Evaluation of the bearing capacity of a pavement subgrade using elastic back-calculation based on deflection measurements: the concept of apparent modulus

This article investigates the evaluation of pavement subgrade bearing capacity using elastic back-calculation based on deflection measurements, with a particular focus on the concept of apparent modulus. The study reviews current practices and analytical models, such as Westergaard and Burmister multilayer approaches, as well as static and dynamic measurement methods including plate loading tests, deflectograph, Benkelman beam, and Falling Weight Deflectometer (FWD). It highlights the inconsistencies observed between historical deformation moduli (EV2, Mr) and back-calculated values, as well as between static (Benkelman Beam, Deflectograph Lacroix) and FWD measurement results. The research identifies key factors contributing to these discrepancies and proposes practical methodologies to improve the evaluation of subgrade elastic modulus, considering systemic differences in measurement interpretation and extending the FWD method to the characterisation of bearing capacity of stabilised subgrades. The findings aim to support more accurate assessment of existing road infrastructure conditions, ensuring their suitability for future traffic demands.Abbreviations: AASHTO: American Association of State Highway and Transportation Officials; APRON: Airport apron / aircraft parking; CEREMA: French Center for Studies and Expertise on Risks, Environment, Mobility and Planning; COST: European Cooperation in Science and Technology; D02: Lacroix deflectograph type 02 – referring to the type of measuring and loading associated; D03: Lacroix deflectograph type 03 – referring to the type of measuring and loading associated; D04: Lacroix deflectograph type 04 – referring to the type of measuring and loading associated; DC: Corrected deflection, after geometric corrections linked to the measurement system; DIS_T: Discrete translational element used in Code_Aster; DIS_TR: Discrete translational and rotational element used in Code_Aster; DX: Displacement or degree of freedom along the X direction; DY: Displacement or degree of freedom along the Y direction; DZ: Displacement or deflection along the Z direction; absolute vertical deflection before correction; Edyn: Dynamic modulus measured using a dynamic plate test; EF: Referring to Finite Element method; EF_WINK_ELAS: Finite element model developed for this study combining an elastic slab and a Winkler foundation; EV2: Static deformation modulus measured by static plate loading test; FAA: Federal Aviation Administration; FLASH: Flash deflectograph – referring to the type of measuring and loading associated; FWD: Falling Weight Deflectometer; GB-3: Bituminous base course – class 3; GTR: French technical guide for designing capping layer and embankment; GTS: French technical guide for designing treated capping layer with hydraulic binder; HWD: Heavy Weight Deflectometer; IDRRIM: French Institute to Promote methodologies and guidance in the road and infrastructure sector; INFRALAB: Swiss pavement survey Laboratory involved in the VSS research report related to deflexion surveys with Benkelman beam and FWD equipment; JUM: Reference isolated half twin-tires axle – theoretical type of loading for pavement design; LCPC: Former French public research institute for civil engineering; currently UGE: University Gustave Eiffel; LPC: Laboratoires des Ponts et Chaussées – Currently attached to CEREMA; MEL: Multilayer Elastic Linear Model (Burmister type); MEL-1: Multilayer Elastic Linear model used for FWD back-calculation; MEL-2: Multilayer elastic model used for static deflection simulations or back-calculations; MEPDG: Mechanistic-Empirical Pavement Design Guide; Mr: Resilient Modulus; NF: Referring to French standard; PARASOL: Code or modelling approach used for soil-structure interaction with reaction moduli in Code Aster; PB: Benkelman Beam Test – referring to the type of measuring and loading associated; PF: Referring to the level of the capping layer bearing capacity: PF2, PF3, … according to the French standards; PV: Test report; RGRA: Revue Générale des Routes et de l’Aménagement – French technical journal on linear transport infrastructures; SETRA / Sétra: Service d’études techniques des routes et autoroutes – Currently attached to CEREMA; STAC: French Civil Aviation Technical Services; STBA: French Air Base Technical Services – Currently STAC; VSS: Swiss Association of Road and Transport Professionals

Authors

Institutions

Publication Details

Journal
Road Materials and Pavement Design
Published
2026-11-16
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1080/14680629.2026.2761038
Primary Topic
Geotechnical and construction materials studies
Type
article
Field-Weighted Citation Impact
0.00
Controls
|||
ALL TIME
JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
OCT
NOV
article

Evaluation of the bearing capacity of a pavement subgrade using elastic back-calculation based on deflection measurements: the concept of apparent modulus

Alan Ezaoui, Jean-Maurice Balay, M. Masdan
Road Materials and Pavement Design
Geotechnical and construction materials studies
article

Evaluation of the bearing capacity of a pavement subgrade using elastic back-calculation based on deflection measurements: the concept of apparent modulus

Alan Ezaoui, Jean-Maurice Balay, M. Masdan
article en

Abstract

This article investigates the evaluation of pavement subgrade bearing capacity using elastic back-calculation based on deflection measurements, with a particular focus on the concept of apparent modulus. The study reviews current practices and analytical models, such as Westergaard and Burmister multilayer approaches, as well as static and dynamic measurement methods including plate loading tests, deflectograph, Benkelman beam, and Falling Weight Deflectometer (FWD). It highlights the inconsistencies observed between historical deformation moduli (EV2, Mr) and back-calculated values, as well as between static (Benkelman Beam, Deflectograph Lacroix) and FWD measurement results. The research identifies key factors contributing to these discrepancies and proposes practical methodologies to improve the evaluation of subgrade elastic modulus, considering systemic differences in measurement interpretation and extending the FWD method to the characterisation of bearing capacity of stabilised subgrades. The findings aim to support more accurate assessment of existing road infrastructure conditions, ensuring their suitability for future traffic demands.Abbreviations: AASHTO: American Association of State Highway and Transportation Officials; APRON: Airport apron / aircraft parking; CEREMA: French Center for Studies and Expertise on Risks, Environment, Mobility and Planning; COST: European Cooperation in Science and Technology; D02: Lacroix deflectograph type 02 – referring to the type of measuring and loading associated; D03: Lacroix deflectograph type 03 – referring to the type of measuring and loading associated; D04: Lacroix deflectograph type 04 – referring to the type of measuring and loading associated; DC: Corrected deflection, after geometric corrections linked to the measurement system; DIS_T: Discrete translational element used in Code_Aster; DIS_TR: Discrete translational and rotational element used in Code_Aster; DX: Displacement or degree of freedom along the X direction; DY: Displacement or degree of freedom along the Y direction; DZ: Displacement or deflection along the Z direction; absolute vertical deflection before correction; Edyn: Dynamic modulus measured using a dynamic plate test; EF: Referring to Finite Element method; EF_WINK_ELAS: Finite element model developed for this study combining an elastic slab and a Winkler foundation; EV2: Static deformation modulus measured by static plate loading test; FAA: Federal Aviation Administration; FLASH: Flash deflectograph – referring to the type of measuring and loading associated; FWD: Falling Weight Deflectometer; GB-3: Bituminous base course – class 3; GTR: French technical guide for designing capping layer and embankment; GTS: French technical guide for designing treated capping layer with hydraulic binder; HWD: Heavy Weight Deflectometer; IDRRIM: French Institute to Promote methodologies and guidance in the road and infrastructure sector; INFRALAB: Swiss pavement survey Laboratory involved in the VSS research report related to deflexion surveys with Benkelman beam and FWD equipment; JUM: Reference isolated half twin-tires axle – theoretical type of loading for pavement design; LCPC: Former French public research institute for civil engineering; currently UGE: University Gustave Eiffel; LPC: Laboratoires des Ponts et Chaussées – Currently attached to CEREMA; MEL: Multilayer Elastic Linear Model (Burmister type); MEL-1: Multilayer Elastic Linear model used for FWD back-calculation; MEL-2: Multilayer elastic model used for static deflection simulations or back-calculations; MEPDG: Mechanistic-Empirical Pavement Design Guide; Mr: Resilient Modulus; NF: Referring to French standard; PARASOL: Code or modelling approach used for soil-structure interaction with reaction moduli in Code Aster; PB: Benkelman Beam Test – referring to the type of measuring and loading associated; PF: Referring to the level of the capping layer bearing capacity: PF2, PF3, … according to the French standards; PV: Test report; RGRA: Revue Générale des Routes et de l’Aménagement – French technical journal on linear transport infrastructures; SETRA / Sétra: Service d’études techniques des routes et autoroutes – Currently attached to CEREMA; STAC: French Civil Aviation Technical Services; STBA: French Air Base Technical Services – Currently STAC; VSS: Swiss Association of Road and Transport Professionals

Road Materials and Pavement Design
Université Gustave Eiffel (FR)
Geotechnical and construction materials studies
AI Navigator

Ask Laika to Summarize, Analyze, and Connect papers live on the map.

Summarize Papers & Methodologies

Extract key findings, datasets, and comparative methods across publications.

Benchmark Rankings & Visual Analytics

Rank top research institutions, authors, funders, topics, and journals by Field-Weighted Citation Impact (FWCI) and paper volume with instant charts.

Connect Distant Disciplines

Bridge topological clusters on the map to find hidden collaborative intersections.

Laika access coming soon