Improved Knee Function and Activity Levels After Circumferential Repair Versus Partial Meniscectomy for Horizontal Cleavage Meniscus Tears: A Minimum 2‐Year Propensity‐Matched Comparative Study

PURPOSE: To evaluate and compare patient-reported outcome measures between 2 propensity-matched cohorts of patients undergoing circumferential repair and partial meniscectomy for isolated meniscal horizontal cleavage tears (HCTs) and compare return to sport (RTS) characteristics between groups at a minimum 2-year follow-up. METHODS: A retrospective study identified patients with isolated meniscal HCTs undergoing circumferential repair between 2015 and 2022 at a single academic institution. Patients undergoing circumferential repair were propensity-matched to a partial meniscectomy cohort 1:1 by age, sex, body mass index, knee laterality, and meniscus laterality. Patient-reported outcome measures, including International Knee Documentation Committee (IKDC), Tegner activity scale, and visual analog scale scores, and RTS data were collected at a minimum 2-year follow-up and analyzed. Failures were defined as knee reoperations or significant symptoms that required additional intervention. RESULTS: In total, 32 patients (69% men; 66% right knees; 50% lateral menisci; mean age 31 ± 13 years) underwent circumferential repair for isolated meniscal HCTs. At an average follow-up of 5.0 years (range 2.1-8.7 years), failures occurred in 3 (13%) circumferential repair and 5 (22%) partial meniscectomy patients (P = .700). The circumferential repair cohort showed significantly greater IKDC (82.0 vs 44.7; P < .001) and Tegner scores (6.2 vs 4.7; P = .046) compared with the partial meniscectomy cohort. In total, 27 patients (60%) played sports preoperatively, and RTS was achieved in 16 (84%) circumferential repair and 7 (88%) partial meniscectomy patients (P > .999), with 15 (94%) and 5 (71%) returning at the same or higher level, respectively. CONCLUSIONS: Patients who underwent circumferential repair of meniscal HCTs yielded significantly higher knee function (IKDC) and activity levels (Tegner) at an average follow-up of 5.0 years compared with propensity-matched partial meniscectomy controls. Circumferential repair was also associated with more patients achieving reported Patient Acceptable Symptom State thresholds for IKDC compared with partial meniscectomy. The all-cause failure and RTS rates were similar between groups. LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: Level III, retrospective cohort study.

Authors

Institutions

Publication Details

Journal
Arthroscopy The Journal of Arthroscopic and Related Surgery
Published
2026-11-17
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1002/arj.70711
Primary Topic
Knee injuries and reconstruction techniques
Type
article
Field-Weighted Citation Impact
0.00
Controls
|||
ALL TIME
JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
OCT
NOV
article

Improved Knee Function and Activity Levels After Circumferential Repair Versus Partial Meniscectomy for Horizontal Cleavage Meniscus Tears: A Minimum 2‐Year Propensity‐Matched Comparative Study

Adam J. Tagliero, Sanathan Iyer, Bruce A. Levy, Aaron John Krych et al.
2 links
Arthroscopy The Journal of Arthroscopic and Related Surgery
Knee injuries and reconstruction techniques
article

Improved Knee Function and Activity Levels After Circumferential Repair Versus Partial Meniscectomy for Horizontal Cleavage Meniscus Tears: A Minimum 2‐Year Propensity‐Matched Comparative Study

Adam J. Tagliero, Sanathan Iyer, Bruce A. Levy, Aaron John Krych, Gavin H. Ward, Christopher L. Camp, Jason G. Ina, Mario Hevesi
article en

Abstract

PURPOSE: To evaluate and compare patient-reported outcome measures between 2 propensity-matched cohorts of patients undergoing circumferential repair and partial meniscectomy for isolated meniscal horizontal cleavage tears (HCTs) and compare return to sport (RTS) characteristics between groups at a minimum 2-year follow-up. METHODS: A retrospective study identified patients with isolated meniscal HCTs undergoing circumferential repair between 2015 and 2022 at a single academic institution. Patients undergoing circumferential repair were propensity-matched to a partial meniscectomy cohort 1:1 by age, sex, body mass index, knee laterality, and meniscus laterality. Patient-reported outcome measures, including International Knee Documentation Committee (IKDC), Tegner activity scale, and visual analog scale scores, and RTS data were collected at a minimum 2-year follow-up and analyzed. Failures were defined as knee reoperations or significant symptoms that required additional intervention. RESULTS: In total, 32 patients (69% men; 66% right knees; 50% lateral menisci; mean age 31 ± 13 years) underwent circumferential repair for isolated meniscal HCTs. At an average follow-up of 5.0 years (range 2.1-8.7 years), failures occurred in 3 (13%) circumferential repair and 5 (22%) partial meniscectomy patients (P = .700). The circumferential repair cohort showed significantly greater IKDC (82.0 vs 44.7; P < .001) and Tegner scores (6.2 vs 4.7; P = .046) compared with the partial meniscectomy cohort. In total, 27 patients (60%) played sports preoperatively, and RTS was achieved in 16 (84%) circumferential repair and 7 (88%) partial meniscectomy patients (P > .999), with 15 (94%) and 5 (71%) returning at the same or higher level, respectively. CONCLUSIONS: Patients who underwent circumferential repair of meniscal HCTs yielded significantly higher knee function (IKDC) and activity levels (Tegner) at an average follow-up of 5.0 years compared with propensity-matched partial meniscectomy controls. Circumferential repair was also associated with more patients achieving reported Patient Acceptable Symptom State thresholds for IKDC compared with partial meniscectomy. The all-cause failure and RTS rates were similar between groups. LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: Level III, retrospective cohort study.

Arthroscopy The Journal of Arthroscopic and Related Surgery
Mayo Clinic (US), Orlando Health (US)
Good health and well-being
Knee injuries and reconstruction techniques
AI Navigator

Ask Laika to Summarize, Analyze, and Connect papers live on the map.

Summarize Papers & Methodologies

Extract key findings, datasets, and comparative methods across publications.

Benchmark Rankings & Visual Analytics

Rank top research institutions, authors, funders, topics, and journals by Field-Weighted Citation Impact (FWCI) and paper volume with instant charts.

Connect Distant Disciplines

Bridge topological clusters on the map to find hidden collaborative intersections.

Laika access coming soon