The Field Coordination Residual Hypothesis: Can Mission-Relative Relational Analysis Reveal Coordination Failures Beyond Conventional Multi-Agent Models?
Multi-agent artificial-intelligence systems can produce convincing local success reports while leaving business objectives incomplete, misattributing the origin of a breakdown, or recommending repairs that are insufficiently authorized or evidenced. This conceptual paper formulates the Field Coordination Residual Hypothesis (FCRH): a mission-relative relational representation may, in certain bounded settings, improve the practical quality, total decision cost, or independent auditability of coordination-failure diagnosis compared with an information-matched conventional system. A Field is defined here as an optional representation of mission obligations, actors, dependencies, evidence, authority, and admissible transitions—not a novel physical entity or independently established computational ontology. The paper distinguishes detection, causal attribution, decision triage, evidence acquisition, intervention qualification, and post hoc reconstruction. It specifies a diagnostic identifiability boundary, matched-resource loss estimands, mission-switch pairs, equivalence conditions, and a prospective adversarial benchmark with strong baselines based on provenance, causal graphs, conformance checking, selective prediction, and cost-aware diagnosis. A processing-of-information argument precludes any claim that a deterministic Field transformation of the same evidence confers intrinsic informational superiority. Illustrative numerical examples expose confounding by baseline weakness, amortization, and unequal evidence; they are not empirical observations. The defensible contribution is a falsifiable evaluation constitution and a carefully delimited hypothesis about possible operational value. No Field-specific advantage, novel causal mechanism, independent experimental validation, or generalizable effect has yet been demonstrated. Explicit limitations and a prioritized research agenda specify what evidence would be required to support, constrain, or reject the hypothesis.
Authors
- Rogério Figurelli (ORCID: https://orcid.org/0009-0002-5726-1765)
Publication Details
- Journal
- Zenodo (CERN European Organization for Nuclear Research)
- Published
- 2026-11-17
- DOI
- https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24325556
- Primary Topic
- Multi-Agent Systems and Negotiation
- Type
- preprint