Detecting False Self-Consistency in Density-Functional Calculations
Density-functional calculations feed materials databases and machine-learning models, and are declared converged when energy changes and residuals fall below thresholds. We show that these criteria, and even the agreement of independent optimizers, can accept a state from which the energy still descends or whose Hamiltonian is inconsistent with the energy. A variational formulation of self-consistency in the space of Kohn-Sham Hamiltonians yields a descent probe that exposes lower states accessible from a returned solution, and a frozen-orbital Janak test detects such an inconsistency. Both apply to any code without modification. In VASP, a UO$_2$ PBE+$U$ calculation converges 1.46 eV above a lower state, and CoO and FeO converge as metals 0.8-0.9 eV above insulating states. In a census of 339 converged calculations on tungsten-free Materials Project structures, recomputed with a modified static protocol, 57 (16.8%) show energy decreases above the threshold, 49 without an initial energy rise exceeding the tolerance.
Authors
- Mohsen Sotoudeh (ORCID: https://orcid.org/0000-0002-0970-5336)
Publication Details
- Journal
- arXiv (Cornell University)
- Published
- 2026-11-16
- DOI
- https://doi.org/10.48550/arxiv.2611.20789
- Primary Topic
- Advanced Chemical Physics Studies
- Type
- preprint