The qutrit value of the determinant dimension witness with independent devices is 3√3/4

Preprint, version 2 (17 November 2026); not peer reviewed. Version 2 adds a section on finite statistics; the theorems and proofs are unchanged from version 1. Bowles, Quintino and Brunner (Phys. Rev. Lett. 112, 140407 (2014)) introduced a nonlinear dimension witness for prepare-and-measure experiments with independent devices: four preparations, two binary measurements, and W2 = |det D|, where D is the 2×2 matrix of differences of outcome probabilities. Classical bits give W2 = 0, qubits and classical trits give at most 1, and systems of dimension four reach the algebraic maximum 2. For qutrits they reported, from numerical analysis, W2 ≤ 1.299. We prove that the qutrit maximum is exactly 3√3/4 = 1.29903…, over all mixed states and all binary measurements. More precisely, for measurements given by rank-one projectors (or their complements) with overlap c, the maximum is √(1−c)(1+√c) for every c in [0,1], and it is largest at c = 1/4. The proof is elementary: it reduces the problem to the plane of the two measurement vectors and a convex body of probability pairs, and it shows where dimension three is used. We also give a short proof of the classical-trit bound 1. Consequently, if the noise does not depend on the preparation and scales every probability difference by the same visibility η (white noise on the states is an example), the optimal qutrit strategy excludes qubits and all classical trits exactly when η > (4/(3√3))^(1/2) = 0.87738…. This threshold holds only for that noise model; it is not a tolerance to arbitrary experimental imperfections. For finite data we give a rigorous interval test. Under independent, identically distributed trials it certifies W2 > 1 at confidence 1 − 10⁻³, with probability 0.9, using about 650 trials per setting for noiseless data and about 2.4·10⁴ per setting at η = 0.9. A plain z-test on the determinant estimator is shown not to be a valid certificate. The proof was checked symbolically, its extremal cases were certified by a branch-and-bound computation, and it was confirmed by two blind re-derivations by a separate AI instance, with negative controls. These re-derivations are cross-checks by a separate instance of the same language model, not verification by a human referee. Files: the preprint, and a reproducibility archive with: the preregistrations and addenda, the proof notes and the literature check; exact SymPy checks of every formula in the note; the certified branch-and-bound check; both blind re-verifications with their specifications, reports and manifests; the finite-statistics study (new in version 2); all run logs, including crashed, capped, superseded and degenerate-control runs, labelled as such; verify.sh. The theorems rest on the written proofs; the scripts check identities, explicit strategies, finite enumerations, finitely many parameter values and simulated error rates.

Authors

Publication Details

Journal
Zenodo (CERN European Organization for Nuclear Research)
Published
2026-11-17
DOI
https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24302455
Primary Topic
Quantum Mechanics and Applications
Type
preprint
Controls
|||
ALL TIME
JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
OCT
NOV
preprint

The qutrit value of the determinant dimension witness with independent devices is 3√3/4

Vasily Psykovsky
2 links
Zenodo (CERN European Organization for Nuclear Research)
Quantum Mechanics and Applications
preprint

The qutrit value of the determinant dimension witness with independent devices is 3√3/4

Vasily Psykovsky
preprint en

Abstract

Preprint, version 2 (17 November 2026); not peer reviewed. Version 2 adds a section on finite statistics; the theorems and proofs are unchanged from version 1. Bowles, Quintino and Brunner (Phys. Rev. Lett. 112, 140407 (2014)) introduced a nonlinear dimension witness for prepare-and-measure experiments with independent devices: four preparations, two binary measurements, and W2 = |det D|, where D is the 2×2 matrix of differences of outcome probabilities. Classical bits give W2 = 0, qubits and classical trits give at most 1, and systems of dimension four reach the algebraic maximum 2. For qutrits they reported, from numerical analysis, W2 ≤ 1.299. We prove that the qutrit maximum is exactly 3√3/4 = 1.29903…, over all mixed states and all binary measurements. More precisely, for measurements given by rank-one projectors (or their complements) with overlap c, the maximum is √(1−c)(1+√c) for every c in [0,1], and it is largest at c = 1/4. The proof is elementary: it reduces the problem to the plane of the two measurement vectors and a convex body of probability pairs, and it shows where dimension three is used. We also give a short proof of the classical-trit bound 1. Consequently, if the noise does not depend on the preparation and scales every probability difference by the same visibility η (white noise on the states is an example), the optimal qutrit strategy excludes qubits and all classical trits exactly when η > (4/(3√3))^(1/2) = 0.87738…. This threshold holds only for that noise model; it is not a tolerance to arbitrary experimental imperfections. For finite data we give a rigorous interval test. Under independent, identically distributed trials it certifies W2 > 1 at confidence 1 − 10⁻³, with probability 0.9, using about 650 trials per setting for noiseless data and about 2.4·10⁴ per setting at η = 0.9. A plain z-test on the determinant estimator is shown not to be a valid certificate. The proof was checked symbolically, its extremal cases were certified by a branch-and-bound computation, and it was confirmed by two blind re-derivations by a separate AI instance, with negative controls. These re-derivations are cross-checks by a separate instance of the same language model, not verification by a human referee. Files: the preprint, and a reproducibility archive with: the preregistrations and addenda, the proof notes and the literature check; exact SymPy checks of every formula in the note; the certified branch-and-bound check; both blind re-verifications with their specifications, reports and manifests; the finite-statistics study (new in version 2); all run logs, including crashed, capped, superseded and degenerate-control runs, labelled as such; verify.sh. The theorems rest on the written proofs; the scripts check identities, explicit strategies, finite enumerations, finitely many parameter values and simulated error rates.

Zenodo (CERN European Organization for Nuclear Research)
Quantum Mechanics and Applications
AI Navigator

Ask Laika to Summarize, Analyze, and Connect papers live on the map.

Summarize Papers & Methodologies

Extract key findings, datasets, and comparative methods across publications.

Benchmark Rankings & Visual Analytics

Rank top research institutions, authors, funders, topics, and journals by Field-Weighted Citation Impact (FWCI) and paper volume with instant charts.

Connect Distant Disciplines

Bridge topological clusters on the map to find hidden collaborative intersections.

Laika access coming soon