Chronic Ankle Instability: An Evidence-Based Framework of Constitutional and Consequential Determinants

Objective: To systematically review the literature on determinants of chronic ankle instability (CAI), grade the evidence for each, and organize the findings within the 2019 Hertel and Corbett model as constitutional (present before the first sprain) or consequential (possibly acquired after the first sprain). Study Selection: Included study designs were 1) comparing people with CAI, functional or mechanical instability, or recurrent sprains to people without instability, 2) prospective cohorts measuring factors before an incident sprain or CAI, 3) case series of people with instability. Of 410 full-text articles assessed, 138 studies were included. Data Extraction: Statistically significant associations, with study design and risk of bias. Each association ( in-depth determinant ) was grouped into research determinants , which may require laboratory measurement, and clinical determinants , identifiable by history, examination, questionnaires or routine imaging; research determinants received levels of evidence and grades of recommendation. Data Synthesis: Of 402 associations extracted from the 138 studies, 353 were retained as in-depth determinants and grouped into 43 research determinants and 26 clinical determinants . Each were graded for level of evidence. Fifteen research determinants were constitutional and 34 consequential; 6 were found on both sides (constitutional and consequential) and were graded separately on each side, giving 49 grades. None was A (consistent Level I studies); 25 were B (consistent Level II or III studies), 11 C (conflicting or lower-level studies) and 13 I (single study). Most evidence came from cross-sectional or case-control comparisons of people with and without instability (114 studies, Level III); only 4 publications from 3 cohorts followed patients from a first sprain to development of CAI. Conclusions: The evidence on determinants of CAI is broad but mostly based on case-control. Therefore the current body of literature describes the clinical picture of established instability rather than its pathogenesis. The proposed framework retains the components of the 2019 model, organizes the evidence along a constitutional-consequential axis, and identifies the candidate determinants that cohorts recruited at the first sprain should test.

Authors

Institutions

Publication Details

Published
2026-11-17
DOI
https://doi.org/10.51224/sportrxiv.1147
Primary Topic
Foot and Ankle Surgery
Type
preprint
Controls
|||
ALL TIME
JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
OCT
NOV
preprint

Chronic Ankle Instability: An Evidence-Based Framework of Constitutional and Consequential Determinants

Jay N. Hertel, Matthieu Lalevée, Elisabeth Bubay, Eli Schmidt
1 links
Foot and Ankle Surgery
preprint

Chronic Ankle Instability: An Evidence-Based Framework of Constitutional and Consequential Determinants

Jay N. Hertel, Matthieu Lalevée, Elisabeth Bubay, Eli Schmidt
preprint en

Abstract

Objective: To systematically review the literature on determinants of chronic ankle instability (CAI), grade the evidence for each, and organize the findings within the 2019 Hertel and Corbett model as constitutional (present before the first sprain) or consequential (possibly acquired after the first sprain). Study Selection: Included study designs were 1) comparing people with CAI, functional or mechanical instability, or recurrent sprains to people without instability, 2) prospective cohorts measuring factors before an incident sprain or CAI, 3) case series of people with instability. Of 410 full-text articles assessed, 138 studies were included. Data Extraction: Statistically significant associations, with study design and risk of bias. Each association ( in-depth determinant ) was grouped into research determinants , which may require laboratory measurement, and clinical determinants , identifiable by history, examination, questionnaires or routine imaging; research determinants received levels of evidence and grades of recommendation. Data Synthesis: Of 402 associations extracted from the 138 studies, 353 were retained as in-depth determinants and grouped into 43 research determinants and 26 clinical determinants . Each were graded for level of evidence. Fifteen research determinants were constitutional and 34 consequential; 6 were found on both sides (constitutional and consequential) and were graded separately on each side, giving 49 grades. None was A (consistent Level I studies); 25 were B (consistent Level II or III studies), 11 C (conflicting or lower-level studies) and 13 I (single study). Most evidence came from cross-sectional or case-control comparisons of people with and without instability (114 studies, Level III); only 4 publications from 3 cohorts followed patients from a first sprain to development of CAI. Conclusions: The evidence on determinants of CAI is broad but mostly based on case-control. Therefore the current body of literature describes the clinical picture of established instability rather than its pathogenesis. The proposed framework retains the components of the 2019 model, organizes the evidence along a constitutional-consequential axis, and identifies the candidate determinants that cohorts recruited at the first sprain should test.

University of Minnesota (US), Centre Hospitalier Universitaire de Rouen (FR), University of Virginia (US)
Good health and well-being
Foot and Ankle Surgery
AI Navigator

Ask Laika to Summarize, Analyze, and Connect papers live on the map.

Summarize Papers & Methodologies

Extract key findings, datasets, and comparative methods across publications.

Benchmark Rankings & Visual Analytics

Rank top research institutions, authors, funders, topics, and journals by Field-Weighted Citation Impact (FWCI) and paper volume with instant charts.

Connect Distant Disciplines

Bridge topological clusters on the map to find hidden collaborative intersections.

Laika access coming soon