How do wind ripples become asymmetric?
Wind ripples have a characteristic size and an asymmetric shape: a long, gentle stoss side and a short, steep lee side. In an earlier survey on the Hulshorster Zand, the Netherlands, the mean crest spacing was 107 mm, the height 5 mm, and the stoss side about three times as long as the lee side (Brugmans, 1983). With a two-dimensional numerical model we examine whether known processes together can produce such ripples without the shape being imposed. In the model, ripples form that migrate downwind and remain asymmetric, but less so than in the field. The difference lies mainly in the lee side, which is too long and too gentle. The asymmetry responds to the description of the wind and to wind-driven sliding, but we do not find which process produces the short, steep lee side.The bed is a grid of cells, each one grain. Grains in the air follow computed trajectories in a wind profile that they themselves slow down. On impact a grain rebounds, ejects grains and pushes bed grains forward (creep). Bed grains can also slide over the bed driven by the wind itself. Over the ripple the wind changes in strength and in direction: the response of the bed shear stress follows from linear flow theory for a rough, undulating bed, and the streamlines follow the bed; how this is translated into the wind at each height is a modelling choice. No wind shadow behind the crest is imposed, and the strength of creep is not tuned to the migration rate.From a flat, dry bed with noise, ripplets with a spacing of 30 to 40 mm form in the model within a minute; they merge and grow. Within half an hour to an hour the ripples reach their size, which then stays nearly constant, also in a 16-hour series. After 4 hours the crest spacing is 127 mm and the height 4.9 mm. We compare with the field as it was measured in 1983: the ratios computed per ripple and then averaged. The height (4.9 versus 5 mm), the stoss length (71 versus 80 mm) and the ripple index (26 versus 22) lie within one standard deviation of the field, the crest spacing (127 versus 107 mm) at its edge. The stoss side is steeper than in the field (7.7 versus 5 %).The model does not reach the field asymmetry. The lee side is twice as long as in the field (56 versus 27 mm) and half as steep (10.7 versus 20 %). The symmetry index is therefore 1.6, against 3 in the field, also in the 16-hour series. An imposed wind shadow behind the crest does not change this. The ripples migrate 20 mm per minute, faster than estimated in the field.Which process produces the short, steep lee side of the 1983 field is therefore the open question. The shape of the lee side and the wind in the lowest centimetres above the ripple are the measurements that can test the model most sharply. The model does already indicate that two things contribute most, and nearly equally, to the asymmetry: the description of the wind over the ripple, in particular where the wind pulls hardest on the bed, and grains sliding directly driven by the wind. The symmetry index of 1.6 is close to that on a recent photograph of smaller wind ripples on the Hulshorster Zand (1.85, also computed per ripple; one photograph). A fit of the typical ripple shape of 1983 moreover shows that the model ripples have a recognisable shape, with the gentle side facing the wind, that noise with the same spectrum lacks: their symmetry index is 0.3 to 0.4 higher than that of the noise, for every way of delimiting the ripples and in every seed. The shape is weak per ripple, and measured this way too the lee side remains too gentle.
Authors
- Freddy Brugmans
Publication Details
- Journal
- Zenodo (CERN European Organization for Nuclear Research)
- Published
- 2026-11-17
- DOI
- https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24323843
- Primary Topic
- Aeolian processes and effects
- Type
- article
- Field-Weighted Citation Impact
- 0.00