Designing an augmented reality environment for students to explore electric fields: What worked, and what did not

We report on a retrospective analysis of design decisions that guided the development of an augmented reality (AR) environment to support undergraduate physics students’ reasoning about electric fields. This analysis addresses a gap in AR education research: most studies report whether an AR intervention worked, but not which specific design decisions drove that outcome and why. Using a discussion-based framework grounded in commognitive theory and situated learning perspectives, we examined how design decisions afforded or constrained students’ development of higher levels of disciplinary language and reasoning across three instructional sequences. We coded language sophistication at pivotal moments for 15 pairs of students working through electric field questions embedded in the AR environment, tracking the changes in disciplinary reasoning and word use. We then analyzed the relationship between the discussion patterns and specific creative decisions regarding artifact design and pedagogy. We found that AR’s educational value lies in the relationship between what the environment makes visible and what the instructional design scaffolds. Sequences that paired affordances (such as animations, 3D exploration) with explicit linguistic scaffolding (vocabulary, numerical values, targeted prompts) supported meaningful growth in argumentation. In fact, 87% of pairs increased levels of thinking during point charge exploration, and 93% during trajectory prediction questions. In contrast, a sequence offering rich visualization without linguistic support produced widespread regression (53% of pairs), as students reverted to visual descriptions rather than more in-depth physics when asked to articulate abstractions for which they lacked vocabulary. These findings extend prior work showing that making the invisible visible is necessary but not sufficient for educational AR development. This paper offers examples of what supported increases in how students talked about the environment and the concepts relating to properties of electric fields. We conclude with generalized design and instructional implications for educational AR environments.

Authors

Publication Details

Journal
Physical Review Physics Education Research
Published
2026-11-17
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1103/398r-xrxq
Primary Topic
Augmented Reality Applications
Type
article
Field-Weighted Citation Impact
0.00
Controls
|||
ALL TIME
JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
OCT
NOV
article

Designing an augmented reality environment for students to explore electric fields: What worked, and what did not

Dustin B. Thoman, Janet S. Bowers, Adrian Larios, India Wishart et al.
1 links
Physical Review Physics Education Research
Augmented Reality Applications
article

Designing an augmented reality environment for students to explore electric fields: What worked, and what did not

Dustin B. Thoman, Janet S. Bowers, Adrian Larios, India Wishart, Matthew E. Anderson, Elizabeth Flynn, Beau Green, Luke Anderson
article en

Abstract

We report on a retrospective analysis of design decisions that guided the development of an augmented reality (AR) environment to support undergraduate physics students’ reasoning about electric fields. This analysis addresses a gap in AR education research: most studies report whether an AR intervention worked, but not which specific design decisions drove that outcome and why. Using a discussion-based framework grounded in commognitive theory and situated learning perspectives, we examined how design decisions afforded or constrained students’ development of higher levels of disciplinary language and reasoning across three instructional sequences. We coded language sophistication at pivotal moments for 15 pairs of students working through electric field questions embedded in the AR environment, tracking the changes in disciplinary reasoning and word use. We then analyzed the relationship between the discussion patterns and specific creative decisions regarding artifact design and pedagogy. We found that AR’s educational value lies in the relationship between what the environment makes visible and what the instructional design scaffolds. Sequences that paired affordances (such as animations, 3D exploration) with explicit linguistic scaffolding (vocabulary, numerical values, targeted prompts) supported meaningful growth in argumentation. In fact, 87% of pairs increased levels of thinking during point charge exploration, and 93% during trajectory prediction questions. In contrast, a sequence offering rich visualization without linguistic support produced widespread regression (53% of pairs), as students reverted to visual descriptions rather than more in-depth physics when asked to articulate abstractions for which they lacked vocabulary. These findings extend prior work showing that making the invisible visible is necessary but not sufficient for educational AR development. This paper offers examples of what supported increases in how students talked about the environment and the concepts relating to properties of electric fields. We conclude with generalized design and instructional implications for educational AR environments.

Physical Review Physics Education Research
Quality education
Augmented Reality Applications
AI Navigator

Ask Laika to Summarize, Analyze, and Connect papers live on the map.

Summarize Papers & Methodologies

Extract key findings, datasets, and comparative methods across publications.

Benchmark Rankings & Visual Analytics

Rank top research institutions, authors, funders, topics, and journals by Field-Weighted Citation Impact (FWCI) and paper volume with instant charts.

Connect Distant Disciplines

Bridge topological clusters on the map to find hidden collaborative intersections.

Laika access coming soon