Beyond the Binary: Pain as a Health–Disease Continuum – A Theoretical Framework Integrating Biomedical, Phenomenological and Salutogenic Perspectives

RATIONALE: Clinical practice continues to treat pain, once reported, as a symptom requiring elimination. This binary framing collapses a heterogeneous range of experiences into a single pathological category, obscures the extent to which pain is part of normal physiology, and fails to distinguish, within chronic pain, between patients whose lives remain intact and patients whose lifeworld has been dismantled. AIMS AND OBJECTIVES: To propose a theoretical framework, the Pain Continuum Model (PCM), that reconceptualises pain as a phenomenon occupying shifting positions between health and disease, and to derive from it criteria for clinical judgement and empirically testable predictions. METHOD: Conceptual analysis integrating the philosophy of disease (Boorse, Nordenfelt and Canguilhem), contemporary pain science including the IASP concepts of nociplastic and chronic primary pain, the phenomenology of embodiment (Merleau-Ponty, Leder and Toombs) and Antonovsky's salutogenic theory. RESULTS: The PCM locates any pain experience along three axes: a neurophysiological axis describing the degree to which pain has become decoupled from tissue state; a phenomenological axis describing the transformation of embodied experience; and a salutogenic axis describing the sense of coherence with which the person meets the experience. The transition from physiological to pathological pain is characterised as a qualitative shift marked by the loss of a causal narrative, the exhaustion of manageability and discordance between the axes, rather than by a quantitative threshold. Five refutable predictions are formulated. CONCLUSIONS: The PCM offers a conceptual basis for evaluating clinical reasoning about pain: for resisting the medicalisation of physiological pain, for reconceiving chronification as a multidimensional process that can be recognised before the temporal criterion of chronicity is met, and for reframing therapeutic goals at the pathological end of the continuum. It makes explicit, and therefore assessable, the grounds on which a pain experience is assigned to the side of health or of disease.

Authors

Institutions

Publication Details

Journal
Journal of Evaluation in Clinical Practice
Published
2026-11-17
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1111/jep.70750
Primary Topic
Medicine, History, and Philosophy
Type
article
Field-Weighted Citation Impact
0.00
Controls
|||
ALL TIME
JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
OCT
NOV
article

Beyond the Binary: Pain as a Health–Disease Continuum – A Theoretical Framework Integrating Biomedical, Phenomenological and Salutogenic Perspectives

Helmar Bornemann‐Cimenti
1 links
Journal of Evaluation in Clinical Practice
Medicine, History, and Philosophy
article

Beyond the Binary: Pain as a Health–Disease Continuum – A Theoretical Framework Integrating Biomedical, Phenomenological and Salutogenic Perspectives

Helmar Bornemann‐Cimenti
article en

Abstract

RATIONALE: Clinical practice continues to treat pain, once reported, as a symptom requiring elimination. This binary framing collapses a heterogeneous range of experiences into a single pathological category, obscures the extent to which pain is part of normal physiology, and fails to distinguish, within chronic pain, between patients whose lives remain intact and patients whose lifeworld has been dismantled. AIMS AND OBJECTIVES: To propose a theoretical framework, the Pain Continuum Model (PCM), that reconceptualises pain as a phenomenon occupying shifting positions between health and disease, and to derive from it criteria for clinical judgement and empirically testable predictions. METHOD: Conceptual analysis integrating the philosophy of disease (Boorse, Nordenfelt and Canguilhem), contemporary pain science including the IASP concepts of nociplastic and chronic primary pain, the phenomenology of embodiment (Merleau-Ponty, Leder and Toombs) and Antonovsky's salutogenic theory. RESULTS: The PCM locates any pain experience along three axes: a neurophysiological axis describing the degree to which pain has become decoupled from tissue state; a phenomenological axis describing the transformation of embodied experience; and a salutogenic axis describing the sense of coherence with which the person meets the experience. The transition from physiological to pathological pain is characterised as a qualitative shift marked by the loss of a causal narrative, the exhaustion of manageability and discordance between the axes, rather than by a quantitative threshold. Five refutable predictions are formulated. CONCLUSIONS: The PCM offers a conceptual basis for evaluating clinical reasoning about pain: for resisting the medicalisation of physiological pain, for reconceiving chronification as a multidimensional process that can be recognised before the temporal criterion of chronicity is met, and for reframing therapeutic goals at the pathological end of the continuum. It makes explicit, and therefore assessable, the grounds on which a pain experience is assigned to the side of health or of disease.

Journal of Evaluation in Clinical PracticeVol. 32(8)
Medical University of Graz (AT)
Good health and well-being
Medicine, History, and Philosophy
AI Navigator

Ask Laika to Summarize, Analyze, and Connect papers live on the map.

Summarize Papers & Methodologies

Extract key findings, datasets, and comparative methods across publications.

Benchmark Rankings & Visual Analytics

Rank top research institutions, authors, funders, topics, and journals by Field-Weighted Citation Impact (FWCI) and paper volume with instant charts.

Connect Distant Disciplines

Bridge topological clusters on the map to find hidden collaborative intersections.

Laika access coming soon