Sodomy’s Golden Age: Sex, Race and Citizenship in the Seventeenth-Century Dutch Empire (1600-1730)

This dissertation complicates how current Dutch scholarship has ceded the concept of sodomy to contemporary legal discourses that inaugurated sodomy as a marker of homosexual identity. Contrary to established scholarship on sodomy as a socio-political category of social control since at least the tenth century in the English, French, and Spanish empires, Dutch histories of sodomy have centered on the 1730 sodomy trials as the inaugural moment of modern homosexual identity, with the implicit assumption that sodomy was of little concern to the Republic before these prosecutions. Sodomy’s Golden Age recovers the range of early modern meanings associated with sodomy, especially in its relation to race and empire, and shows that the category of sodomy functioned as a multifaceted discourse that was contingent on the intersections of gender, sexuality, race, class, language, memory, and place. The dissertation argues that these significations of sodomy amalgamate into a cluster of transgressions that demonstrate a neologism: sodomitical assemblages. The cartographic orientation of the dissertation also forms an assemblage of the Dutch Republic’s three constituent urban centers in the early modern period: Amsterdam—the economic and political center, New Amsterdam (New York), and the Cape of Good Hope at the Cape Colony (Cape Town). The analysis embodies a transoceanic and transtemporal framework to grapple with the multiple sites of sodomy’s signification in the Dutch empire. The dissertation theorizes the concept of transoceanic geographies to underscore the argument that these colonized geographies were not isolated but existed as a networked series of geopolitical and cultural influences on the Republic. The six chapters are organized to chronicle the significance of the colonies to the development of the Dutch empire. The first chapter is concerned with the Atlantic littoral as a productive site of maritime expansion in the empire. Chapters Two and Three focus on the Cape of Good Hope and offer a critical intervention in Atlantic and Indian ocean slavery studies by focusing on the West African people who were trafficked to the settlement in the first decade of the outpost’s existence. Chapters Four and Five explore the symbolic understandings of sodomy in the colony of New Amsterdam and the modern city of New York by reevaluating modern interpretations of the infamous case of sodomy against the Dutch settler, Harmen van den Bogaert, who was accused of the crime of sodomy on his enslaved servant, Tobias, an African boy. The concluding chapter reads Jessie Burton’s The Miniaturist, a historical fiction set in the seventeenth-century Dutch Republic, and explores the gendered representations of sodomy in the novel. The dissertation’s arguments form part of ongoing critical interventions by scholars invested in broadening and historicizing the social, cultural, and geographical boundaries of early modern Europe. The analysis focuses on the men, women, children, and colonial geographies that have been excluded from contemporary arguments in the history of sexuality about the Netherlands and its empire in the seventeenth century.

Authors

Publication Details

Journal
Rutgers University Community Repository (Rutgers University)
Published
2026-11-17
DOI
https://doi.org/10.7282/t3-4617-ex25
Primary Topic
Medieval and Early Modern Justice
Type
article
Field-Weighted Citation Impact
0.00
Controls
|||
ALL TIME
JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
OCT
NOV
article

Sodomy’s Golden Age: Sex, Race and Citizenship in the Seventeenth-Century Dutch Empire (1600-1730)

Thato Magano
1 links
Rutgers University Community Repository (Rutgers University)
Medieval and Early Modern Justice
article

Sodomy’s Golden Age: Sex, Race and Citizenship in the Seventeenth-Century Dutch Empire (1600-1730)

Thato Magano
article en

Abstract

This dissertation complicates how current Dutch scholarship has ceded the concept of sodomy to contemporary legal discourses that inaugurated sodomy as a marker of homosexual identity. Contrary to established scholarship on sodomy as a socio-political category of social control since at least the tenth century in the English, French, and Spanish empires, Dutch histories of sodomy have centered on the 1730 sodomy trials as the inaugural moment of modern homosexual identity, with the implicit assumption that sodomy was of little concern to the Republic before these prosecutions. Sodomy’s Golden Age recovers the range of early modern meanings associated with sodomy, especially in its relation to race and empire, and shows that the category of sodomy functioned as a multifaceted discourse that was contingent on the intersections of gender, sexuality, race, class, language, memory, and place. The dissertation argues that these significations of sodomy amalgamate into a cluster of transgressions that demonstrate a neologism: sodomitical assemblages. The cartographic orientation of the dissertation also forms an assemblage of the Dutch Republic’s three constituent urban centers in the early modern period: Amsterdam—the economic and political center, New Amsterdam (New York), and the Cape of Good Hope at the Cape Colony (Cape Town). The analysis embodies a transoceanic and transtemporal framework to grapple with the multiple sites of sodomy’s signification in the Dutch empire. The dissertation theorizes the concept of transoceanic geographies to underscore the argument that these colonized geographies were not isolated but existed as a networked series of geopolitical and cultural influences on the Republic. The six chapters are organized to chronicle the significance of the colonies to the development of the Dutch empire. The first chapter is concerned with the Atlantic littoral as a productive site of maritime expansion in the empire. Chapters Two and Three focus on the Cape of Good Hope and offer a critical intervention in Atlantic and Indian ocean slavery studies by focusing on the West African people who were trafficked to the settlement in the first decade of the outpost’s existence. Chapters Four and Five explore the symbolic understandings of sodomy in the colony of New Amsterdam and the modern city of New York by reevaluating modern interpretations of the infamous case of sodomy against the Dutch settler, Harmen van den Bogaert, who was accused of the crime of sodomy on his enslaved servant, Tobias, an African boy. The concluding chapter reads Jessie Burton’s The Miniaturist, a historical fiction set in the seventeenth-century Dutch Republic, and explores the gendered representations of sodomy in the novel. The dissertation’s arguments form part of ongoing critical interventions by scholars invested in broadening and historicizing the social, cultural, and geographical boundaries of early modern Europe. The analysis focuses on the men, women, children, and colonial geographies that have been excluded from contemporary arguments in the history of sexuality about the Netherlands and its empire in the seventeenth century.

Rutgers University Community Repository (Rutgers University)
Medieval and Early Modern Justice
AI Navigator

Ask Laika to Summarize, Analyze, and Connect papers live on the map.

Summarize Papers & Methodologies

Extract key findings, datasets, and comparative methods across publications.

Benchmark Rankings & Visual Analytics

Rank top research institutions, authors, funders, topics, and journals by Field-Weighted Citation Impact (FWCI) and paper volume with instant charts.

Connect Distant Disciplines

Bridge topological clusters on the map to find hidden collaborative intersections.

Laika access coming soon