From safeguard to surveillance justification: The transformation of the right to be informed in ECtHR jurisprudence

This article examines the evolving function of the right to be informed in regulating workplace surveillance through a systematic analysis of the European Court of Human Rights’ case law. It asks whether workers’ prior information continues to operate as a meaningful safeguard against employer monitoring or whether its function within the Court's reasoning has progressively changed. While the Court continues formally to rely on the criterion established in Bărbulescu v Romania , a systematic examination of its subsequent case law reveals that workers’ information has lost much of its protective force. Once a safeguard whose absence weighed heavily against employers, information is increasingly treated as one criterion among others within the Court's proportionality assessment, readily outweighed by expanding managerial and property-based interests and, once formally satisfied, capable of supporting the very monitoring it was meant to constrain. The article traces this evolution through two interconnected developments. First, the circumstances in which employers may engage in covert surveillance have progressively broadened. Second, increasingly intrusive monitoring practices have been considered compatible with Article 8 despite limited, ambiguous, or delayed information being provided to workers. As a result, the threshold for complying with transparency obligations has gradually been reduced to a minimal notification requirement. Transparency therefore functions less as an autonomous safeguard protecting workers ex ante and increasingly as part of the Court's justificatory reasoning when assessing the compatibility of workplace surveillance with Article 8. On this basis, the article identifies a transformation in the legal function assigned to workers’ information. Prior information progressively ceases to operate as an ex ante constraint on monitoring and instead becomes one element within the Court's proportionality assessment capable of supporting its ex post justification. Workers’ information and transparency requirements, intended to mitigate structural power asymmetries in the employment relationship, may therefore contribute to legitimising workplace surveillance when reduced to formal transparency obligations. By reconstructing this jurisprudential evolution, the article offers a new explanation for the “ more surveillance approach ” identified in recent scholarship and shows that this development reflects a broader transformation in the Court's reasoning rather than a position confined to a limited number of cases. It further situates this evolution within a European and international regulatory landscape that increasingly reinforces transparency obligations and workers’ informational rights. Against this background, the article argues that the effectiveness of informational safeguards ultimately depends less on their formal recognition than on the weight courts are willing to accord them within their proportionality assessment. As new regulatory instruments reinforce transparency and participatory safeguards for workers, the Court may increasingly be called upon to restore the weight attributed to workers’ right to be informed of monitoring and the threshold of transparency expected from employers within Article 8 balancing.

Authors

Institutions

Publication Details

Journal
European Labour Law Journal
Published
2026-11-17
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1177/20319525261498423
Primary Topic
Legal and Labor Studies
Type
article
Field-Weighted Citation Impact
0.00
Controls
|||
ALL TIME
JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
OCT
NOV
article

From safeguard to surveillance justification: The transformation of the right to be informed in ECtHR jurisprudence

Maéva El Bouchikhi
1 links
European Labour Law Journal
Legal and Labor Studies
article

From safeguard to surveillance justification: The transformation of the right to be informed in ECtHR jurisprudence

Maéva El Bouchikhi
article en

Abstract

This article examines the evolving function of the right to be informed in regulating workplace surveillance through a systematic analysis of the European Court of Human Rights’ case law. It asks whether workers’ prior information continues to operate as a meaningful safeguard against employer monitoring or whether its function within the Court's reasoning has progressively changed. While the Court continues formally to rely on the criterion established in Bărbulescu v Romania , a systematic examination of its subsequent case law reveals that workers’ information has lost much of its protective force. Once a safeguard whose absence weighed heavily against employers, information is increasingly treated as one criterion among others within the Court's proportionality assessment, readily outweighed by expanding managerial and property-based interests and, once formally satisfied, capable of supporting the very monitoring it was meant to constrain. The article traces this evolution through two interconnected developments. First, the circumstances in which employers may engage in covert surveillance have progressively broadened. Second, increasingly intrusive monitoring practices have been considered compatible with Article 8 despite limited, ambiguous, or delayed information being provided to workers. As a result, the threshold for complying with transparency obligations has gradually been reduced to a minimal notification requirement. Transparency therefore functions less as an autonomous safeguard protecting workers ex ante and increasingly as part of the Court's justificatory reasoning when assessing the compatibility of workplace surveillance with Article 8. On this basis, the article identifies a transformation in the legal function assigned to workers’ information. Prior information progressively ceases to operate as an ex ante constraint on monitoring and instead becomes one element within the Court's proportionality assessment capable of supporting its ex post justification. Workers’ information and transparency requirements, intended to mitigate structural power asymmetries in the employment relationship, may therefore contribute to legitimising workplace surveillance when reduced to formal transparency obligations. By reconstructing this jurisprudential evolution, the article offers a new explanation for the “ more surveillance approach ” identified in recent scholarship and shows that this development reflects a broader transformation in the Court's reasoning rather than a position confined to a limited number of cases. It further situates this evolution within a European and international regulatory landscape that increasingly reinforces transparency obligations and workers’ informational rights. Against this background, the article argues that the effectiveness of informational safeguards ultimately depends less on their formal recognition than on the weight courts are willing to accord them within their proportionality assessment. As new regulatory instruments reinforce transparency and participatory safeguards for workers, the Court may increasingly be called upon to restore the weight attributed to workers’ right to be informed of monitoring and the threshold of transparency expected from employers within Article 8 balancing.

European Labour Law Journal
University of Lausanne (CH)
Peace, justice, and strong institutions, Decent work and economic growth
Legal and Labor Studies
AI Navigator

Ask Laika to Summarize, Analyze, and Connect papers live on the map.

Summarize Papers & Methodologies

Extract key findings, datasets, and comparative methods across publications.

Benchmark Rankings & Visual Analytics

Rank top research institutions, authors, funders, topics, and journals by Field-Weighted Citation Impact (FWCI) and paper volume with instant charts.

Connect Distant Disciplines

Bridge topological clusters on the map to find hidden collaborative intersections.

Laika access coming soon