PCCI™ Ishikawa Anamnesis A Framework for Structured and Mandatory Re-anamnesis in Clinical Diagnosis Companion paper to the ISWB Model — the anamnesis framework behind node v1, v2 and v4

Background. The ISWB model [1] places a mandatory re-anamnesis node (v4) after imaging, and names a structured six-branch anamnesis — the Ishikawa component of ISWB — as the method that feeds its nodes v1, v2 and v4. That method has not until now been described on its own. It is not new: it formalises a single practitioner's clinical anamnesis habit, refined over 49 years of neuroradiology practice, into a fixed set of six question branches that can be taught, audited and counted. Aim. To describe the PCCI™ Ishikawa anamnesis as a standalone framework — its six branches, where each is explored in the diagnostic pathway, and the mechanism by which a missed answer becomes a dated entry in a cause–effect dictionary — independently of the Bayesian formalism of ISWB, and to illustrate it with one retrospective case documented in the companion clinical annotation tool. Method. The anamnesis is organised as a fishbone (Ishikawa) diagram with six branches — patient factors, provocation and lifestyle, physical examination, past history, pathology and prior tests, and pharmacy and toxins — each carrying a short, fixed set of question types rather than an open interview. Five of the six branches are explored at the first encounter (node v1) and on examination (node v2); all six are re-explored after imaging, at the mandatory re-anamnesis node (v4). An answer obtained at v4 that was not obtained earlier is flagged as new information, together with one of five reasons for the omission. Flagged answers are the raw material of a cause–effect dictionary: a running, dated record of what is missed, how often, and why. Results. In the one case worked through in full (Section 5), the six-branch re-exploration at v4 surfaced one piece of information — a seated fall during a match — that none of the five branches had surfaced at v1 or v2, flagged as not volunteered by the patient. That single flagged answer raised the probability of the leading hypothesis from 0.70 to 0.92 and changed the management. The framework's other claims — a target redirection rate of 10–25%, and the branch taxonomy's coverage of the causes clinicians actually miss — are design targets stated in the companion guide [2], not yet measured prospectively. Conclusions. A fishbone that is fixed, short and re-asked after imaging turns anamnesis from an open conversation of variable quality into a countable, auditable step, and gives the ISWB model's node v4 a defined question set rather than a general instruction to “ask again”. The framework is a single-practitioner formalisation awaiting external replication; the dictionary it feeds has one entry so far.

Authors

Institutions

Publication Details

Journal
Zenodo (CERN European Organization for Nuclear Research)
Published
2026-11-17
DOI
https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24302182
Primary Topic
Clinical Reasoning and Diagnostic Skills
Type
preprint
Controls
|||
ALL TIME
JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
OCT
NOV
preprint

PCCI™ Ishikawa Anamnesis A Framework for Structured and Mandatory Re-anamnesis in Clinical Diagnosis Companion paper to the ISWB Model — the anamnesis framework behind node v1, v2 and v4

Francesco Matozza, Ernesto Matozza
1 links
Zenodo (CERN European Organization for Nuclear Research)
Clinical Reasoning and Diagnostic Skills
preprint

PCCI™ Ishikawa Anamnesis A Framework for Structured and Mandatory Re-anamnesis in Clinical Diagnosis Companion paper to the ISWB Model — the anamnesis framework behind node v1, v2 and v4

Francesco Matozza, Ernesto Matozza
preprint en

Abstract

Background. The ISWB model [1] places a mandatory re-anamnesis node (v4) after imaging, and names a structured six-branch anamnesis — the Ishikawa component of ISWB — as the method that feeds its nodes v1, v2 and v4. That method has not until now been described on its own. It is not new: it formalises a single practitioner's clinical anamnesis habit, refined over 49 years of neuroradiology practice, into a fixed set of six question branches that can be taught, audited and counted. Aim. To describe the PCCI™ Ishikawa anamnesis as a standalone framework — its six branches, where each is explored in the diagnostic pathway, and the mechanism by which a missed answer becomes a dated entry in a cause–effect dictionary — independently of the Bayesian formalism of ISWB, and to illustrate it with one retrospective case documented in the companion clinical annotation tool. Method. The anamnesis is organised as a fishbone (Ishikawa) diagram with six branches — patient factors, provocation and lifestyle, physical examination, past history, pathology and prior tests, and pharmacy and toxins — each carrying a short, fixed set of question types rather than an open interview. Five of the six branches are explored at the first encounter (node v1) and on examination (node v2); all six are re-explored after imaging, at the mandatory re-anamnesis node (v4). An answer obtained at v4 that was not obtained earlier is flagged as new information, together with one of five reasons for the omission. Flagged answers are the raw material of a cause–effect dictionary: a running, dated record of what is missed, how often, and why. Results. In the one case worked through in full (Section 5), the six-branch re-exploration at v4 surfaced one piece of information — a seated fall during a match — that none of the five branches had surfaced at v1 or v2, flagged as not volunteered by the patient. That single flagged answer raised the probability of the leading hypothesis from 0.70 to 0.92 and changed the management. The framework's other claims — a target redirection rate of 10–25%, and the branch taxonomy's coverage of the causes clinicians actually miss — are design targets stated in the companion guide [2], not yet measured prospectively. Conclusions. A fishbone that is fixed, short and re-asked after imaging turns anamnesis from an open conversation of variable quality into a countable, auditable step, and gives the ISWB model's node v4 a defined question set rather than a general instruction to “ask again”. The framework is a single-practitioner formalisation awaiting external replication; the dictionary it feeds has one entry so far.

Zenodo (CERN European Organization for Nuclear Research)
Fondation pour la Recherche Stratégique (FR), European Society of Radiology (AT), European Society of Cardiology (FR)
Good health and well-being
Clinical Reasoning and Diagnostic Skills
AI Navigator

Ask Laika to Summarize, Analyze, and Connect papers live on the map.

Summarize Papers & Methodologies

Extract key findings, datasets, and comparative methods across publications.

Benchmark Rankings & Visual Analytics

Rank top research institutions, authors, funders, topics, and journals by Field-Weighted Citation Impact (FWCI) and paper volume with instant charts.

Connect Distant Disciplines

Bridge topological clusters on the map to find hidden collaborative intersections.

Laika access coming soon