When Time Refutes: Minimum Generation Length and Claims of Joint Hashemite Descent; Exclusion tests on the claimant clades under J-FGC11, from Hashim to 'Adnan

Abstract Descent claims in genetic genealogy usually rest on membership in named clusters, inheriting whatever identity the cluster was assigned. This paper proposes a chronological test that identifies no cluster with any ancestor: if two lineages descend patrilineally from one ancestor, their most recent common ancestor cannot predate him. Given the meeting age M, the reference-generation date T₀ and the generation count k, the data set a lower bound on mean generation length, g ≥ (M − T₀) ÷ k; above a declared ceiling of 35 years, joint descent is excluded. A declared rule draws the sides from public data: every clade under J-FGC11 no older than Hashim’s time in which a sample carries one of four descent names, yielding sixteen units, 75 records and 120 pairs. Exclusion at Hashim is guaranteed by this construction; the findings are the grades. Meeting ages are resolved under three published mutation rates; an exclusion is firm only at probability ≥ 0.95 under all three. Five units part from the rest about 2,900–3,100 years ago and are excluded at every rung from Hashim to ‘Adnan. The remaining eleven fall in four groups that part about 2,200 years ago and cannot share an ancestor from Hashim to Ghalib. Of the 120 pairs, 115 are firmly excluded at Hashim. Five are not: the three among J-ZS4753, J-BY258 and J-FGC11743 under J-FGC4302 (probable exclusion), and one pair each inside J-FGC7944 and J-KM2 (undecided). The test establishes no descent and does not locate where sides meet.

Authors

Publication Details

Journal
Research Square
Published
2026-11-17
DOI
https://doi.org/10.21203/rs.3.rs-11727955/v1
Primary Topic
Forensic and Genetic Research
Type
preprint
Controls
|||
ALL TIME
JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
OCT
NOV
preprint

When Time Refutes: Minimum Generation Length and Claims of Joint Hashemite Descent; Exclusion tests on the claimant clades under J-FGC11, from Hashim to 'Adnan

Sultan Faleh Alshaabi
Research Square
Forensic and Genetic Research
preprint

When Time Refutes: Minimum Generation Length and Claims of Joint Hashemite Descent; Exclusion tests on the claimant clades under J-FGC11, from Hashim to 'Adnan

Sultan Faleh Alshaabi
preprint en

Abstract

Abstract Descent claims in genetic genealogy usually rest on membership in named clusters, inheriting whatever identity the cluster was assigned. This paper proposes a chronological test that identifies no cluster with any ancestor: if two lineages descend patrilineally from one ancestor, their most recent common ancestor cannot predate him. Given the meeting age M, the reference-generation date T₀ and the generation count k, the data set a lower bound on mean generation length, g ≥ (M − T₀) ÷ k; above a declared ceiling of 35 years, joint descent is excluded. A declared rule draws the sides from public data: every clade under J-FGC11 no older than Hashim’s time in which a sample carries one of four descent names, yielding sixteen units, 75 records and 120 pairs. Exclusion at Hashim is guaranteed by this construction; the findings are the grades. Meeting ages are resolved under three published mutation rates; an exclusion is firm only at probability ≥ 0.95 under all three. Five units part from the rest about 2,900–3,100 years ago and are excluded at every rung from Hashim to ‘Adnan. The remaining eleven fall in four groups that part about 2,200 years ago and cannot share an ancestor from Hashim to Ghalib. Of the 120 pairs, 115 are firmly excluded at Hashim. Five are not: the three among J-ZS4753, J-BY258 and J-FGC11743 under J-FGC4302 (probable exclusion), and one pair each inside J-FGC7944 and J-KM2 (undecided). The test establishes no descent and does not locate where sides meet.

Research Square
Forensic and Genetic Research
AI Navigator

Ask Laika to Summarize, Analyze, and Connect papers live on the map.

Summarize Papers & Methodologies

Extract key findings, datasets, and comparative methods across publications.

Benchmark Rankings & Visual Analytics

Rank top research institutions, authors, funders, topics, and journals by Field-Weighted Citation Impact (FWCI) and paper volume with instant charts.

Connect Distant Disciplines

Bridge topological clusters on the map to find hidden collaborative intersections.

Laika access coming soon