The Energy Case for Tier-0: A Pre-Registered, Measured Energy Frontier and System-Gating Law for a Frozen Decision Token on Microcontroller Silicon

The Energy Case for Tier-0: A Pre-Registered, Measured Energy Frontier and System-Gating Law for a Frozen Decision Token on Microcontroller Silicon Randolph James Ferlic, M.D. and Kimberly Kate Ferlic — Fieldstone Analytics, LLC, Austin, TX, USA Preprint · Zenodo DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.24322465 · CC-BY 4.0 · Community: spiral-domain-encoder-campaign · a characterization of previously published methods that are the subject of filed U.S. patent applications, measured on commodity microcontroller silicon against third-party prior-art baselines; it discloses no new algorithmic subject matter and is accompanied by no new patent application — see the notice below. Abstract The prevailing efficiency argument for a cheap edge classifier is made in FLOPs. FLOPs are an estimate; the quantity a battery pays is energy, and on a cache-poor microcontroller energy is set as much by memory traffic and duty cycle as by operation count. This paper measures, rather than estimates, the energy of a frozen, deterministic, class-discriminant single-token decision encoder against the efficient-edge frontier, on real Nordic silicon (a Cortex-M33, nRF54L15, instrumented with a Power Profiler Kit II), under two pre-registered campaigns with frozen Go/No-Go bands. The first establishes a measured energy-per-decision frontier: the 1-byte token decides in 12.3 µJ, against 19× (depthwise-separable CNN), 29× (a MicroNets-style micro-CNN), 135× (ROCKET), and 481× (an int8 "SRAM-wall" CNN the 32-bit path cannot even fit) more energy for the raw-signal neural and classical time-series frontier — a span of roughly two and a half orders of magnitude, with the token competitive or better on accuracy. A host study across ten datasets confirms the compute-proxy version (the token is Pareto-non-dominated by the neural frontier at 20–300× fewer multiply-accumulates at matched accuracy, 10 of 10) and, reported straight, its honest boundary: a trivial linear model on the same cheap features ties the token on accuracy-per-operation, so the token's defensible value over a linear baseline is not accuracy-per-FLOP but the invariant package — a deterministic ≤256-entry lookup, a one-byte output, and a built-in label-free nearest-centroid competence monitor — and the compute/energy win is specifically against the neural frontier the field reaches for. The second campaign composes the measured per-tier energies into a system-gating law: a frozen Tier-0 token in front of an expensive Tier-N stage is an energy valve that saves total system energy only below a break-even wake-rate, a closed form r* = 1 − E₀/E_N in the measured per-tier energies. We confirm the composition on silicon: an interleaved Tier-0+Tier-N sweep shows the composed per-decision energy is linear in the wake-rate to better than 0.1 % (R² = 1.000000), so the composed system costs exactly E₀ + w·E_N with no context-switch or cache overhead, and the measured break-even matches the closed form to within 0.1 % for two on-device Tier-N magnitudes. Translating the measured energies into the battery-swap/maintenance interval that dominates deployed-sensor ownership, the token-gated architecture runs for months on a coin cell where always-on deep learning runs for hours, and an operating-mode × domain map (literature-grounded cadences for seizure EEG, arrhythmia ECG, bearing vibration, wearable activity, and continuous glucose monitoring) shows that in continuous rare-event monitoring the token-triggered architecture is the only one delivering full event coverage and multi-month battery life. We then red-team the frontier across seven axes and report the results, including the ones that temper the claim: the advantage is window-length- and channel-count-dependent (≈5–29× versus the smallest CNN, 24–481× versus a real CNN, never inverting); every model's latency is bounded with under-0.2 % jitter; the ratios are preserved on a second core (slightly larger on a Cortex-M4F); the naive int8 baseline is already at the scalar-compiler ceiling (fair, not a strawman); and — a correction folded into a companion erratum — on this hardware's DC-DC buck regulator the supply energy per decision is approximately voltage-independent (≈ −8 % at 1.8 V, not the quadratic saving a linear-regulator intuition predicts). This is a characterization, on commodity hardware, of previously published, patent-pending methods against third-party prior-art baselines; it discloses no new algorithmic subject matter and is accompanied by no new patent application. The per-deployment operating-point and architecture-selection procedure is retained as trade secret. Highlights · A measured energy-per-decision frontier, not a FLOP estimate. On one Cortex-M33 the 1-byte token decides in 12.3 µJ, versus 19–481× more for the raw-signal neural / classical time-series frontier (depthwise-separable 235 µJ · micro-CNN 352 µJ · ROCKET 1.66 mJ · int8 CNN 5.92 mJ) — all at a constant, directly measured active power — with the token competitive-or-better on accuracy. · The honest boundary, reported straight. A linear model on the same cheap features ties the token on accuracy-per-operation; the token's defensible edge over a linear baseline is the invariant package (deterministic ≤256-entry lookup, one-byte output, built-in label-free monitor), and the energy win is specifically versus the neural frontier — not a claim to be the cheapest classifier that exists. · A system-gating law, confirmed on silicon. Composing the token gate with an expensive Tier-N stage is linear in the wake-rate to <0.1 % (R² = 1.000000) — no composition overhead — so the break-even wake-rate r* = 1 − E₀/E_N predicts the measured crossover to within 0.1 % for two on-device Tier-N magnitudes. · From joules to cost: a deployability flip. At 10 Hz on a coin cell the token-gated architecture runs ≈5 months between battery swaps while always-on deep learning runs ≈8 hours; across verticals by their literature-grounded cadence, token-triggering is the only architecture with full event coverage and long battery life for continuous rare-event monitoring — and the advantage is honestly moot at ultra-low cadence (e.g. glucose), where the idle floor dominates. · A worst-case, cross-core, fair-baseline frontier. Every model's latency is bounded with < 0.2 % jitter; the token-versus-neural ratios are preserved on a second core (larger on a Cortex-M4F: 33× / 517×); and compiler optimization does not improve the naive int8 baseline (it is already the scalar ceiling), so the comparison is fair, not a strawman. · Honest scoping and a self-correction. The advantage is window-length-dependent (≈5–29× versus the smallest CNN) — 29× is the long-window best case, never an inversion; and on this DC-DC-regulated part the supply energy is approximately voltage-independent, correcting a companion deposit's linear-regulator voltage estimate. No new mechanism is introduced. The frontier, in two measured tables On one Cortex-M33 the active power is directly measured constant at 2.58 mA (7.74 mW) at 3.0 V across every model, so per-decision energy is the measured active power divided by the measured throughput and any two models' energy ratio is purely their measured throughput ratio. The measured ratio exceeds the multiply-accumulate ratio, because the networks are memory-bound over large activation buffers while the token's cost is a cache-resident feature front-end. The feature-fed linear and MLP heads tie the token, locating the honest boundary; the energy win is specifically against the neural frontier. Model Input Latency/decision Energy/decision × token LR (features) 16 feats 1.37 ms 10.6 µJ 0.9× tiny-MLP (features) 16 feats 1.39 ms 10.8 µJ 0.9× token (1 byte) 16 feats 1.58 ms 12.3 µJ 1.0× dwsep-CNN (raw) 1024 samples 30.41 ms 235.3 µJ ~19× micro-CNN (raw) 1024 samples 45.05 ms 352.0 µJ ~29× ROCKET-lite (raw) 1024 samples 214.26 ms 1658.0 µJ ~135× int8 small-CNN (raw) 1024 samples 755.96 ms 5919.0 µJ ~481× Translating the measured energies into the battery-swap/maintenance interval that dominates deployed-sensor ownership gives a deployability flip: at a 10 Hz always-on cadence on a standard coin cell, the token decides for months where always-on deep learning lasts hours. The advantage grows with cadence and ceilings below ~0.8 Hz, where the model-independent idle floor (measured 9.7 µW deep-idle) dominates and all architectures converge; the absolute lives exclude sensor and radio acquisition energy (both model-independent) — the robust claim is the ratio. Model Energy/decision Coin-cell life @10 Hz vs token token (1 byte) 12.3 µJ ~145 days (~5 months) 1.0× micro-CNN (raw) 352.0 µJ ~5.5 days ~27× shorter int8 small-CNN (raw) 5919.0 µJ ~7.8 hours ~446× shorter The system-gating law, confirmed on silicon A frozen Tier-0 token in front of an expensive Tier-N stage is an energy valve: per window it costs E_gate = E₀ + w·E_N, where w = λ·TPR + (1−λ)·FPR is the wake-rate, so gating beats always-running Tier-N exactly when w < r* = 1 − E₀/E_N. A firmware sweep that interleaves the always-on token with a 1/k-fraction Tier-N invocation shows the composed per-decision time is linear in the wake-rate to better than 0.1 % (R² = 1.000000), with intercept equal to the token's own time and slope equal to the Tier-N time — no measurable context-switch or cache penalty. Because the active power is model-independent, a linear composed time is a linear composed energy. The measured break-even matches the closed form to within 0.1 % for two on-device Tier-N magnitudes (micro-CNN: measured 0.9653 vs. closed-form 0.9651; int8 small-CNN: 0.9980 vs. 0.9979); a radio-wake Tier-N (measured 16.6 µJ BLE transmit) places the break-even at an interior wake-rate of 0.

Authors

Publication Details

Journal
Zenodo (CERN European Organization for Nuclear Research)
Published
2026-11-17
DOI
https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24322464
Primary Topic
Parallel Computing and Optimization Techniques
Type
preprint
Controls
|||
ALL TIME
JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
OCT
NOV
preprint

The Energy Case for Tier-0: A Pre-Registered, Measured Energy Frontier and System-Gating Law for a Frozen Decision Token on Microcontroller Silicon

Randolph James Ferlic, Kimberly Kate Ferlic
6 links
Zenodo (CERN European Organization for Nuclear Research)
Parallel Computing and Optimization Techniques
preprint

The Energy Case for Tier-0: A Pre-Registered, Measured Energy Frontier and System-Gating Law for a Frozen Decision Token on Microcontroller Silicon

Randolph James Ferlic, Kimberly Kate Ferlic
preprint en

Abstract

The Energy Case for Tier-0: A Pre-Registered, Measured Energy Frontier and System-Gating Law for a Frozen Decision Token on Microcontroller Silicon Randolph James Ferlic, M.D. and Kimberly Kate Ferlic — Fieldstone Analytics, LLC, Austin, TX, USA Preprint · Zenodo DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.24322465 · CC-BY 4.0 · Community: spiral-domain-encoder-campaign · a characterization of previously published methods that are the subject of filed U.S. patent applications, measured on commodity microcontroller silicon against third-party prior-art baselines; it discloses no new algorithmic subject matter and is accompanied by no new patent application — see the notice below. Abstract The prevailing efficiency argument for a cheap edge classifier is made in FLOPs. FLOPs are an estimate; the quantity a battery pays is energy, and on a cache-poor microcontroller energy is set as much by memory traffic and duty cycle as by operation count. This paper measures, rather than estimates, the energy of a frozen, deterministic, class-discriminant single-token decision encoder against the efficient-edge frontier, on real Nordic silicon (a Cortex-M33, nRF54L15, instrumented with a Power Profiler Kit II), under two pre-registered campaigns with frozen Go/No-Go bands. The first establishes a measured energy-per-decision frontier: the 1-byte token decides in 12.3 µJ, against 19× (depthwise-separable CNN), 29× (a MicroNets-style micro-CNN), 135× (ROCKET), and 481× (an int8 "SRAM-wall" CNN the 32-bit path cannot even fit) more energy for the raw-signal neural and classical time-series frontier — a span of roughly two and a half orders of magnitude, with the token competitive or better on accuracy. A host study across ten datasets confirms the compute-proxy version (the token is Pareto-non-dominated by the neural frontier at 20–300× fewer multiply-accumulates at matched accuracy, 10 of 10) and, reported straight, its honest boundary: a trivial linear model on the same cheap features ties the token on accuracy-per-operation, so the token's defensible value over a linear baseline is not accuracy-per-FLOP but the invariant package — a deterministic ≤256-entry lookup, a one-byte output, and a built-in label-free nearest-centroid competence monitor — and the compute/energy win is specifically against the neural frontier the field reaches for. The second campaign composes the measured per-tier energies into a system-gating law: a frozen Tier-0 token in front of an expensive Tier-N stage is an energy valve that saves total system energy only below a break-even wake-rate, a closed form r* = 1 − E₀/E_N in the measured per-tier energies. We confirm the composition on silicon: an interleaved Tier-0+Tier-N sweep shows the composed per-decision energy is linear in the wake-rate to better than 0.1 % (R² = 1.000000), so the composed system costs exactly E₀ + w·E_N with no context-switch or cache overhead, and the measured break-even matches the closed form to within 0.1 % for two on-device Tier-N magnitudes. Translating the measured energies into the battery-swap/maintenance interval that dominates deployed-sensor ownership, the token-gated architecture runs for months on a coin cell where always-on deep learning runs for hours, and an operating-mode × domain map (literature-grounded cadences for seizure EEG, arrhythmia ECG, bearing vibration, wearable activity, and continuous glucose monitoring) shows that in continuous rare-event monitoring the token-triggered architecture is the only one delivering full event coverage and multi-month battery life. We then red-team the frontier across seven axes and report the results, including the ones that temper the claim: the advantage is window-length- and channel-count-dependent (≈5–29× versus the smallest CNN, 24–481× versus a real CNN, never inverting); every model's latency is bounded with under-0.2 % jitter; the ratios are preserved on a second core (slightly larger on a Cortex-M4F); the naive int8 baseline is already at the scalar-compiler ceiling (fair, not a strawman); and — a correction folded into a companion erratum — on this hardware's DC-DC buck regulator the supply energy per decision is approximately voltage-independent (≈ −8 % at 1.8 V, not the quadratic saving a linear-regulator intuition predicts). This is a characterization, on commodity hardware, of previously published, patent-pending methods against third-party prior-art baselines; it discloses no new algorithmic subject matter and is accompanied by no new patent application. The per-deployment operating-point and architecture-selection procedure is retained as trade secret. Highlights · A measured energy-per-decision frontier, not a FLOP estimate. On one Cortex-M33 the 1-byte token decides in 12.3 µJ, versus 19–481× more for the raw-signal neural / classical time-series frontier (depthwise-separable 235 µJ · micro-CNN 352 µJ · ROCKET 1.66 mJ · int8 CNN 5.92 mJ) — all at a constant, directly measured active power — with the token competitive-or-better on accuracy. · The honest boundary, reported straight. A linear model on the same cheap features ties the token on accuracy-per-operation; the token's defensible edge over a linear baseline is the invariant package (deterministic ≤256-entry lookup, one-byte output, built-in label-free monitor), and the energy win is specifically versus the neural frontier — not a claim to be the cheapest classifier that exists. · A system-gating law, confirmed on silicon. Composing the token gate with an expensive Tier-N stage is linear in the wake-rate to <0.1 % (R² = 1.000000) — no composition overhead — so the break-even wake-rate r* = 1 − E₀/E_N predicts the measured crossover to within 0.1 % for two on-device Tier-N magnitudes. · From joules to cost: a deployability flip. At 10 Hz on a coin cell the token-gated architecture runs ≈5 months between battery swaps while always-on deep learning runs ≈8 hours; across verticals by their literature-grounded cadence, token-triggering is the only architecture with full event coverage and long battery life for continuous rare-event monitoring — and the advantage is honestly moot at ultra-low cadence (e.g. glucose), where the idle floor dominates. · A worst-case, cross-core, fair-baseline frontier. Every model's latency is bounded with < 0.2 % jitter; the token-versus-neural ratios are preserved on a second core (larger on a Cortex-M4F: 33× / 517×); and compiler optimization does not improve the naive int8 baseline (it is already the scalar ceiling), so the comparison is fair, not a strawman. · Honest scoping and a self-correction. The advantage is window-length-dependent (≈5–29× versus the smallest CNN) — 29× is the long-window best case, never an inversion; and on this DC-DC-regulated part the supply energy is approximately voltage-independent, correcting a companion deposit's linear-regulator voltage estimate. No new mechanism is introduced. The frontier, in two measured tables On one Cortex-M33 the active power is directly measured constant at 2.58 mA (7.74 mW) at 3.0 V across every model, so per-decision energy is the measured active power divided by the measured throughput and any two models' energy ratio is purely their measured throughput ratio. The measured ratio exceeds the multiply-accumulate ratio, because the networks are memory-bound over large activation buffers while the token's cost is a cache-resident feature front-end. The feature-fed linear and MLP heads tie the token, locating the honest boundary; the energy win is specifically against the neural frontier. Model Input Latency/decision Energy/decision × token LR (features) 16 feats 1.37 ms 10.6 µJ 0.9× tiny-MLP (features) 16 feats 1.39 ms 10.8 µJ 0.9× token (1 byte) 16 feats 1.58 ms 12.3 µJ 1.0× dwsep-CNN (raw) 1024 samples 30.41 ms 235.3 µJ ~19× micro-CNN (raw) 1024 samples 45.05 ms 352.0 µJ ~29× ROCKET-lite (raw) 1024 samples 214.26 ms 1658.0 µJ ~135× int8 small-CNN (raw) 1024 samples 755.96 ms 5919.0 µJ ~481× Translating the measured energies into the battery-swap/maintenance interval that dominates deployed-sensor ownership gives a deployability flip: at a 10 Hz always-on cadence on a standard coin cell, the token decides for months where always-on deep learning lasts hours. The advantage grows with cadence and ceilings below ~0.8 Hz, where the model-independent idle floor (measured 9.7 µW deep-idle) dominates and all architectures converge; the absolute lives exclude sensor and radio acquisition energy (both model-independent) — the robust claim is the ratio. Model Energy/decision Coin-cell life @10 Hz vs token token (1 byte) 12.3 µJ ~145 days (~5 months) 1.0× micro-CNN (raw) 352.0 µJ ~5.5 days ~27× shorter int8 small-CNN (raw) 5919.0 µJ ~7.8 hours ~446× shorter The system-gating law, confirmed on silicon A frozen Tier-0 token in front of an expensive Tier-N stage is an energy valve: per window it costs E_gate = E₀ + w·E_N, where w = λ·TPR + (1−λ)·FPR is the wake-rate, so gating beats always-running Tier-N exactly when w < r* = 1 − E₀/E_N. A firmware sweep that interleaves the always-on token with a 1/k-fraction Tier-N invocation shows the composed per-decision time is linear in the wake-rate to better than 0.1 % (R² = 1.000000), with intercept equal to the token's own time and slope equal to the Tier-N time — no measurable context-switch or cache penalty. Because the active power is model-independent, a linear composed time is a linear composed energy. The measured break-even matches the closed form to within 0.1 % for two on-device Tier-N magnitudes (micro-CNN: measured 0.9653 vs. closed-form 0.9651; int8 small-CNN: 0.9980 vs. 0.9979); a radio-wake Tier-N (measured 16.6 µJ BLE transmit) places the break-even at an interior wake-rate of 0.

Zenodo (CERN European Organization for Nuclear Research)
Parallel Computing and Optimization Techniques
AI Navigator

Ask Laika to Summarize, Analyze, and Connect papers live on the map.

Summarize Papers & Methodologies

Extract key findings, datasets, and comparative methods across publications.

Benchmark Rankings & Visual Analytics

Rank top research institutions, authors, funders, topics, and journals by Field-Weighted Citation Impact (FWCI) and paper volume with instant charts.

Connect Distant Disciplines

Bridge topological clusters on the map to find hidden collaborative intersections.

Laika access coming soon