Fluctuations in quantum heat: exact decompositions, interpretations, bounds, and limitations of a conjectured ordering
Recently, Ref.~ studied fluctuations in quantum heat derived from the Kirkwood–Dirac quasiprobability distribution, denoted by v a r ( Q m ) here, in the context of quantum measurement-based engines and batteries. In particular, in addition to two upper bounds, two lower bounds, denoted by L o w B v and L o w B v ′ , on fluctuations in quantum heat were derived for arbitrary quantum measurements . It was then conjectured that L o w B v ′ ≥ L o w B v for quantum systems initially prepared in thermal equilibrium and subsequently evolved by nonselective quantum projective measurement channels (NQPMCs). Motivated by this conjecture, we first derive several new equivalent expressions for v a r ( Q m ) , providing new mathematical and physical perspectives on this quantity. These reformulations lead to new upper and lower bounds on v a r ( Q m ) , some of which can improve upon previously derived bounds in Ref.~, depending on the parameters. In particular, one reformulation shows that v a r ( Q m ) can be written as the sum of the variance of the heat operator in the premeasurement state and the variance of the same heat operator in the postmeasurement state. This shows that the previously derived lower bounds in Ref.~ can be established without invoking the Kadison–Schwarz inequality, resulting in simpler proofs. Regarding the conjecture, we prove that it can be violated. However, we also prove that, for a given Hamiltonian, if its block-diagonal decomposition with respect to mutually orthogonal subspaces is such that each Hamiltonian block fails to commute with at most two projectors of arbitrary rank from the set of projectors associated with the NQPMC, then the conjectured ordering holds independently of the state of the quantum system. When only two projectors of arbitrary rank are associated with the NQPMC, the conjectured ordering holds for any quantum system, independently of the state and the Hamiltonian, with the qubit case being a particular instance. We also show how these results can be extended to the variance of arbitrary, not necessarily Hermitian, operators. Moreover, Monte Carlo simulations, using 10 7 realizations for Hilbert spaces of dimensions 3 , 7 , and 11 , show that violations of the conjectured ordering can become less frequent as the dimension increases, although the conjecture can still be violated. This suggests that there may be additional conditions under which the inequality L o w B v ′ ≥ L o w B v is guaranteed, although identifying such conditions remains an open question. Finally, we generalize the expression for fluctuations in quantum heat to situations involving successive NQPMCs or probabilistic mixtures of NQPMCs, obtaining compact analytical expressions for the corresponding fluctuations and their bounds, together with a physical interpretation of each term.
Authors
- Abdelkader El Makouri (ORCID: https://orcid.org/0000-0003-1539-851X)
Publication Details
- Journal
- APS Open Science
- Published
- 2026-11-17
- DOI
- https://doi.org/10.1103/px7s-fv69
- Primary Topic
- Advanced Thermodynamics and Statistical Mechanics
- Type
- article
- Field-Weighted Citation Impact
- 0.00