Evaluating distributed construction with life cycle assessment: a scenario-based comparative study of construction-stage environmental impacts

Abstract Purpose Distributed construction (DC) decentralizes fabrication and assembly across multiple locations while planning and coordination remain centralized. Empirical data on its construction-stage greenhouse gas impacts relative to conventional construction and traditional modular construction are limited. This study addresses this gap by providing a scenario-based comparative life cycle assessment of DC’s construction-stage environmental performance using a U.S. hospitality project. Methods The study develops an attributional, comparative evaluation of life cycle greenhouse gas emissions (GHG) for a newly built hotel in Alpharetta, Georgia. The study evaluates three construction and production configurations: conventional construction (CC), traditional modular construction (TM), and a modeled distributed construction (DC) scenario that differs from TM mainly in its production and logistics network. The functional unit is the complete hotel project, with results also normalized per guestroom and per unit floor area. The system boundary follows EN 15978 production and construction stages A1–A5 and includes material production, transportation, construction energy and water use, and material impacts associated with construction waste. Scenario development draws on project documentation, published literature, industry presentations, professional meetings, and explicitly documented scenario assumptions. Sensitivity analysis examines key assumptions, including transport distance, facility proximity, payload and backhaul treatment, material-loss factors, construction duration, and energy intensity. Results and discussion Under the modeled assumptions, the DC scenario has the lowest modeled construction-stage A1–A5 GHG emissions among the three scenarios. Total A1–A5 emissions are approximately 1,168 t CO₂e for CC, 1,055 t CO₂e for TM, and 1,004 t CO₂e for DC, representing estimated reductions of 14% relative to CC and 5% relative to TM. DC’s incremental advantage over TM mainly comes from lower transportation and construction energy- and water-related impacts. Modeled material impacts are identical for TM and DC and about 8% higher than for CC because of the double-layer module walls, and DC waste-associated impacts are slightly higher than TM because of the additional kitting-stage loss. The advantage relative to CC depends strongly on the assumed CC site material-loss factor; TM no longer has lower emissions than CC when the CC site loss falls below approximately 15%. Sensitivity analysis indicates that transportation performance depends heavily on facility proximity; under the current route, payload, and return-trip assumptions, DC transportation emissions reach parity with TM at a Rapid Plant-to-site distance of approximately 178 miles (287 km). These results are scenario-dependent: DC remains below TM across the other tested parameter ranges, but the advantage disappears when the Rapid Plant is more than approximately 245 mi (395 km) from the site or the Kit Center loss exceeds approximately 13%. Conclusions Distributed construction may achieve lower modeled construction-stage A1–A5 GHG emissions when localized fabrication and coordinated logistics are feasible. This study applies a comparative LCA framework to evaluate production-network configuration as an environmental performance variable in construction. The results indicate that any benefit depends on project-specific logistics and resource-use characteristics.

Authors

Institutions

Publication Details

Journal
The International Journal of Life Cycle Assessment
Published
2026-11-17
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1007/s11367-026-02771-5
Primary Topic
Environmental Impact and Sustainability
Type
article
Field-Weighted Citation Impact
0.00
Controls
|||
ALL TIME
JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
OCT
NOV
article

Evaluating distributed construction with life cycle assessment: a scenario-based comparative study of construction-stage environmental impacts

Tran Duong Nguyen, Valerie M. Thomas, Pardis Pishdad
3 links
The International Journal of Life Cycle Assessment
Environmental Impact and Sustainability
article

Evaluating distributed construction with life cycle assessment: a scenario-based comparative study of construction-stage environmental impacts

Tran Duong Nguyen, Valerie M. Thomas, Pardis Pishdad
article en

Abstract

Abstract Purpose Distributed construction (DC) decentralizes fabrication and assembly across multiple locations while planning and coordination remain centralized. Empirical data on its construction-stage greenhouse gas impacts relative to conventional construction and traditional modular construction are limited. This study addresses this gap by providing a scenario-based comparative life cycle assessment of DC’s construction-stage environmental performance using a U.S. hospitality project. Methods The study develops an attributional, comparative evaluation of life cycle greenhouse gas emissions (GHG) for a newly built hotel in Alpharetta, Georgia. The study evaluates three construction and production configurations: conventional construction (CC), traditional modular construction (TM), and a modeled distributed construction (DC) scenario that differs from TM mainly in its production and logistics network. The functional unit is the complete hotel project, with results also normalized per guestroom and per unit floor area. The system boundary follows EN 15978 production and construction stages A1–A5 and includes material production, transportation, construction energy and water use, and material impacts associated with construction waste. Scenario development draws on project documentation, published literature, industry presentations, professional meetings, and explicitly documented scenario assumptions. Sensitivity analysis examines key assumptions, including transport distance, facility proximity, payload and backhaul treatment, material-loss factors, construction duration, and energy intensity. Results and discussion Under the modeled assumptions, the DC scenario has the lowest modeled construction-stage A1–A5 GHG emissions among the three scenarios. Total A1–A5 emissions are approximately 1,168 t CO₂e for CC, 1,055 t CO₂e for TM, and 1,004 t CO₂e for DC, representing estimated reductions of 14% relative to CC and 5% relative to TM. DC’s incremental advantage over TM mainly comes from lower transportation and construction energy- and water-related impacts. Modeled material impacts are identical for TM and DC and about 8% higher than for CC because of the double-layer module walls, and DC waste-associated impacts are slightly higher than TM because of the additional kitting-stage loss. The advantage relative to CC depends strongly on the assumed CC site material-loss factor; TM no longer has lower emissions than CC when the CC site loss falls below approximately 15%. Sensitivity analysis indicates that transportation performance depends heavily on facility proximity; under the current route, payload, and return-trip assumptions, DC transportation emissions reach parity with TM at a Rapid Plant-to-site distance of approximately 178 miles (287 km). These results are scenario-dependent: DC remains below TM across the other tested parameter ranges, but the advantage disappears when the Rapid Plant is more than approximately 245 mi (395 km) from the site or the Kit Center loss exceeds approximately 13%. Conclusions Distributed construction may achieve lower modeled construction-stage A1–A5 GHG emissions when localized fabrication and coordinated logistics are feasible. This study applies a comparative LCA framework to evaluate production-network configuration as an environmental performance variable in construction. The results indicate that any benefit depends on project-specific logistics and resource-use characteristics.

The International Journal of Life Cycle AssessmentVol. 31(12)
Georgia Institute of Technology (US)
Climate action, Industry, innovation and infrastructure, Responsible consumption and production, Affordable and clean energy, Sustainable cities and communities
Environmental Impact and Sustainability
AI Navigator

Ask Laika to Summarize, Analyze, and Connect papers live on the map.

Summarize Papers & Methodologies

Extract key findings, datasets, and comparative methods across publications.

Benchmark Rankings & Visual Analytics

Rank top research institutions, authors, funders, topics, and journals by Field-Weighted Citation Impact (FWCI) and paper volume with instant charts.

Connect Distant Disciplines

Bridge topological clusters on the map to find hidden collaborative intersections.

Laika access coming soon