False-Positive Scar Control in Scribble-Supervised LGE-CMR Segmentation Using an Asymmetric Intensity Prior

Background: Scribble-supervised LGE-CMR segmentation can overestimate myocardial scar. Methods: We introduced an asymmetric intensity prior that penalizes predicted scar darker than a scribble-derived reference. We evaluated 36 patient-disjoint test cases using reference myocardium-guided crops and performed separate reference-free central-crop and automatic-myocardial-wall analyses. The main prior-specific comparison matched the 2.5D backbone with and without the prior across three seeds. Results: On the pre-cropped images, mean Dice increased from 0.5328±0.0108 to 0.5472±0.0060, while recall fell from 0.6924 to 0.6399. The predicted-to-reference scar ratio fell from 1.6796±0.1834 to 1.4039±0.1389, and absolute scar-volume error fell from 21.09±5.27 to 14.08±2.47 mL on the common crop grid. However, restriction to the reference myocardial wall increased absolute percent-LV-scar error from 5.55±1.14 to 6.58±0.99 percentage points. With additional healthy-myocardium background points (seed 2022), the matched prior model reduced Pred/GT from 1.5789 to 1.1500 but Dice fell from 0.5441 to 0.5366. With one fixed-rule reference-free central crop and retraining (seed 2022), Dice was 0.4892 without and 0.5047 with the prior. In a paired automatic-wall analysis, the prior did not improve three-seed wall-restricted burden error (6.14 versus 8.16 percentage points). Conclusions: The prior reduced full-output overestimation on the pre-cropped images, but did not improve intramyocardial burden agreement or retain a Dice advantage in the single-seed healthy-background sensitivity analysis. Its effects depend on localization and wall quality and require independent prospective reference-free evaluation.

Authors

Institutions

Publication Details

Journal
Journal of Cardiovascular Development and Disease
Published
2026-11-17
DOI
https://doi.org/10.3390/jcdd13110605
Primary Topic
Medical Image Segmentation Techniques
Type
article
Field-Weighted Citation Impact
0.00

Funders

Controls
|||
ALL TIME
JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
OCT
NOV
article

False-Positive Scar Control in Scribble-Supervised LGE-CMR Segmentation Using an Asymmetric Intensity Prior

Xin Lan, Qitong Zhang, Wangbin Ding, Chenming Zhao et al.
3 links
Journal of Cardiovascular Development and Disease
Medical Image Segmentation Techniques
article

False-Positive Scar Control in Scribble-Supervised LGE-CMR Segmentation Using an Asymmetric Intensity Prior

Xin Lan, Qitong Zhang, Wangbin Ding, Chenming Zhao, Shimei Fu, Xinchen Xie, Jinwei Dong
article en

Abstract

Background: Scribble-supervised LGE-CMR segmentation can overestimate myocardial scar. Methods: We introduced an asymmetric intensity prior that penalizes predicted scar darker than a scribble-derived reference. We evaluated 36 patient-disjoint test cases using reference myocardium-guided crops and performed separate reference-free central-crop and automatic-myocardial-wall analyses. The main prior-specific comparison matched the 2.5D backbone with and without the prior across three seeds. Results: On the pre-cropped images, mean Dice increased from 0.5328±0.0108 to 0.5472±0.0060, while recall fell from 0.6924 to 0.6399. The predicted-to-reference scar ratio fell from 1.6796±0.1834 to 1.4039±0.1389, and absolute scar-volume error fell from 21.09±5.27 to 14.08±2.47 mL on the common crop grid. However, restriction to the reference myocardial wall increased absolute percent-LV-scar error from 5.55±1.14 to 6.58±0.99 percentage points. With additional healthy-myocardium background points (seed 2022), the matched prior model reduced Pred/GT from 1.5789 to 1.1500 but Dice fell from 0.5441 to 0.5366. With one fixed-rule reference-free central crop and retraining (seed 2022), Dice was 0.4892 without and 0.5047 with the prior. In a paired automatic-wall analysis, the prior did not improve three-seed wall-restricted burden error (6.14 versus 8.16 percentage points). Conclusions: The prior reduced full-output overestimation on the pre-cropped images, but did not improve intramyocardial burden agreement or retain a Dice advantage in the single-seed healthy-background sensitivity analysis. Its effects depend on localization and wall quality and require independent prospective reference-free evaluation.

Journal of Cardiovascular Development and DiseaseVol. 13(11)
Fujian University of Traditional Chinese Medicine (CN), Fujian Medical University (CN), National University of Singapore (SG), Fujian Provincial Cancer Hospital (CN), Fuzhou University (CN)
Fujian Medical University
Good health and well-being
Medical Image Segmentation Techniques
AI Navigator

Ask Laika to Summarize, Analyze, and Connect papers live on the map.

Summarize Papers & Methodologies

Extract key findings, datasets, and comparative methods across publications.

Benchmark Rankings & Visual Analytics

Rank top research institutions, authors, funders, topics, and journals by Field-Weighted Citation Impact (FWCI) and paper volume with instant charts.

Connect Distant Disciplines

Bridge topological clusters on the map to find hidden collaborative intersections.

Laika access coming soon