EVALUASI FORMATIF BUKU PANDUAN PERSONALIZED LEARNING BERBASIS AI TERINTEGRASI LMS

ABSTRACT The study produced a findings matrix and proposed revisions to learning profiles, attendance tutorials, incident forms, the allocation of responsibilities, and quality indicators. The study employs document analysis during the initial formative evaluation phase of a design-based research project. The corpus comprises the development proposal, the initial version of the guide, and three review reports covering language, quality management, and educational technology/LMS operations. The scores and comments within the review reports represent AI-generated suggestions that have not yet been verified through independent expert assessment. The analysis links review items, problem locations, corrective actions, and verification requirements. Mathematical reconstruction of the scores yields mean indices of 0.500 for language, 0.521 for quality management, and 0.500 for educational technology/LMS. Item B2 was excluded because it evaluated Indonesian language usage in an English-language guide. These indices serve as descriptive summaries of the suggested scores and do not establish content validity. Revision priorities include document consistency, navigation, accessibility, resources, menu instructions, recovery mechanisms, and compatibility. The study produced a findings matrix and proposed revisions to the guide for learning profiles, attendance tutorials, incident forms, authority allocation, and quality indicators. Independent expert assessment and verification of revisions are required before determining readiness for pilot testing; the practicality and learning effectiveness have not yet been tested. ABSTRAK Penelitian ini bertujuan mengidentifikasi ketidaksesuaian isi dan prosedur dalam buku panduan personalized learning berbasis Artificial Intelligence (AI) terintegrasi Learning Management System (LMS) serta menyusun rancangan revisinya. Kajian menggunakan analisis dokumen pada tahap evaluasi formatif awal penelitian pengembangan berbasis desain. Korpus mencakup proposal pengembangan, panduan versi pertama, dan tiga berkas telaah bidang bahasa, manajemen mutu, serta teknologi pendidikan dan operasional LMS. Skor dan komentar dalam berkas telaah merupakan usulan berbantuan AI yang belum dikonfirmasi melalui penilaian ahli secara mandiri; keduanya dianalisis sebagai isi dokumen, bukan sebagai data penilaian ahli. Analisis menghubungkan butir telaah, lokasi masalah, tindakan koreksi, dan kebutuhan bukti verifikasi. Rekonstruksi matematis skor menghasilkan rerata indeks 0,500 untuk bahasa, 0,521 untuk manajemen mutu, dan 0,500 untuk teknologi pendidikan–LMS. Butir B2 dikeluarkan karena menilai bahasa Indonesia pada panduan berbahasa Inggris. Indeks tersebut merupakan ringkasan deskriptif skor usulan dan tidak membuktikan validitas isi. Prioritas revisi mencakup konsistensi dokumen, navigasi, aksesibilitas, sumber daya, petunjuk menu, pemulihan, dan kompatibilitas. Kajian menghasilkan matriks temuan serta rancangan perbaikan profil belajar, tutorial presensi, formulir insiden, pembagian kewenangan, dan indikator mutu. Penilaian ahli independen serta verifikasi revisi diperlukan sebelum kesiapan uji coba ditetapkan; kepraktisan dan efektivitas pembelajaran belum diuji.

Authors

Institutions

Publication Details

Journal
EDUTECH Jurnal Inovasi Pendidikan Berbantuan Teknologi
Published
2026-11-17
DOI
https://doi.org/10.51878/edutech.v6i4.16379
Primary Topic
Educational Technology and E-Learning
Type
article
Field-Weighted Citation Impact
0.00
Controls
|||
ALL TIME
JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
OCT
NOV
article

EVALUASI FORMATIF BUKU PANDUAN PERSONALIZED LEARNING BERBASIS AI TERINTEGRASI LMS

Yulita Molliq Rangkuti, Hutkemri Zulnaidi, Abdurrahman Adisaputera, Eddiyanto Eddiyanto et al.
3 links
EDUTECH Jurnal Inovasi Pendidikan Berbantuan Teknologi
Educational Technology and E-Learning
article

EVALUASI FORMATIF BUKU PANDUAN PERSONALIZED LEARNING BERBASIS AI TERINTEGRASI LMS

Yulita Molliq Rangkuti, Hutkemri Zulnaidi, Abdurrahman Adisaputera, Eddiyanto Eddiyanto, Amirrudin Bin Kamsin
article en

Abstract

ABSTRACT The study produced a findings matrix and proposed revisions to learning profiles, attendance tutorials, incident forms, the allocation of responsibilities, and quality indicators. The study employs document analysis during the initial formative evaluation phase of a design-based research project. The corpus comprises the development proposal, the initial version of the guide, and three review reports covering language, quality management, and educational technology/LMS operations. The scores and comments within the review reports represent AI-generated suggestions that have not yet been verified through independent expert assessment. The analysis links review items, problem locations, corrective actions, and verification requirements. Mathematical reconstruction of the scores yields mean indices of 0.500 for language, 0.521 for quality management, and 0.500 for educational technology/LMS. Item B2 was excluded because it evaluated Indonesian language usage in an English-language guide. These indices serve as descriptive summaries of the suggested scores and do not establish content validity. Revision priorities include document consistency, navigation, accessibility, resources, menu instructions, recovery mechanisms, and compatibility. The study produced a findings matrix and proposed revisions to the guide for learning profiles, attendance tutorials, incident forms, authority allocation, and quality indicators. Independent expert assessment and verification of revisions are required before determining readiness for pilot testing; the practicality and learning effectiveness have not yet been tested. ABSTRAK Penelitian ini bertujuan mengidentifikasi ketidaksesuaian isi dan prosedur dalam buku panduan personalized learning berbasis Artificial Intelligence (AI) terintegrasi Learning Management System (LMS) serta menyusun rancangan revisinya. Kajian menggunakan analisis dokumen pada tahap evaluasi formatif awal penelitian pengembangan berbasis desain. Korpus mencakup proposal pengembangan, panduan versi pertama, dan tiga berkas telaah bidang bahasa, manajemen mutu, serta teknologi pendidikan dan operasional LMS. Skor dan komentar dalam berkas telaah merupakan usulan berbantuan AI yang belum dikonfirmasi melalui penilaian ahli secara mandiri; keduanya dianalisis sebagai isi dokumen, bukan sebagai data penilaian ahli. Analisis menghubungkan butir telaah, lokasi masalah, tindakan koreksi, dan kebutuhan bukti verifikasi. Rekonstruksi matematis skor menghasilkan rerata indeks 0,500 untuk bahasa, 0,521 untuk manajemen mutu, dan 0,500 untuk teknologi pendidikan–LMS. Butir B2 dikeluarkan karena menilai bahasa Indonesia pada panduan berbahasa Inggris. Indeks tersebut merupakan ringkasan deskriptif skor usulan dan tidak membuktikan validitas isi. Prioritas revisi mencakup konsistensi dokumen, navigasi, aksesibilitas, sumber daya, petunjuk menu, pemulihan, dan kompatibilitas. Kajian menghasilkan matriks temuan serta rancangan perbaikan profil belajar, tutorial presensi, formulir insiden, pembagian kewenangan, dan indikator mutu. Penilaian ahli independen serta verifikasi revisi diperlukan sebelum kesiapan uji coba ditetapkan; kepraktisan dan efektivitas pembelajaran belum diuji.

EDUTECH Jurnal Inovasi Pendidikan Berbantuan TeknologiVol. 6(4)
State University of Medan (ID), Universitas Sumatera Utara (ID), University of Malaya (MY)
Quality education
Educational Technology and E-Learning
AI Navigator

Ask Laika to Summarize, Analyze, and Connect papers live on the map.

Summarize Papers & Methodologies

Extract key findings, datasets, and comparative methods across publications.

Benchmark Rankings & Visual Analytics

Rank top research institutions, authors, funders, topics, and journals by Field-Weighted Citation Impact (FWCI) and paper volume with instant charts.

Connect Distant Disciplines

Bridge topological clusters on the map to find hidden collaborative intersections.

Laika access coming soon