Bridging the recovery gap: a qualitative comparative study of service failure, complaint behaviour and service recovery across public and private hospitals in Nigeria
Abstract Background Service failures are an inevitable feature of healthcare delivery, but hospitals differ in their capacity to recover without compounding the original harm. In Nigeria, public hospitals operate under the SERVICOM service-delivery and complaint-resolution framework, although implementation is uneven across facilities. Private hospitals, in contrast, generally employ internally developed complaint-handling and service-recovery mechanisms. How patients and providers experience and enact service recovery across these sectors remains poorly understood. This study explored service failures and complaint handling from both perspectives in public and private hospitals in Ilorin, Nigeria. Methods We used a qualitative comparative study design, including semi-structured interviews with 10 healthcare providers and 14 patients, purposively sampled across both sectors. Data were analysed using Framework Analysis. Themes emerged inductively from participants' accounts and were then interpreted deductively in relation to Justice Theory and the Service Recovery Paradox. Results Six themes emerged, spanning definitional understanding, service failure experiences, complaint behaviour, provider responses, recovery outcomes, and institutional capacity. Patient and provider accounts in the private sector were more closely aligned, whereas those in the public sector showed greater divergence. Public-sector providers described defined complaint-handling procedures, but patients often avoided formal complaints for fear of reprisal from staff on whom they depended for ongoing care. Continued attendance at public hospitals was often driven by affordability, while isolated praise for individual clinicians coexisted with low institutional trust. Recovery practices also differed: private-sector providers described tangible forms of redress, including waived costs, whereas public-sector responses were predominantly verbal or procedural. Across sectors, perceptions of distributive, procedural, and interactional justice appeared to shape whether recovery restored trust or compounded the original failure. Conclusion Formal recovery protocols do not necessarily translate into felt resolution, particularly where power asymmetry constrains patient voice and financial constraints limit patients' ability to switch providers. The findings suggest that the conditions underpinning the service recovery paradox may not readily apply in the public-sector context studied. Effective service recovery therefore requires more than formal complaint mechanisms; it also depends on reducing barriers to patient voice, strengthening trust, and ensuring that recovery is experienced as timely, fair, and responsive.
Authors
- Abiodun Ebenezer Kolapo
- Michael Sunday Oguntoye
- Olubusayo Elizabeth Kolapo
Institutions
- University of Ibadan (NG)
- Primary Health Care (QA)
- National Primary Health Care Development Agency (NG)
Publication Details
- Journal
- Research Square
- Published
- 2026-11-17
- DOI
- https://doi.org/10.21203/rs.3.rs-11253269/v1
- Primary Topic
- Customer Service Quality and Loyalty
- Type
- preprint