What Are the Useful Characteristics of Synthetic Data? A Qualitative Study of Researcher Perspectives

IntroductionWhen access to real data is restricted by confidentiality requirements and lengthy approval procedures, researchers may consider ways to support their work prior to seeking access, such as using synthetic data. This is often the case with administrative datasets that contain sensitive information about individuals' interactions with government systems, including health, education, justice, benefits and income. While such datasets are highly valuable for research, they are typically securely held and strictly controlled. Synthetic data is increasingly being used to support the use of real-world data across various research activities. To optimise synthetic data creation and use, it is essential to define and assess its characteristics and understand how they relate to utility. While frameworks exist for understanding real data quality and utility, approaches to synthetic data characterisation remain limited, with a predominant focus on statistical fidelity. ObjectivesOur study aimed to identify which characteristics of synthetic data are important for utility from researchers' perspectives, the contexts in which they see benefits and what is needed to enable optimal use. MethodsDrawing on real data quality frameworks, we conducted interviews with the researchers to explore their opinions and experiences using secure real data and synthetic versions. We interviewed 19 researchers with experience using secure administrative or health data for research, of whom 18 had some experience using synthetic data. Interviews were analysed qualitatively to identify key themes. ResultsWe uncovered four areas of interest: (1) barriers to real data access, such as discoverability and governance; (2) versatility of synthetic data use cases, including research planning, education and collaboration; (3) dependencies affecting adoption, such as governance, cost, quality, suitability for use cases and safety; and (4) an underdeveloped ecosystem due to uncertainty in synthetic data usefulness, a lack of clarity on use and limited available information, which reduces confidence in synthetic data provision. ConclusionsBased on our findings, we propose an initial synthetic data characterisation framework emphasising the relationship between synthetic and real data and the context of intended use. We recommend that synthetic data is developed with clear use cases, meets quality requirements, is well-documented, accessible and discoverable and is provided safely under proportionate governance. Embedding mechanisms for improvement, such as feedback loops and regular review, would further optimise the value and benefits of synthetic data for both providers and users.

Authors

Institutions

Publication Details

Journal
International Journal for Population Data Science
Published
2026-11-17
DOI
https://doi.org/10.23889/ijpds.v11i1.3406
Primary Topic
Privacy-Preserving Technologies in Data
Type
article
Field-Weighted Citation Impact
0.00
Controls
|||
ALL TIME
JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
OCT
NOV
article

What Are the Useful Characteristics of Synthetic Data? A Qualitative Study of Researcher Perspectives

Emily Oliver, Lora Frayling, Elizabeth Pattinson
5 links
International Journal for Population Data Science
Privacy-Preserving Technologies in Data
article

What Are the Useful Characteristics of Synthetic Data? A Qualitative Study of Researcher Perspectives

Emily Oliver, Lora Frayling, Elizabeth Pattinson
article en

Abstract

IntroductionWhen access to real data is restricted by confidentiality requirements and lengthy approval procedures, researchers may consider ways to support their work prior to seeking access, such as using synthetic data. This is often the case with administrative datasets that contain sensitive information about individuals' interactions with government systems, including health, education, justice, benefits and income. While such datasets are highly valuable for research, they are typically securely held and strictly controlled. Synthetic data is increasingly being used to support the use of real-world data across various research activities. To optimise synthetic data creation and use, it is essential to define and assess its characteristics and understand how they relate to utility. While frameworks exist for understanding real data quality and utility, approaches to synthetic data characterisation remain limited, with a predominant focus on statistical fidelity. ObjectivesOur study aimed to identify which characteristics of synthetic data are important for utility from researchers' perspectives, the contexts in which they see benefits and what is needed to enable optimal use. MethodsDrawing on real data quality frameworks, we conducted interviews with the researchers to explore their opinions and experiences using secure real data and synthetic versions. We interviewed 19 researchers with experience using secure administrative or health data for research, of whom 18 had some experience using synthetic data. Interviews were analysed qualitatively to identify key themes. ResultsWe uncovered four areas of interest: (1) barriers to real data access, such as discoverability and governance; (2) versatility of synthetic data use cases, including research planning, education and collaboration; (3) dependencies affecting adoption, such as governance, cost, quality, suitability for use cases and safety; and (4) an underdeveloped ecosystem due to uncertainty in synthetic data usefulness, a lack of clarity on use and limited available information, which reduces confidence in synthetic data provision. ConclusionsBased on our findings, we propose an initial synthetic data characterisation framework emphasising the relationship between synthetic and real data and the context of intended use. We recommend that synthetic data is developed with clear use cases, meets quality requirements, is well-documented, accessible and discoverable and is provided safely under proportionate governance. Embedding mechanisms for improvement, such as feedback loops and regular review, would further optimise the value and benefits of synthetic data for both providers and users.

International Journal for Population Data ScienceVol. 11(1)
Fulbourn Hospital (GB), Economic and Social Research Council (GB)
Privacy-Preserving Technologies in Data
AI Navigator

Ask Laika to Summarize, Analyze, and Connect papers live on the map.

Summarize Papers & Methodologies

Extract key findings, datasets, and comparative methods across publications.

Benchmark Rankings & Visual Analytics

Rank top research institutions, authors, funders, topics, and journals by Field-Weighted Citation Impact (FWCI) and paper volume with instant charts.

Connect Distant Disciplines

Bridge topological clusters on the map to find hidden collaborative intersections.

Laika access coming soon