From soil loss to soil erosion risk: A composite-indicator framework for identifying

9 Soil erosion caused by water is a major concern, as it poses a threat to land resources and the ecosystem 10 services that soil provides. At continental scales, soil erosion is commonly assessed using the Revised 11 Universal Soil Loss Equation (RUSLE), which estimates long-term average annual soil loss (A). 12 However, RUSLE soil-loss maps are frequently interpreted as maps of soil erosion risk, although soil 13 loss and environmental risk represent conceptually different quantities. This study proposes a 14 complementary, indicator-based framework termed soil erosion risk (SER), aimed at providing a more 15 risk-oriented interpretation of erosion-controlling factors. Specifically, the five RUSLE factors are 16 reorganized into two composite indicators representing soil erosion hazard (H), derived from rainfall 17 erosivity (R) and topographic conditions (LS), and potential damage (pD), derived from soil erodibility 18 (K), cover-management (C), and support practices (P). Their combination (SER = H×pD) provides a 19 dimensionless, relative screening indicator that complements, rather than replaces, conventional RUSLE 20 soil-loss estimates. Continental-scale RUSLE maps provide a valuable reference for large-scale soil 21 erosion assessments, yet their application to regional conservation planning requires refinement using 22 region-specific observations. 23 The indicator-based framework was applied to Campania (southern Italy) by comparing SER maps 24 derived from continental-scale European Soil Data Centre (ESDAC) datasets with those obtained using 25 regionally refined R and K factors (HYBRID approach). The latter incorporates rainfall observations 26 from 277 monitoring gauge stations, including 107 stations providing high-temporal-resolution records, 27 and soil information from 3,316 sampling locations. This was compared with 20 rainfall stations and 69 28 soil sampling locations underlying the corresponding ESDAC datasets for Campania. The two SER 29 implementations exhibited moderate spatial agreement (Pearson’s correlation coefficient of 0.664; 30 spatial efficiency of 0.629), underscoring the sensitivity of regional screening patterns to the underlying 31 input datasets. Although independent validation is required to ascertain predictive accuracy, these 32 findings emphasized that transferring continental-scale erosion assessments to regional applications 33 should not be regarded as a simple spatial downscaling exercise. Rather, investment in more extensive 34 regional monitoring, soil surveys, and spatial modeling is necessary to better characterize local 35 environmental variability. The proposed SER framework, when used in conjunction with conventional 36 RUSLE soil-loss maps, can support the preliminary identification of candidate priority intervention 37 areas and provide regional stakeholders with complementary information for soil conservation planning. 38 39

Authors

Institutions

Publication Details

Published
2026-11-17
DOI
https://doi.org/10.22541/essoar.15012371/v1
Primary Topic
Soil erosion and sediment transport
Type
preprint
Controls
|||
ALL TIME
JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
OCT
NOV
preprint

From soil loss to soil erosion risk: A composite-indicator framework for identifying

Nunzio Romano, Paolo Nasta
Soil erosion and sediment transport
preprint

From soil loss to soil erosion risk: A composite-indicator framework for identifying

Nunzio Romano, Paolo Nasta
preprint en

Abstract

9 Soil erosion caused by water is a major concern, as it poses a threat to land resources and the ecosystem 10 services that soil provides. At continental scales, soil erosion is commonly assessed using the Revised 11 Universal Soil Loss Equation (RUSLE), which estimates long-term average annual soil loss (A). 12 However, RUSLE soil-loss maps are frequently interpreted as maps of soil erosion risk, although soil 13 loss and environmental risk represent conceptually different quantities. This study proposes a 14 complementary, indicator-based framework termed soil erosion risk (SER), aimed at providing a more 15 risk-oriented interpretation of erosion-controlling factors. Specifically, the five RUSLE factors are 16 reorganized into two composite indicators representing soil erosion hazard (H), derived from rainfall 17 erosivity (R) and topographic conditions (LS), and potential damage (pD), derived from soil erodibility 18 (K), cover-management (C), and support practices (P). Their combination (SER = H×pD) provides a 19 dimensionless, relative screening indicator that complements, rather than replaces, conventional RUSLE 20 soil-loss estimates. Continental-scale RUSLE maps provide a valuable reference for large-scale soil 21 erosion assessments, yet their application to regional conservation planning requires refinement using 22 region-specific observations. 23 The indicator-based framework was applied to Campania (southern Italy) by comparing SER maps 24 derived from continental-scale European Soil Data Centre (ESDAC) datasets with those obtained using 25 regionally refined R and K factors (HYBRID approach). The latter incorporates rainfall observations 26 from 277 monitoring gauge stations, including 107 stations providing high-temporal-resolution records, 27 and soil information from 3,316 sampling locations. This was compared with 20 rainfall stations and 69 28 soil sampling locations underlying the corresponding ESDAC datasets for Campania. The two SER 29 implementations exhibited moderate spatial agreement (Pearson’s correlation coefficient of 0.664; 30 spatial efficiency of 0.629), underscoring the sensitivity of regional screening patterns to the underlying 31 input datasets. Although independent validation is required to ascertain predictive accuracy, these 32 findings emphasized that transferring continental-scale erosion assessments to regional applications 33 should not be regarded as a simple spatial downscaling exercise. Rather, investment in more extensive 34 regional monitoring, soil surveys, and spatial modeling is necessary to better characterize local 35 environmental variability. The proposed SER framework, when used in conjunction with conventional 36 RUSLE soil-loss maps, can support the preliminary identification of candidate priority intervention 37 areas and provide regional stakeholders with complementary information for soil conservation planning. 38 39

Department of Agricultural Sciences (RU), University of Naples Federico II (IT)
Life on land
Soil erosion and sediment transport
AI Navigator

Ask Laika to Summarize, Analyze, and Connect papers live on the map.

Summarize Papers & Methodologies

Extract key findings, datasets, and comparative methods across publications.

Benchmark Rankings & Visual Analytics

Rank top research institutions, authors, funders, topics, and journals by Field-Weighted Citation Impact (FWCI) and paper volume with instant charts.

Connect Distant Disciplines

Bridge topological clusters on the map to find hidden collaborative intersections.

Laika access coming soon