Unpacking the politics of STI governance in emerging and transition economies

Purpose This paper aims to examine how ideational orientations toward strategic autonomy and cooperative openness enter science, technology and innovation (STI) governance across fifteen selected national STI systems, and how these orientations are associated with different implementation configurations. While existing literature largely attributes implementation gaps to institutional or financial weaknesses, the ideational layer of governance remains less explicitly examined. The study addresses this narrower gap without treating political orientation as an independent cause of STI outcomes. Design/methodology/approach The study develops a four-dimensional governance heuristic spanning sovereignty-oriented and cooperation-oriented profiles: openness to external cooperation, knowledge sharing, multilateral engagement and stakeholder breadth. The framework is applied through a qualitative comparison of 15 purposively selected national STI systems. Country positions are derived from a structured interpretation of official strategies, policy reports and contextual evidence. K-means clustering and principal component analysis are then used as an exploratory illustration of how these qualitative positions coexist with R&D intensity, patenting and institutional quality. Findings The comparison identifies recurring but nonuniform associations between governance orientation and implementation patterns. Singapore and Korea combine cooperation-oriented profiles with strong institutional and technological capacity, while India, Brazil and South Africa display more uneven configurations. Centralized and sovereignty-oriented systems also vary substantially, indicating that orientation alone is insufficient to account for STI performance. The exploratory clustering broadly reflects some of these configurations, but the small sample and moderate separation prevent statistical validation. The quantitative results are therefore used only to visualize possible relationships among orientation, institutional capacity and selected STI indicators. Originality/value This paper contributes by making the ideational orientation of STI governance explicit and operational within cross-national comparison. Rather than treating the Realist–Liberal distinction as a fixed taxonomy of political regimes, it develops a multidimensional heuristic for examining how national STI systems configure openness to external cooperation, knowledge circulation, multilateral engagement and stakeholder participation. The framework complements established institutional and political-economy explanations by examining how these orientations coexist with different governance choices and implementation configurations. Its empirical contribution is exploratory: it identifies configurations and anomalous cases that can inform further research in comparative foresight and innovation governance.

Authors

Institutions

Publication Details

Journal
foresight
Published
2026-11-18
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1108/fs-12-2025-0289
Primary Topic
Research, Science, and Academia
Type
article
Field-Weighted Citation Impact
0.00
Controls
|||
ALL TIME
JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
OCT
NOV
article

Unpacking the politics of STI governance in emerging and transition economies

Reza Hafezi
foresight
Research, Science, and Academia
article

Unpacking the politics of STI governance in emerging and transition economies

Reza Hafezi
article en

Abstract

Purpose This paper aims to examine how ideational orientations toward strategic autonomy and cooperative openness enter science, technology and innovation (STI) governance across fifteen selected national STI systems, and how these orientations are associated with different implementation configurations. While existing literature largely attributes implementation gaps to institutional or financial weaknesses, the ideational layer of governance remains less explicitly examined. The study addresses this narrower gap without treating political orientation as an independent cause of STI outcomes. Design/methodology/approach The study develops a four-dimensional governance heuristic spanning sovereignty-oriented and cooperation-oriented profiles: openness to external cooperation, knowledge sharing, multilateral engagement and stakeholder breadth. The framework is applied through a qualitative comparison of 15 purposively selected national STI systems. Country positions are derived from a structured interpretation of official strategies, policy reports and contextual evidence. K-means clustering and principal component analysis are then used as an exploratory illustration of how these qualitative positions coexist with R&D intensity, patenting and institutional quality. Findings The comparison identifies recurring but nonuniform associations between governance orientation and implementation patterns. Singapore and Korea combine cooperation-oriented profiles with strong institutional and technological capacity, while India, Brazil and South Africa display more uneven configurations. Centralized and sovereignty-oriented systems also vary substantially, indicating that orientation alone is insufficient to account for STI performance. The exploratory clustering broadly reflects some of these configurations, but the small sample and moderate separation prevent statistical validation. The quantitative results are therefore used only to visualize possible relationships among orientation, institutional capacity and selected STI indicators. Originality/value This paper contributes by making the ideational orientation of STI governance explicit and operational within cross-national comparison. Rather than treating the Realist–Liberal distinction as a fixed taxonomy of political regimes, it develops a multidimensional heuristic for examining how national STI systems configure openness to external cooperation, knowledge circulation, multilateral engagement and stakeholder participation. The framework complements established institutional and political-economy explanations by examining how these orientations coexist with different governance choices and implementation configurations. Its empirical contribution is exploratory: it identifies configurations and anomalous cases that can inform further research in comparative foresight and innovation governance.

foresight
Iran National Science Foundation (IR), National Research Institute for Science Policy (IR)
Peace, justice, and strong institutions, Industry, innovation and infrastructure
Research, Science, and Academia
AI Navigator

Ask Laika to Summarize, Analyze, and Connect papers live on the map.

Summarize Papers & Methodologies

Extract key findings, datasets, and comparative methods across publications.

Benchmark Rankings & Visual Analytics

Rank top research institutions, authors, funders, topics, and journals by Field-Weighted Citation Impact (FWCI) and paper volume with instant charts.

Connect Distant Disciplines

Bridge topological clusters on the map to find hidden collaborative intersections.

Laika access coming soon