How consumers evaluate closed-category cultural products: testing a categorical-motivation model-informed, familiarity-oriented proposition in porcelain teacup design

Purpose This study examines aesthetic preferences for porcelain teacups as closed-category cultural products. Unified Model of Aesthetics (UMA) provides the primary appraisal framework, while the categorical-motivation model informs a complementary interpretation of within-pair coefficient differences. In this interpretation, “safety” denotes motivational reassurance rather than physical or functional product safety. Design/methodology/approach In Phase 1, 200 Chinese consumers evaluated 10 teacup designs, yielding 2,000 repeated observations. Repeated-measures ANOVA and generalised estimating equations tested stimulus differentiation and six UMA appraisals. In Phase 2, an independent sample of 610 consumers completed a dichotomous acceptance assessment of one finalised design. Findings All six UMA dimensions positively predicted consumer aesthetic preference. Direct Wald contrasts supported the predicted advantages of unity over variety and connectedness over autonomy, but established no coefficient advantage for either typicality or novelty. The original familiarity-oriented predictions therefore received partial support. Effects were modest but substantively consistent across alternative generalised estimating equations and mixed-effects specifications. In Phase 2, 60.3% endorsed the finalised design as “pleasing to see,” exceeding an equal-proportion reference of 0.50; this indicates immediate aesthetic acceptance, not market success. Research limitations/implications The study used shape-focused stimuli, single-item indicators, and non-probability samples from one Chinese city. The findings are therefore context-specific and do not represent population estimates or fully validated latent constructs. Practical implications Brands may combine visual coherence and sociocultural connectedness with controlled differentiation. Because typicality and novelty were statistically comparable, their balance should be tested across consumer segments and brand positions. The findings support concept screening, portfolio differentiation, and positioning decisions. Social implications The findings support culturally sensitive innovation that balances tradition, shared meaning, and contemporary differentiation. Originality/value This study contributes a pair-specific assessment of familiarity-oriented weighting within UMA in a controlled cultural-product context. It distinguishes the joint relevance of six appraisals from evidence that familiarity-oriented appraisals have stronger associations with preference. Direct coefficient contrasts support the predicted advantages of unity and connectedness, but not typicality, qualifying an across-the-board familiarity-priority interpretation and providing a context-specific empirical basis for further theoretical testing.

Authors

Institutions

Publication Details

Journal
Asia Pacific Journal of Marketing and Logistics
Published
2026-11-18
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1108/apjml-05-2026-1111
Primary Topic
Aesthetic Perception and Analysis
Type
article
Field-Weighted Citation Impact
0.00
Controls
|||
ALL TIME
JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
OCT
NOV
article

How consumers evaluate closed-category cultural products: testing a categorical-motivation model-informed, familiarity-oriented proposition in porcelain teacup design

Ahmad Rizal Abd Rahman, Lichen Tai, Si Yuan Cheng, Yanfeng Hu et al.
3 links
Asia Pacific Journal of Marketing and Logistics
Aesthetic Perception and Analysis
article

How consumers evaluate closed-category cultural products: testing a categorical-motivation model-informed, familiarity-oriented proposition in porcelain teacup design

Ahmad Rizal Abd Rahman, Lichen Tai, Si Yuan Cheng, Yanfeng Hu, Mohd Faiz Bin Yahaya
article en

Abstract

Purpose This study examines aesthetic preferences for porcelain teacups as closed-category cultural products. Unified Model of Aesthetics (UMA) provides the primary appraisal framework, while the categorical-motivation model informs a complementary interpretation of within-pair coefficient differences. In this interpretation, “safety” denotes motivational reassurance rather than physical or functional product safety. Design/methodology/approach In Phase 1, 200 Chinese consumers evaluated 10 teacup designs, yielding 2,000 repeated observations. Repeated-measures ANOVA and generalised estimating equations tested stimulus differentiation and six UMA appraisals. In Phase 2, an independent sample of 610 consumers completed a dichotomous acceptance assessment of one finalised design. Findings All six UMA dimensions positively predicted consumer aesthetic preference. Direct Wald contrasts supported the predicted advantages of unity over variety and connectedness over autonomy, but established no coefficient advantage for either typicality or novelty. The original familiarity-oriented predictions therefore received partial support. Effects were modest but substantively consistent across alternative generalised estimating equations and mixed-effects specifications. In Phase 2, 60.3% endorsed the finalised design as “pleasing to see,” exceeding an equal-proportion reference of 0.50; this indicates immediate aesthetic acceptance, not market success. Research limitations/implications The study used shape-focused stimuli, single-item indicators, and non-probability samples from one Chinese city. The findings are therefore context-specific and do not represent population estimates or fully validated latent constructs. Practical implications Brands may combine visual coherence and sociocultural connectedness with controlled differentiation. Because typicality and novelty were statistically comparable, their balance should be tested across consumer segments and brand positions. The findings support concept screening, portfolio differentiation, and positioning decisions. Social implications The findings support culturally sensitive innovation that balances tradition, shared meaning, and contemporary differentiation. Originality/value This study contributes a pair-specific assessment of familiarity-oriented weighting within UMA in a controlled cultural-product context. It distinguishes the joint relevance of six appraisals from evidence that familiarity-oriented appraisals have stronger associations with preference. Direct coefficient contrasts support the predicted advantages of unity and connectedness, but not typicality, qualifying an across-the-board familiarity-priority interpretation and providing a context-specific empirical basis for further theoretical testing.

Asia Pacific Journal of Marketing and Logistics
Universiti Putra Malaysia (MY), Xinjiang Agricultural University (CN), Wenzao Ursuline University of Languages (TW), Serdang Hospital (MY), Chengdu University (CN), Chengdu Qinggong Polytechnic University (CN)
Aesthetic Perception and Analysis
AI Navigator

Ask Laika to Summarize, Analyze, and Connect papers live on the map.

Summarize Papers & Methodologies

Extract key findings, datasets, and comparative methods across publications.

Benchmark Rankings & Visual Analytics

Rank top research institutions, authors, funders, topics, and journals by Field-Weighted Citation Impact (FWCI) and paper volume with instant charts.

Connect Distant Disciplines

Bridge topological clusters on the map to find hidden collaborative intersections.

Laika access coming soon