Binding school phone-ban laws change school rules with minimal short-run student outcome shifts
Can a law requiring school phone restrictions change school rules, how students use phones at school, and short-run student outcomes? This pre-registered cross-national difference-in-differences study uses PISA 2022–2025 repeated cross-sections for 28 newly legislating and 44 comparison systems. Binding legislation raised the school-reported restriction share by 19.2 percentage points (0.192; 90% CI [0.102, 0.283]). Where the optional ICT questionnaire was fielded, the share of students never or almost never using a smartphone at school rose by 10.8 percentage points in legislating systems and 1.5 points in comparison systems (exploratory description), although 14.9% in legislating systems still used one several times a day in 2025. Short-run outcome changes were small or inconclusive. The mathematics ITT was 0.013 SD (90% CI [−0.033, 0.060]), within the pre-specified ±0.07-SD bound under the maintained assumptions; belonging (0.019 SD) is fragile under the pre-registered trend-sensitivity rule; bullying (−0.068 SD; Holm-adjusted p = .089) is inconclusive. Because the first-stage effective F of 12.8 is below the pre-specified threshold, Anderson–Rubin confidence sets are reported. A significant immigrant-share placebo means outcome estimates are conditional associations, not unqualified causal effects. Legislation reached school rules and partly student behavior; the data exclude only large short-run mathematics changes.
Authors
- Kang Liu (ORCID: https://orcid.org/0009-0004-3214-505X)
Institutions
- Shandong Normal University (CN)
Publication Details
- Journal
- Zenodo (CERN European Organization for Nuclear Research)
- Published
- 2026-11-17
- DOI
- https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24304692
- Primary Topic
- School Choice and Performance
- Type
- preprint