A cross-scale synthesis for woody plant encroachment: Overriding mechanisms, transition pathways, and spatial heterogeneity

Woody plant encroachment (WPE), the expansion of shrubs and trees into ecosystems previously dominated by herbaceous vegetation, is a widespread and consequential form of vegetation change under global environmental change. Despite decades of research, the drivers of WPE remain debated, as findings across biomes, disturbance regimes, and spatial scales are often difficult to generalize. This review summarizes that these inconsistencies reflect a fundamental property of WPE: it is not a linear response to individual drivers, but a hierarchical ecological transition that occurs when mechanisms maintaining grassland openness weaken or fail. We synthesize evidence within a cross-scale framework centered on three linked components. First, grassland openness is regulated by overriding mechanisms, including fire, climatic constraints, anthropogenic management, and herbaceous competition for soil moisture, which determine how global environmental forcing is filtered at local scales. Second, cross-biome synthesis reveals distinct WPE pathways, including climatic threshold crossing in tundra and alpine systems, disturbance-regime alteration in fire-regulated grasslands, management changes in Mediterranean and subalpine systems, and the loss of herbaceous competitive advantage in semi-arid drylands. Despite their differences, these pathways converge on a feedback shift from grass-dominated negative feedbacks to woody-dominated positive feedbacks. Third, WPE patterns and reversibility emerge from interactions across scales: regional mechanism states shape transition pathways, while local topography, soils, and management determine initiation and spatial expansion. Across tundra, Mediterranean, temperate, and montane grasslands, we find that WPE heterogeneity results from cross-scale filtering rather than any single driver. This perspective explains why similar global pressures produce contrasting trajectories and why local interventions may fail after regional stabilizing mechanisms are disrupted. Future research should focus on quantifying mechanism strength, identifying early transition thresholds, understanding feedback amplification, evaluating pathway shifts under global change, and integrating social-ecological processes into WPE frameworks.

Authors

Institutions

Publication Details

Journal
Progress in Physical Geography Earth and Environment
Published
2026-11-17
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1177/03091333261509501
Primary Topic
Ecosystem dynamics and resilience
Type
article
Field-Weighted Citation Impact
0.00

Funders

Controls
|||
ALL TIME
JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
OCT
NOV
article

A cross-scale synthesis for woody plant encroachment: Overriding mechanisms, transition pathways, and spatial heterogeneity

Xulin Guo, Yanzhen Lin
1 links
Progress in Physical Geography Earth and Environment
Ecosystem dynamics and resilience
article

A cross-scale synthesis for woody plant encroachment: Overriding mechanisms, transition pathways, and spatial heterogeneity

Xulin Guo, Yanzhen Lin
article en

Abstract

Woody plant encroachment (WPE), the expansion of shrubs and trees into ecosystems previously dominated by herbaceous vegetation, is a widespread and consequential form of vegetation change under global environmental change. Despite decades of research, the drivers of WPE remain debated, as findings across biomes, disturbance regimes, and spatial scales are often difficult to generalize. This review summarizes that these inconsistencies reflect a fundamental property of WPE: it is not a linear response to individual drivers, but a hierarchical ecological transition that occurs when mechanisms maintaining grassland openness weaken or fail. We synthesize evidence within a cross-scale framework centered on three linked components. First, grassland openness is regulated by overriding mechanisms, including fire, climatic constraints, anthropogenic management, and herbaceous competition for soil moisture, which determine how global environmental forcing is filtered at local scales. Second, cross-biome synthesis reveals distinct WPE pathways, including climatic threshold crossing in tundra and alpine systems, disturbance-regime alteration in fire-regulated grasslands, management changes in Mediterranean and subalpine systems, and the loss of herbaceous competitive advantage in semi-arid drylands. Despite their differences, these pathways converge on a feedback shift from grass-dominated negative feedbacks to woody-dominated positive feedbacks. Third, WPE patterns and reversibility emerge from interactions across scales: regional mechanism states shape transition pathways, while local topography, soils, and management determine initiation and spatial expansion. Across tundra, Mediterranean, temperate, and montane grasslands, we find that WPE heterogeneity results from cross-scale filtering rather than any single driver. This perspective explains why similar global pressures produce contrasting trajectories and why local interventions may fail after regional stabilizing mechanisms are disrupted. Future research should focus on quantifying mechanism strength, identifying early transition thresholds, understanding feedback amplification, evaluating pathway shifts under global change, and integrating social-ecological processes into WPE frameworks.

Progress in Physical Geography Earth and Environment
University of Saskatchewan (CA)
Canadian Space Agency, Natural Sciences and Engineering Research Council of Canada
Life on land
Ecosystem dynamics and resilience
AI Navigator

Ask Laika to Summarize, Analyze, and Connect papers live on the map.

Summarize Papers & Methodologies

Extract key findings, datasets, and comparative methods across publications.

Benchmark Rankings & Visual Analytics

Rank top research institutions, authors, funders, topics, and journals by Field-Weighted Citation Impact (FWCI) and paper volume with instant charts.

Connect Distant Disciplines

Bridge topological clusters on the map to find hidden collaborative intersections.

Laika access coming soon