live on the map.

Summarize Papers & Methodologies

Extract key findings, datasets, and comparative methods across publications.

Benchmark Rankings & Visual Analytics

Rank top research institutions, authors, funders, topics, and journals by Field-Weighted Citation Impact (FWCI) and paper volume with instant charts.

Connect Distant Disciplines

Bridge topological clusters on the map to find hidden collaborative intersections.

Laika access coming soon