Contextualizing the role of mobula rays in household ‘food security’ and what it means for conservation in East Flores, Indonesia

Abstract Elasmobranch conservation increasingly invokes concerns about ‘food security’, yet the term is often applied without a clear theoretical framework or empirical underpinning. This study addresses this gap by first exploring relevant theories of food security, then applying appropriate theory and methods to empirically examine the role of mobula rays ( Mobula spp.) in the food security of fisheries‐dependent households in East Flores, Indonesia, and exploring the implications for mobula conservation. Drawing on Sen's entitlement framework and experience‐based food security tools, we combine surveys ( N = 57), unstructured interviews ( N = 7), participant observation and a community meeting ( N = 34) across three coastal villages: Labelen, Lamawai and Watanhura. Our results showed that while 53% of respondents ( N = 30) considered mobula rays an important food source, 90% ( N = 51) indicated a preference for other protein sources if available, suggesting that mobula rays do not constitute a primary dietary staple. The inconsistent availability of mobula ray meat further limits any direct contribution to household diets. Nevertheless, applying Sen's entitlement theory reveals two indirect roles: mobula ray fisheries generate ‘trade‐based entitlements’ through net income (IDR 190,000–600,000; USD 11–35) per ray, which households use to purchase other food items; and an overlapping ‘labor‐and‐trade’ entitlement pathway, whereby households obtain food through barter, in which mobula ray meat is exchanged for root crops, fruits and other desired foods. Beyond these entitlement pathways, respondents attributed episodes of food insecurity to income volatility, exposure to natural disasters, health‐related challenges and socio‐cultural obligations that compound financial vulnerability. Our findings also suggest that conservation may be possible; however, interventions need to combine principles of perceived and procedural fairness to actively and meaningfully account for communities' aspirations and livelihood realities, thereby opening possibilities for meaningful conservation outcomes. Read the free Plain Language Summary for this article on the Journal blog.

Authors

Institutions

Publication Details

Journal
People and Nature
Published
2026-11-16
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1002/pan3.70482
Primary Topic
Ichthyology and Marine Biology
Type
article
Field-Weighted Citation Impact
0.00
Controls
|||
ALL TIME
JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
OCT
NOV
article

Contextualizing the role of mobula rays in household ‘food security’ and what it means for conservation in East Flores, Indonesia

Edy Topan, Rafid A. Shidqi, Yodhikson M. Bang, Hollie Booth
People and Nature
Ichthyology and Marine Biology
article

Contextualizing the role of mobula rays in household ‘food security’ and what it means for conservation in East Flores, Indonesia

Edy Topan, Rafid A. Shidqi, Yodhikson M. Bang, Hollie Booth
article en

Abstract

Abstract Elasmobranch conservation increasingly invokes concerns about ‘food security’, yet the term is often applied without a clear theoretical framework or empirical underpinning. This study addresses this gap by first exploring relevant theories of food security, then applying appropriate theory and methods to empirically examine the role of mobula rays ( Mobula spp.) in the food security of fisheries‐dependent households in East Flores, Indonesia, and exploring the implications for mobula conservation. Drawing on Sen's entitlement framework and experience‐based food security tools, we combine surveys ( N = 57), unstructured interviews ( N = 7), participant observation and a community meeting ( N = 34) across three coastal villages: Labelen, Lamawai and Watanhura. Our results showed that while 53% of respondents ( N = 30) considered mobula rays an important food source, 90% ( N = 51) indicated a preference for other protein sources if available, suggesting that mobula rays do not constitute a primary dietary staple. The inconsistent availability of mobula ray meat further limits any direct contribution to household diets. Nevertheless, applying Sen's entitlement theory reveals two indirect roles: mobula ray fisheries generate ‘trade‐based entitlements’ through net income (IDR 190,000–600,000; USD 11–35) per ray, which households use to purchase other food items; and an overlapping ‘labor‐and‐trade’ entitlement pathway, whereby households obtain food through barter, in which mobula ray meat is exchanged for root crops, fruits and other desired foods. Beyond these entitlement pathways, respondents attributed episodes of food insecurity to income volatility, exposure to natural disasters, health‐related challenges and socio‐cultural obligations that compound financial vulnerability. Our findings also suggest that conservation may be possible; however, interventions need to combine principles of perceived and procedural fairness to actively and meaningfully account for communities' aspirations and livelihood realities, thereby opening possibilities for meaningful conservation outcomes. Read the free Plain Language Summary for this article on the Journal blog.

People and Nature
Duke University (US)
Ichthyology and Marine Biology
AI Navigator

Ask Laika to Summarize, Analyze, and Connect papers live on the map.

Summarize Papers & Methodologies

Extract key findings, datasets, and comparative methods across publications.

Benchmark Rankings & Visual Analytics

Rank top research institutions, authors, funders, topics, and journals by Field-Weighted Citation Impact (FWCI) and paper volume with instant charts.

Connect Distant Disciplines

Bridge topological clusters on the map to find hidden collaborative intersections.

Laika access coming soon