Streamlined sustainability assessment for regional bioeconomy transition: High-value lignin valorization pathways in the Finnish pulp sector

Kraft lignin, traditionally incinerated for energy recovery in Finland’s pulp sector, is increasingly recognized as a strategic feedstock for accelerating the sector’s decarbonization trajectory. However, most lignin valorisation technologies remain at pilot scale, and data limitations constrain sustainability assessment needed to inform large-scale deployment decisions. To address this challenge, a streamlined sustainability assessment framework is developed to support early-stage decision making. The framework’s novelty lies in its integration of stakeholder perspectives and expert insights through a structured participatory approach to compensate for limited data availability. Environmental performance is prioritized and evaluated using attributional and consequential life cycle impact assessment (ALCA and CLCA, respectively), complemented by a semi-quantitative socio-economic assessment. The environmental and socio-economic scores are integrated into an overall sustainability score of 1000, with the distribution of score across sustainability criteria informed by stakeholder weighting. The framework was applied to three lignin-based product pathways in Finnish pulp mills: adhesives for wood boards, anodes for car batteries, and plasticizers for concrete. Across 16 environmental impact categories, lignin-based products outperformed fossil alternatives in 13–14 categories using both ALCA and CLCA, respectively. Climate change impacts from lignin-based adhesives and anodes were 83% and 57% lower than their fossil counterparts. Using ALCA, adhesives achieved the highest sustainability score (796/1000), while using CLCA both adhesives and anodes performed equally well (751/1000). The main difference in the sustainability score arose from the environmental performance, as the socio-economic scores were relatively similar across the pathways. The findings highlight the environmental benefits of lignin valorization into anodes and adhesives for accelerating the decarbonization of Finland’s pulp sector. They also demonstrate the potential of the proposed framework to support early-stage decision-making regarding sustainability of transition pathways by integrating stakeholder and expert inputs.

Authors

Institutions

Publication Details

Journal
Resources Conservation and Recycling
Published
2026-11-17
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.resconrec.2026.109208
Primary Topic
Lignin and Wood Chemistry
Type
article
Field-Weighted Citation Impact
0.00

Funders

Controls
|||
ALL TIME
JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
OCT
NOV
article

Streamlined sustainability assessment for regional bioeconomy transition: High-value lignin valorization pathways in the Finnish pulp sector

Thomas Schaubroeck, Katri Behm, Gitanjali Thakur, Janne Tapani Keränen et al.
1 links
Resources Conservation and Recycling
Lignin and Wood Chemistry
article

Streamlined sustainability assessment for regional bioeconomy transition: High-value lignin valorization pathways in the Finnish pulp sector

Thomas Schaubroeck, Katri Behm, Gitanjali Thakur, Janne Tapani Keränen, Hanna S. Hörhammer, Enrico Benetto, Eetu Nissinen
article en

Abstract

Kraft lignin, traditionally incinerated for energy recovery in Finland’s pulp sector, is increasingly recognized as a strategic feedstock for accelerating the sector’s decarbonization trajectory. However, most lignin valorisation technologies remain at pilot scale, and data limitations constrain sustainability assessment needed to inform large-scale deployment decisions. To address this challenge, a streamlined sustainability assessment framework is developed to support early-stage decision making. The framework’s novelty lies in its integration of stakeholder perspectives and expert insights through a structured participatory approach to compensate for limited data availability. Environmental performance is prioritized and evaluated using attributional and consequential life cycle impact assessment (ALCA and CLCA, respectively), complemented by a semi-quantitative socio-economic assessment. The environmental and socio-economic scores are integrated into an overall sustainability score of 1000, with the distribution of score across sustainability criteria informed by stakeholder weighting. The framework was applied to three lignin-based product pathways in Finnish pulp mills: adhesives for wood boards, anodes for car batteries, and plasticizers for concrete. Across 16 environmental impact categories, lignin-based products outperformed fossil alternatives in 13–14 categories using both ALCA and CLCA, respectively. Climate change impacts from lignin-based adhesives and anodes were 83% and 57% lower than their fossil counterparts. Using ALCA, adhesives achieved the highest sustainability score (796/1000), while using CLCA both adhesives and anodes performed equally well (751/1000). The main difference in the sustainability score arose from the environmental performance, as the socio-economic scores were relatively similar across the pathways. The findings highlight the environmental benefits of lignin valorization into anodes and adhesives for accelerating the decarbonization of Finland’s pulp sector. They also demonstrate the potential of the proposed framework to support early-stage decision-making regarding sustainability of transition pathways by integrating stakeholder and expert inputs.

Resources Conservation and RecyclingVol. 238
University of Luxembourg (LU), Luxembourg Institute of Science and Technology (LU), VTT Technical Research Centre of Finland (FI)
European Commission
Responsible consumption and production
Lignin and Wood Chemistry
AI Navigator

Ask Laika to Summarize, Analyze, and Connect papers live on the map.

Summarize Papers & Methodologies

Extract key findings, datasets, and comparative methods across publications.

Benchmark Rankings & Visual Analytics

Rank top research institutions, authors, funders, topics, and journals by Field-Weighted Citation Impact (FWCI) and paper volume with instant charts.

Connect Distant Disciplines

Bridge topological clusters on the map to find hidden collaborative intersections.

Laika access coming soon