A City Persona Sensitive Social Optimum Mobility Index for Assessing Inclusive Urban Mobility in Florence

Abstract This study develops and applies the Social Optimum Mobility Index (SOMI), a persona-sensitive and KPI-based framework for assessing socially inclusive urban mobility solutions. Developed within the Horizon Europe Research and Innovation Action GOLIA, the framework contributes to the operationalisation of Mobility as a Right (MaaR) by translating inclusive-mobility principles into measurable assessment pillars: Acceptability, Accessibility, Affordability, Agency, Availability, Legal Recognition, Participation, and Safety & Security. The methodology combines literature-based and MaaR-informed pillar definition, a participatory persona–pillar scoring procedure for deriving persona-specific significance weights, an Impact Creation Board (ICB) procedure for deriving solution-specific persona-influence weights, KPI normalisation, and spatial accessibility interpretation. A sensitivity analysis is also conducted to examine whether the SOMI results remain robust under alternative persona–pillar and persona-influence weighting assumptions. The framework is applied to the Florence case study, where nine personas and three mobility solutions are assessed: (i) 30 km/h zones and traffic calming, (ii) urban logistics micro-hubs, and (iii) road-space redistribution. The results show a clear ranking among the three solutions. Road-space redistribution achieves the strongest solution-level SOMI performance, with a score of 0.840, followed by urban logistics micro-hubs at 0.630 and 30 km/h zones and traffic calming at 0.388. The equal-weighted city-level SOMI estimate for Florence is 0.619.At persona level, road-space redistribution performs best across all personas, indicating strong performance across most SOMI pillars. The sensitivity analysis confirms that the comparative ranking of the three solutions is robust under alternative weighting assumptions. The persona–pillar weight sensitivity test shows that persona-level SOMI values are most responsive for 30 km/h zones and traffic calming, where pillar performance is more uneven. By contrast, the micro-hub solution shows a more balanced sensitivity pattern, while road-space redistribution remains the strongest-performing solution across the full perturbation interval. The ICB sensitivity test shows only limited variation in solution-level SOMI values when persona-influence weights are gradually replaced by equal persona weights, indicating that the final ranking does not depend strongly on the exact ICB weighting structure.

Authors

Institutions

Publication Details

Journal
Research Square
Published
2026-11-17
DOI
https://doi.org/10.21203/rs.3.rs-11332418/v1
Primary Topic
Urban Transport and Accessibility
Type
preprint

Funders

Controls
|||
ALL TIME
JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
OCT
NOV
preprint

A City Persona Sensitive Social Optimum Mobility Index for Assessing Inclusive Urban Mobility in Florence

Sofoklis Dais, Ioannis Mallidis, Georgia Ayfantopoulou, Vasileios Giannoudis et al.
Research Square
Urban Transport and Accessibility
preprint

A City Persona Sensitive Social Optimum Mobility Index for Assessing Inclusive Urban Mobility in Florence

Sofoklis Dais, Ioannis Mallidis, Georgia Ayfantopoulou, Vasileios Giannoudis, Marisa Meta
preprint en

Abstract

Abstract This study develops and applies the Social Optimum Mobility Index (SOMI), a persona-sensitive and KPI-based framework for assessing socially inclusive urban mobility solutions. Developed within the Horizon Europe Research and Innovation Action GOLIA, the framework contributes to the operationalisation of Mobility as a Right (MaaR) by translating inclusive-mobility principles into measurable assessment pillars: Acceptability, Accessibility, Affordability, Agency, Availability, Legal Recognition, Participation, and Safety & Security. The methodology combines literature-based and MaaR-informed pillar definition, a participatory persona–pillar scoring procedure for deriving persona-specific significance weights, an Impact Creation Board (ICB) procedure for deriving solution-specific persona-influence weights, KPI normalisation, and spatial accessibility interpretation. A sensitivity analysis is also conducted to examine whether the SOMI results remain robust under alternative persona–pillar and persona-influence weighting assumptions. The framework is applied to the Florence case study, where nine personas and three mobility solutions are assessed: (i) 30 km/h zones and traffic calming, (ii) urban logistics micro-hubs, and (iii) road-space redistribution. The results show a clear ranking among the three solutions. Road-space redistribution achieves the strongest solution-level SOMI performance, with a score of 0.840, followed by urban logistics micro-hubs at 0.630 and 30 km/h zones and traffic calming at 0.388. The equal-weighted city-level SOMI estimate for Florence is 0.619.At persona level, road-space redistribution performs best across all personas, indicating strong performance across most SOMI pillars. The sensitivity analysis confirms that the comparative ranking of the three solutions is robust under alternative weighting assumptions. The persona–pillar weight sensitivity test shows that persona-level SOMI values are most responsive for 30 km/h zones and traffic calming, where pillar performance is more uneven. By contrast, the micro-hub solution shows a more balanced sensitivity pattern, while road-space redistribution remains the strongest-performing solution across the full perturbation interval. The ICB sensitivity test shows only limited variation in solution-level SOMI values when persona-influence weights are gradually replaced by equal persona weights, indicating that the final ranking does not depend strongly on the exact ICB weighting structure.

Research Square
FIT Consulting (Italy) (IT), Centre for Research and Technology Hellas (GR), University of Western Macedonia (GR)
European Commission, HORIZON EUROPE Framework Programme
Sustainable cities and communities, Reduced inequalities, Industry, innovation and infrastructure
Urban Transport and Accessibility
AI Navigator

Ask Laika to Summarize, Analyze, and Connect papers live on the map.

Summarize Papers & Methodologies

Extract key findings, datasets, and comparative methods across publications.

Benchmark Rankings & Visual Analytics

Rank top research institutions, authors, funders, topics, and journals by Field-Weighted Citation Impact (FWCI) and paper volume with instant charts.

Connect Distant Disciplines

Bridge topological clusters on the map to find hidden collaborative intersections.

Laika access coming soon