Self-Application of Judgment Through Relational Reidentification: How the Person Judging a Case Can Be Found Within It
This conceptual paper introduces Self-Application of Judgment Through Relational Reidentification, an account of how a participant’s judgment of a described relation can become applicable to that participant. A later supported identification places the person in a relevant position within the relation, making self-application of the earlier judgment a live question while the relation and its criterion remain fixed. The account assesses self-application through the warrant for the identity or role mapping and the preservation of differences relevant to the judgment’s criterion. Evidence supporting the mapping is distinct from evidence supporting the original judgment. Resemblance, analogy, and accusation do not establish a valid identification, and the person implicated can contest a mapping that omits a relevant difference. Holding someone to their own criterion does not by itself establish that the original judgment is correct. The operation distinguishes supported self-application from a comparison used to silence criticism on grounds that do not apply. The discussion sets the operation beside Adam Smith’s account of the impartial spectator and examines two documented cases. The Old Book of Tang records Zhang Xuansu’s memorial to Emperor Taizong in 630, connecting proposed palace work to the extravagance the emperor had previously condemned by ordering Sui buildings demolished. The record reports that Taizong accepted the comparison and stopped the work. Frederick Douglass’s Rochester oration of July 5, 1852 addressed the nation through an anti-slavery audience, placing it within the relation of oppression condemned by its celebration of independence. His comparison invoked the nation’s professed commitment to human equality. Part of the Relational Conditions and Dynamics series within On Human Modeling, the paper examines who supplies a mapping, who is implicated by it, and how that person can contest omitted differences. Potential applications in human–AI research include consistency assessment, role-sensitive reasoning, and systems that distinguish a supported application of a participant’s stated judgment from a superficial analogy or an unsupported attribution of hypocrisy.
Authors
- Alexandra Cary
Publication Details
- Journal
- Zenodo (CERN European Organization for Nuclear Research)
- Published
- 2026-11-17
- DOI
- https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24308987
- Primary Topic
- Philosophical Ethics and Theory
- Type
- article
- Field-Weighted Citation Impact
- 0.00