Evaluation Protocol Matters More Than Model Choice: A Simulated-data Study of Intrusion Detection from Raw Network Metadata Under a Preserved Class Prior

Intrusion detection systems must defend enterprise and IoT networks against increasingly sophisticated threats.We evaluate five machine learning classifiers on 10,000 network flow records covering nine attack categories and a benign class, using 26 features engineered from 13 raw metadata attributes.Departing from common practice, we partition before balancing, so the held-out set of 3,000 flows retains the 24 to 1 class ratio of the source data; hyperparameters are tuned on the training partition alone and standardisation is fitted inside a leakage-free pipeline.Gradient boosting attains the highest area under the precision-recall curve (0.670), detecting 66.67% of attacks at a 1.28% false-positive rate, with random forest close behind (0.659).Evaluation protocol dominates model choice: logistic regression appears competitive on a balanced partition, yet its attack-class precision falls to 13.91% at the 4% prevalence of the source data.Binary detection is viable from raw metadata; fine-grained attribution is not.Because all results come from one simulated distribution whose generator is unavailable to us, they characterise that distribution rather than deployed intrusion detection, and the feature rankings describe the fitted models rather than establishing that the underlying fields are intrinsically diagnostic of attacks.A prevalence-sensitivity analysis shows how precision degrades at the lower priors typical of production traffic.

Authors

Institutions

Publication Details

Journal
International journal of intelligent engineering and systems
Published
2026-11-17
DOI
https://doi.org/10.22266/ijies2026.1231.56
Primary Topic
Network Security and Intrusion Detection
Type
article
Field-Weighted Citation Impact
0.00
Controls
|||
ALL TIME
JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
OCT
NOV
article

Evaluation Protocol Matters More Than Model Choice: A Simulated-data Study of Intrusion Detection from Raw Network Metadata Under a Preserved Class Prior

Osama K. Qtaish, Mahmoud Khalid Baklizi, Musab B. Alzghoul, Mohammad Alkhazaleh
International journal of intelligent engineering and systems
Network Security and Intrusion Detection
article

Evaluation Protocol Matters More Than Model Choice: A Simulated-data Study of Intrusion Detection from Raw Network Metadata Under a Preserved Class Prior

Osama K. Qtaish, Mahmoud Khalid Baklizi, Musab B. Alzghoul, Mohammad Alkhazaleh
article en

Abstract

Intrusion detection systems must defend enterprise and IoT networks against increasingly sophisticated threats.We evaluate five machine learning classifiers on 10,000 network flow records covering nine attack categories and a benign class, using 26 features engineered from 13 raw metadata attributes.Departing from common practice, we partition before balancing, so the held-out set of 3,000 flows retains the 24 to 1 class ratio of the source data; hyperparameters are tuned on the training partition alone and standardisation is fitted inside a leakage-free pipeline.Gradient boosting attains the highest area under the precision-recall curve (0.670), detecting 66.67% of attacks at a 1.28% false-positive rate, with random forest close behind (0.659).Evaluation protocol dominates model choice: logistic regression appears competitive on a balanced partition, yet its attack-class precision falls to 13.91% at the 4% prevalence of the source data.Binary detection is viable from raw metadata; fine-grained attribution is not.Because all results come from one simulated distribution whose generator is unavailable to us, they characterise that distribution rather than deployed intrusion detection, and the feature rankings describe the fitted models rather than establishing that the underlying fields are intrinsically diagnostic of attacks.A prevalence-sensitivity analysis shows how precision degrades at the lower priors typical of production traffic.

International journal of intelligent engineering and systemsVol. 19(12)
Petra University (JO), Isra University (JO)
Network Security and Intrusion Detection
AI Navigator

Ask Laika to Summarize, Analyze, and Connect papers live on the map.

Summarize Papers & Methodologies

Extract key findings, datasets, and comparative methods across publications.

Benchmark Rankings & Visual Analytics

Rank top research institutions, authors, funders, topics, and journals by Field-Weighted Citation Impact (FWCI) and paper volume with instant charts.

Connect Distant Disciplines

Bridge topological clusters on the map to find hidden collaborative intersections.

Laika access coming soon